There’s a darkest-before-the-dawn vibe around the once-dominant provincial party that’s spent eight years wandering the political wilderness.
asserted
that → ’ → wilderness
The Ontario Liberals’ campaign to select their next leader, for whom voting is now underway, has been a reminder of how far they’ve fallen since governing from 2003 through 2018.
asserted
they → select → 2018
The opportunity to lead a party stuck in third place proved resistible for several high-profile potential contenders who kicked the tires.
asserted
who → lead → tires
Another who wanted to run, then-MP Nate Erskine-Smith, made the mistake of seeking a provincial seat first and lost a chaotic local nomination battle that the party struggled to administer properly.
asserted
party → want → that
The four candidates who will cross the finish line this weekend — former federal minister Navdeep Bains, MPPs Lee Fairclough and Stephanie Bowman, and former political staffer Dylan Marando — have gamely traversed the province, visiting ridings where their party’s membership is sometimes in the single digits.
asserted
membership → cross → digits
Media coverage has been minimal, a far cry from when reporters would jockey to hear what premiers Dalton McGuinty or Kathleen Wynne had to say.
asserted
McGuinty → jockey → what
To the extent there’s been press, much of it has lamented how boring the race is.
asserted
race → lament → it
Having immersed myself in it, including sitting down with each candidate, I can understand that sentiment.
They all come across as nice people who don’t disagree about much.
asserted
who → immerse → much
And the two seen to have the best chance of winning — Bains, who entered as the presumptive front-runner, and Fairclough, who may have since outhustled him — have seemed allergic to saying much provocative.
uncertain
who → see → much
If you squint hard enough, however, you can also see signs of a party nearing a return to relevance — finally starting to reckon with its own failures, and with the fraught future facing this province and its younger generations.
But that’s a big if, contingent on whoever emerges from this contest proving capable of seizing an opportunity staring the party in its face — even if few others are paying attention to it yet.
asserted
others → squint → it
Ford government will be past its best before date
As ever in politics, part of that opportunity could involve being in the right place at the right time.
uncertain
part → involve → time
Lee Fairclough warns that Navdeep Bains’ lack of a Queen’s Park seat is a political handicap.
asserted
lack → warn → seat
Lee Fairclough warns that Navdeep Bains’ lack of a Queen’s Park seat is a political handicap.
asserted
lack → warn → seat
When the next provincial election campaign rolls around, likely in 2029, Ford’s government will probably be more than a decade old — past the best before date when many governments struggle to overcome baggage they’ve accumulated.
asserted
they → roll → baggage
And lingering public negativity toward the McGuinty-Wynne governments, which overstayed their welcome, has likely dissipated.
asserted
which → linger → welcome
“I don’t think there’s much of a brand problem left,” Abacus Data’s David Coletto told me, pointing to polling by his company that shows the Liberals with the most accessible voters — the percentage of the electorate at least open to casting a ballot for them — among Ontario’s parties.
asserted
that → think → parties
The next campaign will probably be waged under better circumstances for them than the last one in 2025, which Ford called right after Donald Trump had retaken office, making it tough for then-leader Bonnie Crombie — or her NDP counterpart, Marit Stiles — to break through the noise.
asserted
Crombie → wag → noise
Because the Liberals won enough seats in that election to get back official party status, their next leader also won’t have the same disadvantages as Crombie (or her predecessor, Steven Del Duca) in terms of lacking staff and other resources.
asserted
leader → win → staff
Still, it’s hard to understate how much rebuilding work awaits that person.
asserted
work → ’ → person
Candidates all see the need to do things differently
The Liberals have struggled to adapt to an era in which old communication methods no longer work and political volunteerism is down.
asserted
volunteerism → see → which
The grassroots were increasingly neglected during their time in government, Del Duca (not helped by the pandemic coinciding with his leadership) couldn’t invigorate them, and Crombie was perceived as aloof, with limited enthusiasm for talking to riding-level Liberals in pubs and church basements.
asserted
Crombie → neglect → pubs
This is where the leadership race has offered the most cause to feel bullish about the party turning a corner, even though candidates’ sign-up efforts still left it with an underwhelming membership of about 55,000 people.
asserted
efforts → offer → people
Individually, the contenders have made a decent case for their party-building chops.
asserted
contenders → make → chops
Bains, for instance, did some organizational heavy lifting for Justin Trudeau to help rebuild a moribund federal Liberal party, and has lived up to his reputation as a good fundraiser by leading the leadership pack in donations.
asserted
Bains → do → donations
Fairclough has an unflashy willingness to pound the pavement, reflected in spending years working the ground in her Etobicoke riding before winning in the last election.
asserted
Fairclough → have → election
Collectively, they seem to have recognized the need to do things differently at the ground level.
asserted
they → seem → level
That includes choosing riding candidates soon after the leadership through open nominations to build local teams, rather than waiting until the last minute to parachute in candidates.
asserted
That → include → candidates
Bains has much backing from former federal colleagues, and Fairclough is the closest thing to a provincial-establishment candidate.
asserted
Fairclough → have → candidate
But they’ve all tried to show distance from operatives who ran things in the McGuinty and Wynne eras, and who’ve been lingering around recent campaigns despite some sense in the party that they’ve lost their fastballs.
asserted
they → try → fastballs
It’s been enough to encourage critics.
asserted
It → encourage → critics
Noah Parker, who co-founded New Leaf Liberals — a group dedicated to modernizing their party that was active in ousting Crombie — said he’s feeling more optimistic than before the race started.
asserted
race → co → Crombie
But even if the party apparatus proves readier to engage Ontarians than it’s been in a while, it will still need a compelling vision to sell — for which the possible answers are less obvious, but more intriguing.
asserted
answers → prove → which
Marando pushes generational change
To my eyes, and those of many Liberal insiders I spoke with, Marando — who entered with no public profile and has a slim chance of winning because of a modest campaign organization — has been the strongest performer in the candidates’ debates.
asserted
who → push → debates
That’s partly because he’s a sharp communicator, but also because the youngest candidate in the race makes a generational argument that taps into millennial and Gen Z frustrations.
asserted
that → ’ → frustrations
His platform leads with public education, a weakness of Ford’s government and often a perceived Liberal strength, by which he means pre-kindergarten through post-secondary.
asserted
he → lead → secondary
It also goes in unexpected directions — from eliminating income tax on the first $50,000 earned annually by people 35 and under, to an outright ban on online gambling because of its corrosive social impact.
asserted
It → go → impact
(Most of the other candidates propose just ending online gambling ads.)
asserted
Most → propose → ads
When I sat down with him, Marando talked at length about worries for young families — upward mobility, housing, affordability, public services — being worse than for past generations.
asserted
Marando → sit → generations
“How can our political parties find a way to turn the anxiety of folks in their twenties and thirties and forties into optimism and constructive political action?” he said.
asserted
he → find → optimism
“Whoever figures that out is going to be doing a great service to their political movement, their economy and the social fabric of the community they live in.”
asserted
they → figure → community
…and 22 more, not listed.