While out on the campaign trail in Makerfield, Andy Burnham gave a glimpse into where he might land on Labour’s plans for immigration reform, which had already been decried by the left of the party as unfair and the right as electorally necessary.
uncertain
which → give → party
Asked by the Guardian what he thought of Reform’s attack on “open borders Andy” – Nigel Farage’s early attempt to define him as soft on migration – the then Manchester mayor dismissed the charge as “ridiculous” and went on the defensive.
“I’m not like that.
asserted
I → ask → that
You know me.
asserted
You → know → me
I was in the Home Office under Tony Blair, and actually, it was my job to return people.
asserted
it → return → people
That was my specific role,” he said while out knocking on doors in the constituency.
asserted
he → say → constituency
“I used to have to travel to governments around the world and persuade them to take back planes of people who had come here with no basis to stay, so you know, I’ve never have been shy of getting to grips with these difficult issues.
asserted
I → use → issues
But Burnham wasn’t just pitching to the Reform-inclined voters he needed to win the seat; he was already charting whatever path he might then need to take if he made it all the way to Downing Street.
uncertain
he → pitch → Street
While he was supportive of attempts by the home secretary, Shabana Mahmood, to limit legal and illegal migration, which had been criticised by some senior Labour figures as unBritish, Burnham wanted to reframe the changes.
asserted
Burnham → limit → changes
“I think there’s a different way of thinking about it that might in the end get you to a better position, and one that restores public confidence,” he said.
uncertain
he → think → confidence
The prime minister’s political allies say he regards migration as a moral issue, showing people who’ve lost faith in politics that the government does have control over the UK’s borders and is prepared to do something about it.
asserted
government → say → it
But he also wants to tell a positive story about the contribution of migration to the country, they say.
asserted
they → want → country
Weeks after arriving in No 10, the Guardian revealed that social care workers could be exempted from the plans as he looked for ways to relieve pressure on the sector.
uncertain
he → arrive → sector
In an interview with ITV this week, Burnham again tried to make the case.
asserted
Burnham → try → case
“When you have planned migration, it’s difficult to say if it’s too high or too low,” he said, arguing that migrants help plug “gaps in the economy”.
asserted
migrants → have → economy
In the end, Mahmood’s reforms came with a significant carve-out for almost 300,000 care workers to allow them to apply for indefinite leave to remain (ILR) after five years.
asserted
them → come → years
In a further compromise to those on the Labour benches feeling squeamish, those deemed to be making a “strong contribution” to the UK – high earners, those with strong British connections or who work in health and teaching – will also be able to settle in five years.
asserted
who → feel → years
But that Burnham delivered the bulk of Mahmood’s hardline reforms should not come as a surprise to anybody who has been paying attention.
asserted
who → deliver → attention
The prime minister, steeped in the politics of the “red wall”, understands better than many the salience of the issue with voters.
asserted
minister → steep → voters
The most rigorous of the new rules first drawn up a year ago by the Home Office – retrospective changes for many migrants or forcing small boats arrivals to face up to 30 years before applying for settlement – are still there.
asserted
rigorous → draw → settlement
How they land with the public (which polling suggests supports a doubling of the waiting time for most migrants to 10 years) now depends in part on whether ministers can convince them it’s about people making a contribution, rather than a U-turn forced by their own side.
uncertain
people → land → side
The Conservatives and Reform, unsurprisingly, are already pushing the latter narrative, with Farage describing the care workers carve-out as “the beginning of the capitulation” on borders.
asserted
Farage → push → borders
Burnham is, equally predictably, arguing that it’s about fairness.
asserted
it → argue → fairness
“It is only fair that those who are making the most valuable contribution to our communities are given the opportunity to settle earlier,” he said.
asserted
he → make → opportunity
“Those in other roles should expect to wait longer while people who abuse the system or arrive illegally will be refused or will also have to wait longer.”
asserted
who → expect → system
But Burnham’s words did not come in the Commons chamber or at a press conference standing alongside Mahmood or even as part of his prolific social media output.
asserted
words → come → output
They were instead issued in a press release, after the government chose to push ahead with the sensitive policy announcement while he was out of the country – travelling to the Commonwealth leaders summit in Antigua.
asserted
he → issue → Antigua
The plans are still likely to face criticism from some on either wing of the Labour party, although plenty of former critics do now appear to be on board.
asserted
plenty → face → board
But without an obvious vote to coalesce around, any rebellion looks unlikely.
asserted
rebellion → coalesce → vote
Mahmood’s bigger challenge will be convincing the public.
asserted
challenge → convince → public
She will need Burnham, who has praised her for “gripping this problem” so is presumably fully behind them, to help her to do so.
asserted
her → need → them
The Aporia
