President Donald Trump' s push to oust Rep. Ilhan Omar amid allegations of immigration fraud could trigger a constitutional fight, with legal experts telling Fox News Digital that a landmark Supreme Court case involving another entrenched Democrat may not stand in Republicans’ way.
uncertain
case → oust → way
Federal investigators are examining whether the Minneapolis Democrat improperly obtained U.S. citizenship through allegedly fraudulent immigration paperwork involving her late father.
uncertain
Democrat → examine → father
Omar has denied wrongdoing, and no finding that she lacks U.S. citizenship has been established.
asserted
she → deny → citizenship
Experts said Omar may not have the protections established in the landmark case involving House chairman Adam Clayton Powell Jr., D-N.Y., in which the Supreme Court blocked an effort to exclude him from Congress.
uncertain
Court → say → Congress
Powell faced allegations of misusing congressional funds and improperly paying his wife from the congressional payroll.
asserted
Powell → face → payroll
Despite his reelection, the House voted to exclude him in 1967, but the Supreme Court later ruled that Congress could not refuse to seat a duly elected member who satisfied the Constitution's qualifications.
uncertain
who → vote → qualifications
The first potential route for Republicans would be to challenge whether Omar meets the Constitution's citizenship requirement.
asserted
Omar → challenge → requirement
Former Deputy Assistant Attorney General John Yoo and constitutional scholar Cully Stimson told Fox News Digital that the Powell ruling does not prevent Congress from enforcing constitutional qualifications.
asserted
ruling → tell → qualifications
"Powell essentially means that Congress cannot add on to the minimum qualifications set out in the Constitution," Yoo said.
asserted
Yoo → mean → Constitution
"[S]ince citizenship is set out in the text of the Constitution as a qualification, it clearly can be enforced by Congress.
asserted
it → set → Congress
Powell in-fact would support a congressional decision to oust Congresswoman Omar if she was in fact not a citizen."
Stimson argued that citizenship itself is not a legal gray area.
asserted
citizenship → support → fact
The Powell v. McCormack decision did not involve expulsion.
asserted
decision → involve → expulsion
It actually was to judge qualifications.
asserted
It → judge → qualifications
That's a subtle but important difference," he said.
asserted
he → say → ?
Stimson envisioned a January showdown if federal authorities presented evidence challenging Omar's citizenship before the new Congress convenes and House Republicans attempted to prevent her from being seated.
asserted
Republicans → envision → her
Such a move would likely face a legal challenge from Omar, he said, raising questions about whether Congress could act before her citizenship status was resolved.
uncertain
status → face → questions
The Constitution requires House members to be at least 25 years old, have been U.S. citizens for seven years and inhabit the states they represent when elected.
asserted
they → require → states
Stimson argued that even if alleged immigration irregularities originated with Omar's father, Nur Omar Mohamed, the central question would be whether she legally acquired citizenship, regardless of whether she knowingly participated in wrongdoing.
asserted
she → argue → wrongdoing
"It's like you're either pregnant or you're not," he said.
asserted
he → say → ?
"You’re either wet or dry — You're a citizen or you are not a citizen."
asserted
you → ’re → ?
In multiple public comments, Trump has urged Omar’s resignation or expulsion, specifically citing reports that she used a pseudonym when she was sworn into office and that she "married her brother."
"Let’s get her the Hell out of there," he said Monday in Alcorn County, Mississippi.
asserted
he → urge → County
Fox News Digital reached out to Omar for comment.
asserted
Digital → reach → comment
A second route would involve seating Omar and then pursuing expulsion for misconduct, a separate constitutional power requiring a two-thirds House vote.
asserted
route → involve → vote
Unlike exclusion for failing to meet constitutional qualifications, expulsion is a disciplinary action that was not at issue in the Supreme Court's Powell ruling.
asserted
that → fail → ruling
At least one House Republican has already threatened to pursue that option.
asserted
Republican → threaten → option
Rep. Randy Fine, R-Fla., said Friday that if Omar is found to not be a citizen, "I absolutely will demand expulsion immediately."
asserted
I → say → expulsion
Omar faces a separate investigation into her financial disclosures, which U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro previously confirmed to Fox News.
asserted
Pirro → face → News
The inquiry follows scrutiny of businesses tied to her current husband, Timothy Mynett, whose reported valuations reached as high as $30 million before Omar amended the filings, citing accounting errors.
asserted
Omar → follow → errors
No financial wrongdoing has yet been established.
asserted
wrongdoing → establish → ?
Stimson pointed to the 2023 expulsion of former Rep. George Santos, R-N.Y., as an example of the House exercising its disciplinary authority over misconduct that began before a member took office.
asserted
member → point → office
Former House counsel Michael Stern wrote in an examination of the Constitution’s expulsion clause that while Santos’ alleged misconduct largely preceded his term, House investigators found that his misrepresentations continued while he was in office.
asserted
he → write → office
"Thus, acts committed before a member’s first election may constitute disorderly behavior subject to congressional discipline, at least if the misconduct relates to the election and particularly if it involves deceiving the electorate," Stern wrote.
uncertain
Stern → commit → electorate
Stimson said Omar’s case is largely "uncharted waters," but the Santos case could still be instructive.
uncertain
case → say → ?
"I think the argument would be, well, her misrepresentations continued during the time in Congress, they would pull a Santos and use the same logic that they used," he said.
asserted
he → think → that
Any federal determination challenging Omar's citizenship could trigger a legal battle over whether she meets the constitutional requirements for office and what recourse she would have to contest such a finding, Stimson said.
uncertain
Stimson → challenge → finding
"The hard part for her is ‘how do you prove a negative’," Stimson said, adding that placing blame on her father wouldn’t stand up in court because people cannot legally benefit from others’ criminal acts.
"
asserted
people → prove → acts
It’s a harsh world, but it’s a binary situation."
asserted
it → ’ → ?
A challenge to Omar's citizenship could also produce a separate fight over the evidence and legal procedures required to establish whether she meets the Constitution's qualifications.
uncertain
she → produce → qualifications
Fox News Digital’s Pedro Rodriguez-Aparicio contributed to this report.
asserted
Aparicio → contribute → report
The Aporia
