- Published
"Quick, quick, quick, quick! Go, go, go, go, go!"
The words of video assistant referee Matt Donohue as he rushed through the review to award Erling Haaland's winning goal in the Manchester derby.
asserted
he → go → derby
No doubt Donohue was simply trying to be as efficient as possible, but it led to one of the most catastrophic VAR errors the Premier League has seen.
asserted
League → try → errors
Donohue and his assistant VAR, Blake Antrobus, inexplicably failed to notice that Enzo Fernandez was three yards offside before he tried to head the ball.
asserted
he → fail → ball
The goal was given, and Manchester City beat Manchester United 1-0.
asserted
City → give → United
Refereeing has always been a goldfish bowl of scrutiny and pressure, heightened by the introduction of VAR.
asserted
Refereeing → heighten → VAR
The Premier League made a "more efficient application of VAR to reduce delays" one of its football principles for the season.
Has the game tried to prioritise speed over accuracy?
Rushed and chaotic rather than calm and collected
The urgency in Donohue's voice was all too apparent.
"Let's go, let's go, let's go, let's go!"
It was a panicked exchange between the VAR and the replay operator.
asserted
It → make → VAR
The opposite of how a video official should operate.
asserted
official → operate → ?
Officials hear repeatedly - from fans, pundits, radio phone-ins and newspaper columns - that VAR has to be quicker.
asserted
VAR → hear → fans
In the Premier League stakeholders' survey - which includes managers, coaches and supporters - the key theme for improvements to VAR was the speed of decisions.
asserted
theme → include → decisions
This has to create pressure - but it is no excuse for such an error.
asserted
it → have → error
City boss Enzo Maresca had some sympathy speaking on Wednesday, though he was of course the beneficiary of the gaffe.
asserted
he → have → gaffe
"To make a decision in 10, 20 seconds is not easy for them," said Maresca.
asserted
Maresca → make → them
"Sometimes they make mistakes.
asserted
they → make → mistakes
I make mistakes, players make mistakes.
asserted
players → make → mistakes
Referees' chief Howard Webb has taken the desire for quicker reviews on board, but it is still a balancing act.
asserted
it → take → board
There has been a positive impact, as far as the stats go.
asserted
stats → go → ?
VAR delays - including the referee making an announcement to the crowd - have been reduced, from an average of 46 seconds per game to 36 seconds season-on-season.
Yet the only other VAR mistake, the failure to award a penalty to Arsenal at Aston Villa, also arguably came about because the incident was cleared too quickly.
asserted
incident → include → Villa
Completing a VAR review in the shortest possible time is not about skipping steps.
asserted
Completing → complete → steps
Speed is a factor, but the most serious error in process came before Donohue tried to rush through the attacking phase.
asserted
Donohue → come → phase
Donohue asked the replay operator to stop the video on the first replay when Josko Gvardiol touched the ball to cross into the area.
asserted
Gvardiol → ask → area
He then went immediately into the semi-automated offside technology.
asserted
He → go → technology
This should not have happened.
asserted
This → happen → ?
The VAR team should have assessed the full picture, from the playing of the cross to the head of Haaland.
asserted
team → assess → Haaland
This would have provided awareness of Fernandez's position and impact.
asserted
This → provide → position
They did not, and the events inside the penalty area were not considered until the attacking phase was looked at.
asserted
phase → consider → area
By then, all that mattered to Donohue and Antrobus was whether Fernandez touched the ball.
asserted
Fernandez → matter → ball
This would have created a new phase and placed Haaland offside.
asserted
This → create → Haaland
Donohue has received much of the criticism, but arguably Antrobus' involvement, or lack of, was just as influential.
asserted
involvement → receive → criticism
The AVAR's contribution to the entire review was to utter "no, yeah" about the potential touch by Fernandez.
asserted
contribution → utter → Fernandez
This was one second before Donohue uttered the words "final decision is goal, check complete".
asserted
check → utter → words
Antrobus' role is to provide the checks and balances, to make sure the VAR has not missed anything.
asserted
VAR → provide → anything
This fell short.
asserted
This → fall → ?
A Dan Ballard goal was ruled out for a subjective offside against Kevin Danso.
asserted
goal → rule → Danso
There was a great deal of criticism in some parts of the media for that delay, which took over four minutes.
asserted
which → be → minutes
Could that have played on Antrobus' mind on Sunday?
uncertain
that → play → Sunday
We cannot know for sure.
asserted
We → know → ?
Ironically, Antrobus played a crucial role in steering VAR Tim Wood to the correct offside decision against Danso.
asserted
Antrobus → play → Danso
There is also the role of the support VAR, who sits in the operations room next to the match hub at Stockley Park and can intervene on points on protocol.
asserted
who → be → protocol
Aware of what was unfolding with the review, no action was taken.
asserted
action → unfold → review
It would still have been salvageable in the period between the goal being scored and the kick-off.
asserted
goal → score → period
…and 19 more, not listed.
The Aporia
