- Published
Senior figures within the English game are concerned that Manchester City could play in the Champions League next season even if they are relegated for breaching financial regulations.
uncertain
they → publish → regulations
It centres around the possibility that City win the Champions League, which would provide qualification for the competition as titleholders - regardless of their status in the English domestic pyramid.
asserted
which → centre → pyramid
BBC Sport has been told that there is no automatic mechanism to remove City from a European competition they qualify for on sporting merit.
asserted
they → tell → merit
An independent commission found City guilty of all charges related to inflating sponsorship revenue by £830m by using sham contracts, as well as hiding other expenses worth an additional £90m.
Without this, the independent commission said, City would have failed the profit and sustainability rules in all nine seasons between the 2009-10 and 2017-18 seasons.
asserted
City → find → seasons
City continue to strenuously deny any wrongdoing, calling the outcome a "Premier League conspiracy".
asserted
City → continue → outcome
Last week the club lodged an appeal against the verdict.
asserted
club → lodge → verdict
No grounds for City to be denied a licence
BBC Sport has spoken to a number of senior figures with the game in recent days who are concerned about prospect of City qualifying for the Champions League next season.
asserted
City → deny → League
The feeling is that if City do not win their appeal and are therefore handed a strong sanction, then being allowed to compete alongside Europe's elite, and receiving the financial rewards which come with it, would not be acceptable.
asserted
which → win → it
The immediate issue surrounds the Uefa licence, which every club needs in order to play in Europe.
asserted
club → surround → Europe
One source said the issue of City's licence "had been raised" and that a solution "would require the sort of joined up thinking that's been a bit lacking so far".
asserted
that → say → thinking
The licences are issued by the Football Association, though the process itself is delegated to the Premier League.
asserted
process → issue → League
The licences are based upon current information which does not take into account sanctions or breaches related to historical offences.
asserted
which → base → offences
If a club fulfils all minimum criteria required for admission, the licence cannot be refused.
asserted
licence → fulfil → admission
The key reasons a club may fail relate to overdue payables to other teams, players or outstanding tax liabilities.
uncertain
club → fail → teams
Match-fixing convictions within the last 10 years, or a integrity conflict related to multi-club ownership, are considered but would not apply to City.
asserted
convictions → relate → City
A source added that "licences are awarded on the basis of current financial performance, so the grounds to refuse one are unclear".
uncertain
grounds → add → one
If the verdict is upheld by the appeal board is it likely City will face severe sanctions, which could include heavy points deductions, a large fine and transfer embargos.
uncertain
which → uphold → deductions
The sanctioning hearing, which will determine the level of punishment City must face, is yet to be scheduled.
asserted
City → sanction → punishment
While a points deduction could rule City out of qualifying by league position, it might still be achieved through cup competitions.
uncertain
it → rule → competitions
Expelling City from the Premier League immediately is also an option which remains on the table.
asserted
which → expel → table
Uefa may choose to open a disciplinary case
Senior figures both in the English game and in European football are aware of how bad the optics would be if City face strong sanctions yet still play in the Champions League.
uncertain
City → choose → League
It is exacerbated by doubts that the whole process - including an appeal against the sanction - is not guaranteed to be completed by the end of the season.
asserted
process → exacerbate → season
The Premier League added new clauses to its regulations to set timeframes around disciplinary processes and appeals in the summer.
asserted
League → add → summer
If applicable, this would mean a judgement on the sanction must come no later than January.
asserted
judgement → mean → January
But there is no confirmation this applies to the City case.
asserted
this → be → case
It is not just about City winning the Champions League, however.
asserted
City → win → League
If they were to win the FA Cup or Carabao Cup - they play Brighton in the fourth round on 28 October - that would provide a place in the Europa League or the Conference League respectively.
asserted
that → win → League
European football's governing body cannot take any action while the Premier League disciplinary process plays out, but it is understood that potential scenarios are likely to be discussed by the Uefa administration and the Uefa club financial control body (CFCB).
asserted
scenarios → govern → administration
The Premier League case found City guilty of five charges of breaching Uefa's profit and sustainability rules.
asserted
City → find → rules
Uefa may open a case in accordance with the disciplinary regulations to find a way to remove City's eligibility.
uncertain
Uefa → open → eligibility
But this does not provide certainly as City's offences are historical.
asserted
offences → provide → ?
In 2020, City successfully overturned their two-year ban from European club competitions handed down by Uefa.
asserted
City → overturn → Uefa
Uefa issued the ban after ruling City had committed "serious breaches" of financial fair play regulations between 2012 and 2016 - with the same period as the Premier League's investigation.
But the Court of Arbitration for Sport (Cas) overturned the ban because the offences were "time-barred" under Uefa's rules.
asserted
offences → issue → rules
If City are not successful in their appeal and win the Champions League, the CFCB will have to find a disciplinary measure to remove the club from next season's competition.
asserted
CFCB → win → competition
Yet with City already having won against Uefa through Cas once before, there is the concern they could do so again.
uncertain
they → win → Cas
The Aporia
