On Tuesday night, the leaders of Victoria’s four most popular political parties gathered at Melbourne’s Sofitel Hotel to debate each other before next Saturday’s election.
asserted
leaders → gather → election
It is the only debate they have agreed to in this campaign, and few saw it.
asserted
few → agree → it
This is not a dig at News24, the cable news service which hosted the debate.
asserted
which → host → debate
It is not a crack at the leaders, who each put a good case for the things they believe in.
asserted
they → put → things
It is a lament that, on a rare occasion when political leaders in this state stood up and made a proper argument, the people who matter most – the people who will start voting in this state from Wednesday – were for the most part not watching.
asserted
who → stand → part
If they were, they would have seen Premier Ben Carroll, Opposition Leader Jess Wilson, One Nation leader Warren Pickering and Greens leader Ellen Sandell duking it out over a broad range of policy differences with a candour and passion you simply don’t get from manicured campaign events.
asserted
you → see → events
They didn’t leave their talking points at home – anyone playing a drinking game where you had to take a swig each time Carroll accused Wilson of wanting to Americanise the health system or Sandell railed against corporate donations would have been drunk before closing arguments.
asserted
Sandell → leave → arguments
Aside from that, they made clear where the parties stand and differ on education, on the Suburban Rail Loop, on energy policy, on protest permits, on fiscal management and debt reduction, and on health policy including whether Victoria, like South Australia, needs a minister dedicated to people who live with Autism.
asserted
who → make → Autism
We were also provided insight into the very different political personalities on stage – from Carroll’s careful, staccato messaging, to Wilson’s “just let me finish” knuckle-wrap on the three other leaders, to Sandell’s free-wheeling lambast against tech bros and “vampire” data centres, and Pickering’s eagerness to shiv whatever leader strayed into his range.
asserted
leader → provide → range
And then we had Billy, a lyrical curmudgeon from the audience with a grey ponytail and Santa Claus beard.
asserted
we → have → ponytail
“Nobody believes a word you’re saying any more,” he said to everyone in attendance while taking the scenic route to his question.
asserted
he → believe → question
“It’s fundamental – no fun and mostly mental.”
asserted
It → ’ → ?
Billy: “How will you increase transparency and accountability, so all Victorians can see that whatever mistakes are made, they’ll be dealt with in a trustworthy and honorable way?
asserted
they → increase → way
Because honorable should be removed from most politicians’ titles.”
asserted
honorable → remove → titles
Wilson: “Thanks Billy, I completely hear you...”
asserted
I → hear → you
One of the sharpest exchanges was on school funding, when Wilson exploited the premier’s discomfort over a decision taken when he was education minister to secretly cut $2.4 billion out of public schools.
asserted
he → exploit → schools
“How do you explain that?” she pressed.
asserted
she → explain → that
“Why weren’t you upfront with Victorians when you did it?”
asserted
you → do → it
Carroll’s response – that Labor over the past 12 years has delivered record funding to Victorian schools – while true, invited a withering retort from Sandell.
asserted
Labor → deliver → Sandell
The Greens leader pointed out that her grade three daughter will be close to finishing high school by 2034, the year that Victoria’s schools will become fully funded under the state’s agreement with Canberra.
asserted
schools → point → Canberra
If Carroll had no regard for cabinet confidentiality, he could have added that he was furious when his predecessor Jacinta Allan approved the secret funding cut and that he argued against it at the time.
uncertain
he → have → time
This is the rub for the premier and why he had the hardest job of anyone on stage.
asserted
he → have → stage
Throughout this debate, like the broader campaign, he had to straddle the best parts of Labor’s legacy while making a virtue of what he has junked since taking the top job.
asserted
he → have → job
It is an excruciating balancing act that nearly saw the premier become momentarily flustered when asked whether he was trying to wipe the memory of Daniel Andrews, Labour’s longest-serving Victorian premier, from the conscience of voters.
asserted
he → see → voters
“You can say his name, it’s OK,” Wilson teased.
asserted
Wilson → say → name
“I know I can, Jess.”
asserted
I → know → ?
Wilson: “It’s not Voldemort.”
asserted
It → ’ → ?
Carroll’s best moment was in his response to a direct question from Wilson, when she asked him why, in all the years he was a minister and deputy premier and party to decisions he didn’t support, he didn’t “speak up on behalf of Victorians”.
asserted
he → ask → Victorians
His forceful answer was that he had spoken up since becoming premier – on the need for a royal commission, on tougher crime policies and through the generous pay deal for teachers.
asserted
he → speak → teachers
“My history shows that I stand up when I need to,” he said.
asserted
he → show → ?
It is difficult to declare a winner in a four-way debate.
asserted
It → declare → debate
The more pressing question is whether each leader got what they needed from the Sofitel showdown.
asserted
they → get → showdown
Wilson needed to not make a howling mistake and didn’t.
asserted
Wilson → need → mistake
Pickering needed to show that One Nation will be able to mix it in the next parliament and did.
asserted
Nation → need → parliament
Although it can be said that News24 is a home game for any One Nation candidate, Pickering of all the leaders looked like he was enjoying the stoush.
asserted
he → say → stoush
Sandell understood she wasn’t debating for the sake of people watching News24 but general voters who, in the days to come, will be fed edited clips of the strongest lines delivered by the Greens leader.
asserted
who → understand → leader
She left the hotel with no shortage of material.
asserted
She → leave → material
Carroll came to the debate knowing that, with early voting due to start the next morning, Labor needs to produce something spectacular to avoid a rout on November 28.
asserted
Labor → come → November
True to Carroll’s nature, he fell short on that lofty measure but stood his ground.
asserted
he → fall → ground
Labor is facing an election day wipeout
- Hot seats: These One Nation voters are having second thoughts
- ‘Second opinion’: Wilson wants review of puberty blockers
- Unlikely voters: ‘Most of the Sri Lankan community are for One Nation’
asserted
Most → face → Nation