When Billy, one of 100 undecided voters, was asked if his question to four Victorian political leaders during last night's debate was answered, he replied, "Not really."
asserted
he → ask → debate
His question was about how politicians would rebuild trust with the public, but it could have been a response to many of those thrown at the Labor premier, Liberal opposition leader, Greens candidate and One Nation candidate.
uncertain
it → rebuild → premier
The News24/Herald-Sun debate never got deep into policy discussion between parties about their competing visions for the state.
asserted
debate → get → state
Instead, the parties mainly stuck to their policy talking points, with little critique or pushback on what their opponents were asserting.
asserted
opponents → stick → what
Candidates rattled off lists of achievements and what they want to do.
asserted
they → rattle → what
No-one knocked the debate out of the park.
asserted
one → knock → park
With four candidates on stage, all the parties will take something away from the night, and in most cases, it was survival.
asserted
it → take → cases
Premier Ben Carroll was less robotic than at his press conference and appeared more comfortable answering punters' questions.
asserted
Carroll → appear → questions
He didn't set the room on fire.
asserted
He → set → fire
His most difficult moment came when he was pressured about the Andrews and Allan governments he served under, especially the legacy of Daniel Andrews.
asserted
he → come → Andrews
It was a tough moment and he was reluctant to speak about it.
asserted
he → speak → it
"He's not Voldemort", Opposition LeaderJess Wilson chipped in from the side, encouraging him to say Andrews's name.
asserted
Wilson → chip → name
He challenged her to say Jeff Kennett.
asserted
He → challenge → Kennett
She didn't hesitate.
asserted
She → hesitate → ?
It was a moment of political theatre, but it underscores the difficulty Carroll faces every day.
asserted
Carroll → underscore → difficulty
He and Labor are being judged on 12 years in office.
asserted
He → judge → office
Carroll is unlikely to have won over many new voters from the debate; it was a chance to show off his "new direction", a task he never rose to, but he is unlikely to have lost any support either.
asserted
he → win → support
And in a Labor campaign that is increasingly trying to save as many seats as possible, that's almost a win for Labor.
asserted
that → try → Labor
Wilson came across as rehearsed, her lines familiar to those who watch politics every day.
asserted
who → come → politics
But she looked assured and calm, even if some of her answers raised more questions.
asserted
some → look → questions
With the finishing line in sight and polls showing the opposition is on track to win a majority, the Coalition has reached a critical stage where it can't afford to trip.
asserted
it → show → stage
The Liberals wanted her to come across as the adult in the room, as someone who was in control.
asserted
who → want → control
She largely nailed that brief without shining.
asserted
She → nail → brief
The focus would have been even more targeted on Labor's track record, rather than the four competing parties' ideas to solve Victoria's problems.
asserted
focus → compete → problems
The debate never got into deep policy detail.
But the discussion on energy was the trickiest waters for Wilson to navigate; she stressed that her party didn't care what the source of electricity was, as long as it was affordable and reliable.
asserted
it → get → electricity
One Nation's Warren Pickering asked her whether she backed Net Zero, a totemic issue for the party.
asserted
she → ask → party
After a few prods, Wilson said there would be no change to the state's pathway to that emissions goal.
asserted
Wilson → say → goal
It is exactly what Pickering wanted to hear.
asserted
Pickering → want → what
It is an issue that the party is increasingly drumming up ahead of polling centres opening today.
asserted
centres → drum → that
Going into the debate, Pickering loomed as a debate wildcard.
asserted
Pickering → go → wildcard
He has won many voters over with his direct, unpolished, anti-politician style.
asserted
He → win → style
If anything, he appeared a little more muted than normal, but he didn't give his opponents any "out-there" moments to ridicule One Nation's seriousness at this election.
The most surprising performance of the night came from the Greens' Ellen Sandell.
asserted
performance → appear → Sandell
Having been the third biggest presence in state parliament for years, the party has long argued it deserves a seat at these types of events.
asserted
it → argue → events
Sandell didn't waste the opportunity.
asserted
Sandell → waste → opportunity
She delivered the Greens' rhetoric (which was never going to appeal to many in the audience), but she stuck to her guns and stood out.
asserted
she → deliver → guns
She is unlikely to have lost any support over it, even in a tough room, and may have even made some new friends.
uncertain
She → lose → friends
After the debate, the undecided audience were asked to vote for a winner.
asserted
audience → ask → winner
It was grim for Carroll, with just 7 per cent backing him; Wilson was the clear winner on 39 per cent, with One Nation on 16 per cent and 13 per cent still undecided.
asserted
cent → back → cent
Sandell came second, winning 25 per cent of the room, a story in itself.
asserted
Sandell → come → itself
Will Tuesday night's People's Forum have much impact on the election?
asserted
Forum → have → election
…and 1 more, not listed.