A former Pentagon official warns that excessive regulation of artificial intelligence (AI) could harm U.S. competitiveness against China while benefiting large tech firms at the expense of smaller startups. Will Thibeau, who previously worked for both Palantir and the Pentagon, tells Fox News Digital that stringent AI regulations proposed by some "doomers" are overblown and could hinder innovation and economic growth. He advocates for a balanced approach that addresses specific risks without stifling technological advancement or giving China an upper hand in the global AI race.
Written by the local model on 2026-09-16,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Why this leaning score
The model judged this article politically coded and scored it +0.65, but 1 quote(s) could not be found in the article and the other 4 are attributed speech rather than the article's own narration, so the score is not published.
Written under an earlier scoring contract, which gave a paragraph
rather than checkable quotes. Re-analysing this article replaces it.
Leaning score withheld for article 13975: no verified evidence · logged 2026-09-16
"Doomer"-driven AI regulation could kneecap the U.S. against China while helping tech giants lock in their lead over smaller startups, a former Pentagon AI official who also worked for AI company Palantir Technologies told Fox News Digital.
uncertain
who → kneecap → Digital
The warning follows the resignation of an Anthropic researcher who said increasingly powerful AI could threaten humanity, while President Donald Trump called fears of rogue AI a "hoax" and compared those advancing such warnings to climate-change alarmists whose predictions, he argued, haven't come true.
uncertain
he → follow → alarmists
"The notion that I think the president and I share is that we should let the race play out, that the risk of global extinction is not real, it is in fact a hoax," Will Thibeau, a former Palantir deployment strategist who later worked in the Pentagon’s Chief Digital and Artificial Intelligence Office told Fox News Digital.
asserted
who → think → Digital
"The stakes of losing to China, of losing the opportunity to transform our economy, are so high that we shouldn't let 'doomerism' define public policy," the retired Army Ranger added.
asserted
Ranger → lose → policy
Thibeau’s position is not that Washington should take a hands-off approach to AI, but that the U.S. should race aggressively at the frontier while narrowly addressing concrete risks — threading the needle between denying China an advantage and preventing regulations backed by today’s leading AI firms from entrenching a "duopoly" at the expense of new American innovators.
"We must maintain an edge at the frontier, so our economy has the license on the first benefits of artificial intelligence.
asserted
economy → take → intelligence
Enhanced manufacturing capabilities, enhanced processing power, decision-making in financial markets," he said, disputing the idea that Beijing will not race full bore because the technology could countervail the CCP’s grip by incidentally empowering civilians.
uncertain
technology → say → civilians
"Artificial intelligence has the potential to redefine our economy and transform the country for the good," Thibeau said, while rejecting both predictions that it will make life "unrecognizable" and that it poses an uncontrollable "extinction" risk.
asserted
it → have → risk
Those "hyperventilating" over either extreme, he argued, miss the "clearly defined middle path" for AI development.
asserted
he → hyperventilate → development
Thibeau said some of AI’s most important applications are military, where it can process battlefield data quickly enough to give U.S. forces an advantage while helping preserve civilian life.
asserted
it → say → life
"I’m very bullish, if you will, on how artificial intelligence can be applied for the military," he said.
asserted
he → ’m → military
While Thibeau said fears of "drone swarms run amok" are not realistic, he acknowledged AI carries real risks that policymakers should address without allowing those concerns to justify sweeping rules that slow U.S. development or undermine its military edge.
asserted
that → say → edge
The larger danger, he argued, is that leading AI firms can absorb regulations that smaller newcomers cannot.
asserted
newcomers → argue → regulations
"There is a duopoly, perhaps a triopoly if you include Google," Thibeau said, naming Anthropic and OpenAI as the two companies clearly in the lead.
"
asserted
Thibeau → be → lead
They want to slow the game so they can use their built-in advantages and their current lead to solidify this market dominance… to make it harder for new entrants to rise the market chain [and capture] the regulatory incentives of the government."
asserted
entrants → want → government
Fox News Digital reached out to all three firms for comment.
asserted
Digital → reach → comment
Anthropic policy documents outline concerns about biological risks, cyber risks, loss of control and the automation of research and development while also underlining that regulations must "protect innovation."
In terms of government oversight, Sen. Charles Schumer, D-N.Y., told reporters Tuesday that AI should be the rare time for bipartisan collaboration on regulation.
asserted
AI → outline → regulation
"If there's ever a time for Republicans to break from their blinded allegiance to Trump, it is now.
asserted
it → be → Trump
The world is in danger and Republicans are on the sidelines sucking their thumbs," the Senate Minority Leader claimed.
asserted
Leader → suck → thumbs
Former Vice President Kamala Harris added in a statement that AI is "advancing at an alarming speed," and signaled she sides with the Big Tech firms calling for pacing the "frontier" — which Thibeau warned about.
"A slowdown is critical in order to ensure AI serves the public interest," she said in part of a lengthy statement.
asserted
she → add → statement
Meanwhile, House Speaker Mike Johnson, R-La., said guardrails are necessary for the AI sphere but that Congress should not respond with a heavy hand.
asserted
Congress → say → hand
"We have to put up some guardrails, some safety measures in place to ensure that AI doesn’t run away ....
asserted
AI → have → place
But at the same time, we’ve got to make sure that we don’t lose our edge in the global competition on this with China," he told NBC News.
asserted
he → get → News
"It’s got to be done right, safely [and] wisely," he said.
asserted
he → get → ?
The Aporia
