Andy Burnham's bid to get a grip on Brexit tensions in Cabinet was dealt a blow by his Chancellor today.
asserted
bid → get → Chancellor
The PM sent a letter to ministers yesterday urging them not to take fixed positions on future ties with the EU.
asserted
them → send → EU
The move came after he triggered a storm by raising the prospect the UK could rejoin the bloc after the next election, and even restore the previous open borders rules.
However, in an interview after his Budget, John Healey risked undermining the call for 'discipline' on the issue.
uncertain
Healey → come → issue
Asked on GB News whether free movement was 'on the agenda now', Mr Healey - who represents a constituency that voted heavily for Brexit - said: 'No.
asserted
that → ask → Brexit
Freedom of movement is not on the agenda, and certainly for this Parliament it's ruled out.
asserted
it → rule → Parliament
Despite the seemingly trenchant statement, the Chancellor added: 'But inevitably it's part of a bigger discussion about how we get a better Brexit deal and Britain does better after the ten years of Brexit deal that's failing the country.
'
asserted
that → add → country
Now, the Prime Minister wants that bigger conversation.
asserted
Minister → want → conversation
My first focus is this European summit that's coming up next month, and I want to make sure that we can negotiate some better terms and lower costs for our business.
asserted
we → come → business
John Healey insisted free movement is 'not on the agenda', after Andy Burnham urged ministers not to take fixed positions
'
asserted
Burnham → insist → positions
It'll create jobs, improve trade and if we can help bring down costs for consumers here, that's a good thing.
asserted
that → create → consumers
Pressed whether that meant he would be 'in favour of entering the EU on a freedom of movement basis' if it helped the economy, Mr Healey said: 'No, I'm in favour of accepting that we've got a Brexit decision.
asserted
we → press → decision
And I'm in favour of the job we need to do now, which is to make the best of the terms we've got.
'
asserted
we → need → terms
And my job as Chancellor is to make sure that we can reinforce the economy.
asserted
we → make → economy
We can create the support for those people who are ready to start and rapidly grow firms here.'
asserted
who → create → firms
In the letter to the Cabinet published yesterday, Mr Burnham said any 'fundamental change' to post-Brexit arrangements would be 'for the public to decide' and left to the next Parliament.
asserted
public → publish → Parliament
The PM's call at the weekend for an 'honest discussion' about a return to freedom of movement has prompted questions about the parameters around his vision for a deepening relationship with Brussels.
asserted
call → prompt → Brussels
Confusion intensified after he was pressed on Monday about how any change in Labour's manifesto red lines - ruling out rejoining the customs union and single market - would be put to voters.
asserted
change → intensify → voters
Speaking to ITV, Mr Burnham said there would be no shift within this Parliament and signalled that he could fight the next general election on a promise to take the UK back into the bloc.
uncertain
he → speak → bloc
In another interview, he said 'no' when asked whether he would allow the UK to reinstate EU freedom of movement without a referendum, forcing Downing Street to later clarify that he was 'not leaning either way' on how to move forward.
asserted
he → say → Street
Writing to the Cabinet, Mr Burnham said: 'I am clear in my conviction that the Brexit deal negotiated by the Conservative government was not good enough for Britain.
asserted
deal → write → Britain
It has led to a decade of low growth, burdened businesses with more red tape and weakened our ability to control immigration.
asserted
It → lead → immigration
It is a harder Brexit than was promised at the EU referendum.'
asserted
It → promise → referendum
Mr Burnham told ministers there was an 'agreed mandate' for the summit to which Cabinet collective responsibility applies and warned them against publicly advocating for any specific outcome in the period that follows.
'In the period beyond the summit, Government policy will be to explore options for the long-term relationship with the EU for consideration in the next Parliament,' he said.
asserted
he → tell → Parliament
'At the end of this process, we will set out to the country the respective merits and drawbacks of the various options.
asserted
we → set → options
'It is important that we remain aligned and disciplined as a Government in our messaging throughout this period.
asserted
we → remain → period
'It will not be appropriate for ministers individually to advocate for specific options or opine on the likely outcome of the process.'
asserted
ministers → advocate → process
The Aporia
