Legal pressure is building up against Customs and Border Protection (CBP) for its practice of seizing American citizens' electronics without a warrant.
asserted
pressure → build → warrant
Last week, Judge Leonie M. Brinkema ruled that the agency was improperly hiding what it did to nurse Muhammad Numaan Imam's electronics.
asserted
it → rule → electronics
A few days later, Judge Allison D. Burroughs ruled that CBP was likely retaliating against lawyer Andrew Lattarulo by searching his phone.
asserted
CBP → rule → phone
For years, CBP has claimed the absolute authority to look through all travelers' electronic data as part of its routine search for contraband at the border, where Fourth Amendment privacy protections don't apply.
asserted
protections → claim → border
If travelers don't consent to give up their passwords, then agents can simply seize their devices.
asserted
agents → consent → devices
But the Supreme Court appears interested in hearing a challenge to the electronic border searches, and lower courts also seem increasingly annoyed with the border agency's attitude.
asserted
courts → appear → attitude
Lattarulo co-owns the law firm Georges Cote LLP, which takes on both personal injury and immigration cases.
asserted
which → co → cases
Last year, while returning from vacation, he passed through CBP preclearance in Aruba, which allows travelers to "cross" the border before stepping onto a plane to America.
asserted
travelers → return → America
But at the domestic terminal in Boston Logan International Airport, three CBP officers and a Department of Homeland Security (DHS) agent pulled Lattarulo aside to seize his phone.
asserted
officers → pull → phone
The DHS mailed back Lattarulo's phone after downloading all of his data.
asserted
DHS → mail → data
Before it could decrypt the data, Lattarulo sued the government.
uncertain
Lattarulo → decrypt → government
The government claims that it seized Lattarulo's phone as part of an investigation into Georges Cote for illegally employing foreigners.
uncertain
it → claim → foreigners
She believes that the DHS is punishing Lattarulo for speaking out on immigrants' rights.
asserted
DHS → believe → rights
After all, law firm partner Audai Cote—who actually oversees employment compliance at the firm and who had received a request for information from the DHS three days earlier—passed through the same airport on the same day with no issue.
asserted
who → oversee → issue
The government "provided no evidence that searches of cellphones are frequently conducted during the kind of employment investigation at issue here," Burroughs wrote in a ruling on Friday.
asserted
Burroughs → provide → Friday
"The fact that the government, after Lattarulo spoke out publicly against it, elected to adopt a highly unusual investigative method that appears designed to inflict a maximal burden on Lattarulo lends substantial support to an inference that its actions were pretextual."
asserted
actions → speak → inference
Burroughs ordered the government not to decrypt Lattarulo's data while the case is being litigated.
asserted
case → order → data
She didn't immediately rule on Lattarulo's Fourth Amendment claims, but suggested that the government overstepped its bounds there, too.
uncertain
government → rule → bounds
"Based on the information before the Court, there appears to be no connection between Lattarulo's border crossing (or, more broadly, the government's interest in policing the border) and the suspected crime that formed the basis for the government's border search," she wrote.
asserted
she → base → search
At least the government gave a reason for searching Lattarulo.
asserted
government → give → Lattarulo
Imam, a psychiatric nurse practitioner from Virginia, has no idea why the CBP seized his electronics last month.
asserted
CBP → have → electronics
CBP officers at Washington-Dulles International Airport told Imam that he had been "flagged" for unnamed reasons during his return from a family vacation to Turkey.
asserted
he → tell → Turkey
They demanded his phone passwords, and Imam said that he legally couldn't hand them over, because his phone had communications with patients and case management software.
asserted
phone → demand → patients
"Your lawyer cannot do anything.
asserted
lawyer → do → anything
We are the authorities at the border," one of the officers told Imam before seizing all of his family's electronics, according to the lawsuit.
uncertain
one → tell → lawsuit
Imam sued, and the CBP immediately mailed back the electronics, without ever explaining what they were looking for.
asserted
they → sue → what
Brinkema, the judge, ordered the CBP to explain what it did to those electronics before sending them back.
asserted
it → order → them
The agency is now fighting to keep its answers sealed from both the public and Imam himself, arguing that they involve sensitive information about law enforcement tactics.
asserted
they → fight → tactics
"Nearly all of the information the defendants claim is privileged concerns what CBP does when it seizes electronic devices, which the government has routinely disclosed on the public record in other cases," Brinkema wrote in her Tuesday ruling.
uncertain
Brinkema → claim → ruling
"That the government has equipment they use to attempt to access and copy the data contained on cellphones and laptops should be of no great surprise to anyone, much less to those who may have something to hide."
uncertain
who → use → something
She gave the agency one more chance to demonstrate—by Tuesday this week—why she shouldn't unseal most of the information.
asserted
she → give → information
A day before the deadline, CBP asked for a two-day extension because "this Court's order requires coordination across multiple components of the Department of Homeland Security regarding sensitive law enforcement matters."
asserted
order → ask → matters
Although the courts have historically given the government a lot of deference at the border, CBP and other DHS agencies may be overstaying their welcome.
uncertain
CBP → give → welcome
Some of the government's pretexts for hassling travelers have been a little bit too thin, and the government's attempts to avoid giving information make it seem evasive.
asserted
it → hassle → information
Trying to seize lawyers' correspondence also raises attorney-client privacy issues beyond the Fourth Amendment—not to mention making a victim out of people that judges are far more likely to identify with.
asserted
judges → try → that
"In the past, the government has abused national security and law enforcement justifications to cover up corruption and dishonesty, and it's hard not to conclude that is what they are doing here," Jenin Younes, a lawyer for Imam, tells Reason.
asserted
Younes → abuse → Reason