After flipping several key state legislatures and gubernatorial seats in this month’s elections, Democrats now have a path to nullify an institution of U.S. elections that has cost the party at least two presidential contests so far this century: the Electoral College.
asserted
that → flip → contests
Officially abolishing that longstanding system, in which presidents are selected via slates of electors representing each state rather than by a direct popular vote, would require a constitutional amendment.
asserted
presidents → abolish → amendment
But it could effectively be neutralized if enough states join a pledge known as the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact.
uncertain
states → neutralize → Compact
U.S. Takes Step Closer to Popular Vote for Presidential Elections as Virginia Joins Compact
asserted
Virginia → take → Compact
For this to be achieved, the compact’s member-states would need to account for at least 270 electoral votes, the majority needed to secure the presidency.
asserted
states → achieve → presidency
Over the past two decades, 18 Democratic-led states and the District of Columbia, collectively representing 222 electoral votes, have already signed on.
asserted
states → lead → votes
And Democrats won control in enough additional states in the midterms to put the 270-vote threshold within reach—if they choose to go for it.
asserted
they → win → it
Here’s what to know about the compact, and how it could change the future of U.S. elections if it goes into effect.
uncertain
it → know → effect
The National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is an agreement among states to assign their electoral votes to the presidential candidate who wins the national popular vote.
asserted
who → assign → vote
This would mark a significant change in the current electoral system.
asserted
This → mark → system
Presently, almost every U.S. state allocates all of its electors to the candidate who wins the most votes in that state.
asserted
who → allocate → state
As a result of that “winner take all” approach and the disparity between states’ shares of the nation’s voters and electoral votes, a candidate is able to win the presidency even if they have lost the nationwide popular vote.
asserted
they → take → vote
This has happened five times in U.S. history, most recently when Donald Trump lost the popular vote to Hillary Clinton but won the Electoral College in 2016.
asserted
Trump → happen → 2016
Another instance occurred earlier this century, in 2000, when George W. Bush won the presidency but lost the popular vote to Al Gore.
asserted
Bush → occur → Gore
The compact, in contrast, aims to ensure that whoever wins the most votes across the country also wins the White House.
asserted
wins → aim → House
The idea for states to coordinate to circumvent the Electoral College and adopt a national popular vote system in such a way arose in the aftermath of that contentious 2000 election.
asserted
states → coordinate → election
In 2001, brothers Akhil Amar, a professor at Yale Law School, and Vikram Amar, a professor at the University of California Davis Law School, wrote an article that laid out something similar to the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact, which was created roughly five years later, in 2006.
asserted
which → write → 2006
Eighteen states—including California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, Virginia, and Washington—have since agreed to join the compact, as well as Washington D.C.
Together, these pact members make up 222 of the 270 electoral vote majority needed to elect a president.
asserted
members → include → president
The compact will take effect only if its membership collectively reaches that 270-vote mark.
asserted
membership → take → mark
In order for a state to join the compact, it needs to pass legislation through both chambers of its legislature.
asserted
it → join → legislature
The governor then needs to sign the legislation for it to become law—or, if they refuse to do so, the state legislature needs to marshal a supermajority to overturn a gubernatorial veto and enact the measure.
asserted
legislature → need → measure
How Democrats’ midterms wins could enable them to circumvent the Electoral College
In the midterm elections earlier this month, Democrats gained so-called “trifectas”—in which a single party controls both chambers of the state legislature and the governorship—in five additional states: Pennsylvania, Michigan, Arizona, Wisconsin, and Nevada.
uncertain
party → enable → states
Together, those states account for 61 electoral votes, which would be more than enough to put the compact over the required threshold for it to take effect if they agree to sign on.
asserted
they → account → effect
In fact, the pledge could reach the required majority of electoral votes even if just four of those five states join—as long as Pennsylvania, with 19 electoral votes, and Michigan—with 15—are among the four.
uncertain
Michigan → reach → four
Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro said “the national popular vote makes sense” while speaking on the “Pod Save America” podcast this month, and added that he would “work with lawmakers to figure out what the right mechanism is for moving forward on that.”
asserted
mechanism → say → that
Incoming Michigan Senate Majority Leader Darrin Camilleri meanwhile told POLITICO that he is open to adopting a national popular vote system, but acknowledged that enacting it would lead to legal GOP pushback.
“Other states that have done this are not going to be the tipping-point states.
asserted
that → income → this
We very well could be one of those tipping point-states, and so I want to ensure that everybody is on the same page,” Camilleri said.
uncertain
Camilleri → tip → page
The constitutionality of the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact is a matter of contention, and if enacted, it would likely face legal challenges, legal experts tell TIME.
asserted
experts → enact → TIME
Lawrence Lessig, a professor at Harvard Law School, says that the compact is “clearly permissible” under the Constitution, which he asserts “plainly meant to give to state legislatures the power to decide how to allocate their electors.”
asserted
he → say → electors
Opponents of the compact, however, believe that it violates another part of the Constitution called the “compact clause,” explains Jennifer Hendricks, a law professor at the University of Colorado Boulder.
asserted
Hendricks → believe → Colorado
That clause, she says, was designed to prevent “states getting together in a way that threatens the supremacy of the federal government.”
asserted
that → say → government
But like Lessig, Hendricks herself does not believe the compact meets the bar for unconstitutionally challenging the federal government’s authority.
asserted
compact → believe → authority
“That's not a problem here, because this is clearly a matter for the states under the Constitution,” Hendricks tells TIME.
asserted
Hendricks → tell → TIME
“The federal government is not involved in deciding how to pick electors for the Electoral College.”
asserted
government → involve → College
How would the compact impact presidential elections?
asserted
compact → impact → elections
If it were to take effect, the compact would make the nationwide popular vote decisive in presidential elections.
asserted
vote → take → elections
But the impact of that change would go beyond the final act of crowning a winner, experts tell TIME.
asserted
experts → go → TIME
Shifting to a popular vote system would “fundamentally change the dynamic of running for president” by leveling the playing field of every state, Lessig says.
asserted
Lessig → shift → state
Currently, “every single election, candidates are focused on the swing states and not focused on the rest of the country, and that's an injustice,” he says.
asserted
he → focus → country
If the compact were adopted, in contrast, “you would go from a nine state strategy to a 51 jurisdiction strategy.”
asserted
you → adopt → strategy
…and 14 more, not listed.