What if Republicans are about to learn exactly the wrong lesson from this election?
asserted
Republicans → learn → election
Washington has a familiar ritual after an electoral defeat.
asserted
Washington → have → defeat
The losing party convenes a panel of experts, hires consultants, commissions research and emerges six months later with a new slogan and a 90-page PowerPoint explaining why voters have changed.
But what if voters haven't changed at all?
asserted
voters → lose → slogan
What if Democrats just won the 2016 election?
asserted
Democrats → win → election
In 2016, millions of Americans were fed up.
asserted
millions → feed → Americans
Tired of politicians telling them the economy was wonderful while their own finances suggested otherwise.
uncertain
finances → tire → them
They were tired of being called deplorable.
asserted
They → call → ?
Tired of watching the American Dream slip further out of reach.
asserted
Dream → tire → reach
And they were willing to blow up the political establishment to do something about it.
asserted
they → blow → it
Make America Great Again.
asserted
America → make → ?
Make life affordable again.
asserted
life → make → ?
It wasn't particularly complicated. It was a promise that ordinary Americans would finally come first.
asserted
Americans → come → ?
And they voted for it.
asserted
they → vote → it
Now, 10 years later, I wonder whether we're watching the same movie with a different cast.
asserted
we → wonder → cast
Republicans spent this election warning Americans about socialists, communists and radicals.
asserted
Republicans → spend → socialists
But what if those attacks landed the same way former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton's "basket of deplorables" did in 2016?
asserted
basket → land → 2016
What if voters are tired of being told they're stupid for wanting something different?
asserted
they → tell → something
In 2016, millions of Americans were fed up.
asserted
millions → feed → Americans
Tired of politicians telling them the economy was wonderful while their own finances suggested otherwise.
uncertain
finances → tire → them
And what if a person struggling to pay the grocery bill isn't especially concerned about whether the politician promising relief is a socialist?
asserted
politician → struggle → relief
Here's where things get uncomfortable.
asserted
things → get → ?
The voters really did reject parts of Trump's agenda.
asserted
voters → reject → agenda
Exit polls showed widespread opposition to his tariffs, his approach to immigration enforcement and military action against Iran.
asserted
polls → show → Iran
Many voters also wanted Congress to do more to check presidential power.
asserted
Congress → want → power
Republicans would be foolish to dismiss those concerns as a messaging problem.
asserted
Republicans → dismiss → problem
But Democrats would be equally foolish to mistake those votes for a sweeping ideological conversion.
asserted
Democrats → mistake → conversion
After all, roughly one in five Democratic voters in the AP Voter Poll had an unfavorable view of the Democratic Party.
asserted
voters → have → Party
It's more like agreeing to a second date because the other option was worse.
asserted
option → agree → date
What if it was a rejection of Republicans for failing to deliver on their own promises?
asserted
it → fail → promises
Trump promised an economy that worked for working Americans.
asserted
that → promise → Americans
A government that put Americans first.
asserted
that → put → Americans
In 2024, voters gave him another chance to deliver.
asserted
voters → give → chance
And in 2026, many appear to have decided they weren't getting what they signed up for.
asserted
they → appear → what
People didn't vote for tariffs because they wanted things to cost more.
asserted
things → vote → more
They voted for an economy that would make their lives better.
asserted
lives → vote → economy
They didn't vote to trade one foreign conflict for another.
asserted
They → vote → another
Many wanted America to stop fighting expensive wars.
asserted
America → want → wars
And they didn't vote for economic statistics.
asserted
they → vote → statistics
They voted for economic security.
asserted
They → vote → security
There's a difference between telling Americans the economy is booming and Americans feeling like they can afford their lives.
asserted
they → be → lives
…and 19 more, not listed.