Putin pushes the myth of Russian invincibility, seemingly to set his terms for peace
Claims strategic defeat is 'unrealistic' but history tells a different story
uncertain
history → push → story
When Russian President Vladimir Putin recently declared to a television reporter that inflicting a "strategic defeat" on Russia is "unrealistic," it may have sounded like standard wartime bravado.
uncertain
it → declare → bravado
Instead, his boilerplate rhetoric may signal something deeper: positioning ahead of a diplomatic endgame as international pressure grows to end the war in Ukraine.
uncertain
pressure → signal → Ukraine
"It is impossible to defeat Russia on the battlefield," Putin told the reporter on Oct. 22.
asserted
Putin → defeat → Oct.
He continued that "historical Russia" includes all Ukrainian territories and as such, the idea that Moscow could ever relinquish land it has conquered in Ukraine is impossible.
uncertain
it → continue → Ukraine
Analysts who've reviewed the Kremlin leader's comments suggest they're part of a deliberate strategy to shape an eventual peace settlement.
asserted
they → review → settlement
"Putin is using history to make a political statement and a political claim," said Eugene Maikinkov, a Canadian-Latvian scholar of Russian history who lectures at the University of Swansea, in Wales.
uncertain
who → use → Wales
British Kremlin-watcher Mark Galeotti regularly parses Putin's speeches on his In Moscow's Shadows podcast and agrees Russia's leader is sending important signals.
"Everyone is moving into that kind of preparatory position of establishing their negotiating stances," he told CBC News.
asserted
he → parse → News
Putin speaks with state television correspondent Pavel Zarubin following an event at the Bolshoi Theatre in Moscow, on Oct. 22 .
asserted
Putin → speak → Oct.
Maikinkov says Putin's message to Russia's adversaries — Europeans especially — is that inflicting a humiliating defeat that fundamentally changes the trajectory of the Russian state will not happen and, one way or another, Russia's demands to end the war will have to be reckoned.
asserted
demands → say → war
"Russia isn't going anywhere.
asserted
Russia → go → ?
It will have to be a partner in the future," said Maikinkov, suggesting there is no realistic way to rob Putin of negotiating power.
asserted
Maikinkov → have → power
After four and half years of combat, the war on the ground has largely bogged down into a stalemate, with Russia making only incremental territorial gains in Ukraine's Donbas region.
asserted
Russia → bogge → region
Some Western estimates suggest its military has suffered as many as half a million deaths and up to 700,000 wounded.
But despite the bloodbath, Putin has not noticeably moved on any of his key demands to end the invasion: Ukraine must turn over the last remaining 15 per cent of the territory of eastern Donbas region; it must demobilize its army; it must have nothing to do with NATO and must "de-Nazify," as the Kremlin puts it.
asserted
Kremlin → suggest → it
That last condition, along with the Nazi reference, reflects Putin's long-held position that the current Ukrainian government of President Volodymyr Zelenskyy — who is Jewish — is illegitimate and must be replaced.
asserted
who → reflect → Zelenskyy
Most Ukrianians believe Putin's real intention is to totally subjugate their country and erase Ukrainian statehood.
asserted
intention → believe → statehood
Ukrainian soldiers fire rockets toward Russian positions on the outskirts of the front-line city of Kramatorsk, in Ukraine's Donetsk region, on Sunday.
asserted
soldiers → fire → Sunday
The belief in Russian exceptionalism — that Russia is a historic empire which will always emerge victorious no matter how hard its enemies try to tear it apart — is one of Putin's most dominant narratives.
asserted
enemies → emerge → narratives
It's also one of the most intensely contested.
asserted
It → contest → contested
"There is a myth that has been successfully planted in the West that Russia always wins," said Poland's Foreign Minister Radosław Sikorski, in response to Putin's comments.
"
asserted
Minister → be → comments
But things don't always go their way.
asserted
things → go → way
People carry candles past The Motherland Calls, a statue commemorating the Russians killed during the German invasion in the Second World War, in Volgograd, Russia, on June 21, 2021.
asserted
People → carry → June
Putin often cites the German defeat as an example of Russia's military prowess.
asserted
Putin → cite → prowess
Russia was defeated in the Crimean war in 1856 which blocked its territorial ambitions in Europe.
asserted
which → defeat → Europe
In 1905, the country's Baltic navy sailed more than 25,000 kilometres around Africa to confront the Japanese navy in the Pacific only to be literally blown out of the water.
asserted
navy → sail → water
And the brutal Soviet-Afghan war, which started in 1979, turned into a decade-long quagmire that ultimately contributed to the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991.
asserted
that → start → 1991
Still, the rambling lectures that Putin frequently delivers to foreign guests and leaders, particularly Europeans, are always more curated.
asserted
Putin → deliver → leaders
His often sermon-like discussions tend to emphasize the defeat of invaders such as Napoleon and Hitler.
asserted
discussions → tend → Napoleon
Putin has also celebrated Czar Peter the Great who captured the territory that now makes up modern-day Estonia and St. Petersburg.
asserted
that → celebrate → Estonia
"Putin scours the historical landscape for legitimacy," said Maikinkov.
asserted
Maikinkov → scour → legitimacy
"One way to gain legitimacy is to create and sustain the narrative of victory and military success.
asserted
way → gain → victory
That's why this narrative [of Russia's invincibility] is powerful and why it sticks."
European divisions
In recent days, Europe has been divided over engaging with Putin.
asserted
Europe → stick → Putin
Finland's President Alexander Stubb took the lead and called Russia's leader last week — the first direct European outreach in years.
asserted
Stubb → take → years
The move was met with heavy criticism in many European capitals including those of Sweden and Italy, but Denmark's Prime Minister Mette Fredrickson was especially vocal, expressing deep skepticism over the overture.
asserted
Fredrickson → meet → overture
Galeotti says the divisions revert back to a core disagreement over whether its possible to inflict an Afghanistan-style collapse on Putin that fundamentally changes the power dynamics of Europe.
asserted
that → say → Europe
Putin is trying to inject himself into the debate, more or less saying, 'You can be serious [about negotiating] or you cannot be serious, it's your choice.'
asserted
it → try → negotiating
"
Municipal employees work at the site of private houses which were damaged during a Russian drone strike, amid Russia's attack on Ukraine, in Odesa, Ukraine November 2, 2026.
asserted
which → work → Odesa
In recent weeks, the Trump administration has tried to incentivize Putin into a ceasefire, including by waiving sanctions on diesel exports.
asserted
administration → try → exports
The Wall Street Journal has also reported some of his officials are trying to convince Europe to start buying Russian natural gas again.
asserted
some → report → gas
So far, despite Trump's overtures, European nations have expressed little to no interest in re-establishing commercial ties with Russia before there's an end to the war.
asserted
nations → express → war
…and 14 more, not listed.
The Aporia
