Ontario Liberals are about to make one of the most consequential decisions in the party’s recent history.
asserted
Liberals → make → history
After eight years in opposition, two failed leadership tenures and three consecutive Doug Ford majority governments, members will next Saturday choose the politician they believe can finally return the party to power.
That challenge hangs over a recent Thursday night meet-and-greet at Wychwood Barns on Christie Street.
asserted
challenge → fail → Street
The choices abound.
asserted
choices → abound → ?
At an hour when most 9-to-5ers are sitting down to dinner, about 200 members of Ontario’s third-place party are gathered to size up the contenders.
asserted
members → sit → contenders
The task: watch the hopefuls pitch their ideas, maybe squeeze in a quick chat afterward, and rank the candidates from first to fourth for next Saturday’s leadership vote.
asserted
hopefuls → watch → vote
Mindful that the last two Liberal leaders flamed out, members feel the weight of their decision even more this time as insiders and rivals alike joke about putting a “revolving door” on the office.
asserted
insiders → flame → office
Stephanie Bowman and Navdeep Bains pledged a tax freeze while Lee Fairclough and Dylan Marando talked tax reform at Wednesday night’s debate.
asserted
Fairclough → pledge → debate
Stephanie Bowman and Navdeep Bains pledged a tax freeze while Lee Fairclough and Dylan Marando talked tax reform at Wednesday night’s debate.
asserted
Fairclough → pledge → debate
This is a party that regularly places second in public opinion polls behind Ford’s Progressive Conservatives but has been unable to close the deal with voters at election time.
asserted
that → place → time
“The issue is electability — who can broaden the Liberal tent?” says Susanne Boggild, one of more than 55,000 party members eligible to cast ballots online during 12 days of voting that end Friday at 5 p.m.
“The thing I want to do tonight is clinch my number one.”
asserted
I → broaden → number
For Cathy Miller, who admits to voting Tory in the past, there are two key criteria for the person who will get the top spot on her ballot: fiscal responsibility and a place in the legislature.
asserted
who → admit → legislature
“None of these candidates are well-known to the public.
asserted
None → know → public
It’s an uphill battle for all of them,” she says candidly in the long, narrow meeting hall that is barely one-third full.
asserted
that → ’ → hall
“Having a seat helps.”
asserted
Having → have → seat
On that front, two candidates do and two don’t.
asserted
two → do → front
Given that Ford has never faced a full-time Liberal leader in the legislature, it’s an issue that keeps popping up in the party’s third leadership race since 2020.
asserted
that → give → 2020
By way of comparison, the New Democrats have had three new leaders in the last 30 years and the PCs three since 2009.
“It’s not super high on my priority list,” Shannon Spencer says of the notion the leader should represent a riding, noting she is more driven by ideas in the candidates’ platforms.
asserted
she → have → platforms
That’s why she came to the old TTC streetcar barn on an unseasonably warm night in November.
asserted
she → ’ → November
“It’s one thing to read their stuff online.
asserted
It → ’ → stuff
It’s another thing to meet them.”
asserted
It → ’ → them
Standing nearby as a server proffers a tray of shrimp, David Campbell insists the new leader must have a seat to do battle with Ford in question period at Queen’s Park, gaining valuable experience, confidence and media exposure before the next provincial election.
asserted
leader → stand → election
“We’re clueing into that now.
asserted
We → clue → that
It’s important,” he says.
asserted
he → ’ → ?
“It gives you a lot more credibility.”
asserted
It → give → credibility
At this point, the candidates are lining up to take the stage shortly after 7 p.m. for quick remarks before people start heading home to kids, dogs or that night’s NFL tilt featuring the Baltimore Ravens.
asserted
people → line → Ravens
Like the Liberals, the team has been struggling without a first-string quarterback.
asserted
team → struggle → quarterback
Since the race began in earnest last spring, they have been fighting for attention amid a string of federal and provincial byelections, the Trump tariff war, U.S. midterm elections and municipal elections across Ontario.
asserted
they → begin → Ontario
Observers point out a lack of tension and drama has kept the contest below the radar for the general public as candidates play it safe to court each other’s followers for support on the second ballot and beyond.
asserted
candidates → point → ballot
“No sparks,” former PC leader Tim Hudak told the Star before the second of three leadership debates, none of which saw any candidates take the gloves off.
asserted
candidates → tell → gloves
While Bains and Fairclough are widely considered the front-runners, the predictive betting site Polymarket put the odds of victory at 72 per cent for Fairclough versus a 27 per cent shot for Bains as of Friday afternoon at 3 p.m.
asserted
site → consider → p.m.
The odds fluctuate.
asserted
odds → fluctuate → ?
Bains is by far the biggest fundraiser in the race with $808,456, according to Elections Ontario’s real-time disclosure site, which tracks donations of at least $200.
uncertain
which → accord → 200
He is followed by Fairclough, at $564,306, and Bowman, at $507,229.
asserted
He → follow → 507,229
Marando is a distant fourth at $190,869, having run a shoestring campaign that included driving his 16-year-old Subaru around the province, tenting in provincial parks and shaving at picnic tables during the warmer months.
asserted
that → run → months
Each has paid a $150,000 entry free.
asserted
Each → pay → entry
But as the Beatles sang, money can’t buy you love.
asserted
money → sing → love
The last two Liberal leaders, Vaughan Mayor (and York Region chair) Steven Del Duca and former Mississauga mayor Bonnie Crombie, resigned after failing to win seats on their home turf in the 2022 and 2025 elections, respectively.
asserted
leaders → resign → elections
“We can’t keep doing this one-and-done leader thing,” a party veteran laments.
asserted
veteran → keep → thing
He is one of several to cite “leadership fatigue” for the low-key state of the race.
asserted
He → cite → race
The vibe at Wychwood Barns is that the party needs to choose a boss with staying power this time, however he or she brings it.
“I want to make sure we select a leader who can really stand up,” says Natasha Doyle-Merrick, a recent convert.
asserted
Merrick → need → leader
…and 28 more, not listed.