Judge accuses DOJ of 'weaponization,' tosses case against ex-FBI officials
asserted
Judge → accuse → officials
A federal magistrate judge on Monday dismissed the Justice Department's criminal case against two former FBI officials charged in connection with the bureau's investigations into former President Joe Biden's son.
asserted
judge → dismiss → son
Bradley Benavides and Nikki Floris were charged around two weeks ago with lying to Congress in 2023 about their knowledge of the FBI's investigations into Biden's son, Hunter Biden.
asserted
Benavides → charge → son
It is one of several politically charged actions by the Justice Department under President Trump in the run-up to the midterm elections on Tuesday.
asserted
It → charge → Tuesday
At a hearing in federal court in Washington, D.C., U.S. Magistrate Judge Zia Faruqui castigated the government's investigation into Floris and Benavides, describing it as rushed and riddled with errors.
asserted
Faruqui → castigate → errors
"I am deeply troubled by what has happened here," Faruqui said in a scathing ruling from the bench.
asserted
Faruqui → trouble → bench
"What transpired here cannot be described as anything other than weaponization."
asserted
transpired → transpire → weaponization
The U.S. Attorney's Office in Washington, D.C., did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
asserted
Office → respond → comment
The court's ruling came after a days-long preliminary hearing last week to determine whether probable cause existed to charge Floris and Benavides with lying to Congress.
asserted
cause → come → Congress
It featured testimony from one of the FBI agents who investigated the case.
asserted
who → feature → case
Over the course of an hour, Faruqui on Monday laid out the basis for his decision before a packed courtroom that included many former senior FBI officials.
asserted
that → lay → officials
The judge noted that the investigation into Floris and Benavides was opened on FBI Director Kash Patel's orders the day after President Trump delivered a primetime address on national TV in mid-July.
asserted
Trump → note → July
In that speech, Trump repeated his false claims about fraud in the 2020 election and urged the FBI to investigate.
uncertain
Trump → repeat → FBI
Faruqui noted that the alleged false statements were made to Congress in 2023, yet the Justice Department waited three years to pursue the case.
asserted
Department → note → case
Prosecutors then brought charges some two weeks before the midterm elections, despite a DOJ policy prohibiting timing any action to influence an election.
asserted
Prosecutors → bring → election
The judge also noted that charges were filed as a criminal complaint, a document usually used when there is some need for urgency such as an imminent danger, a statute of limitations deadline or a risk of flight—none of which existed in this case.
asserted
none → note → case
The only event that was looming here, he said, was the midterms.
asserted
he → loom → ?
"I will not bury my head in the sand and pretend I cannot read a calendar," Faruqui said.
asserted
Faruqui → bury → calendar
"I will not lobotomize myself that way."
asserted
I → lobotomize → myself
He also said prosecutors appear not to want to take this case before a grand jury, perhaps given the Justice Department's poor track record recently with grand juries in Washington, D.C.
On several occasions under the Trump administration, grand juries in the nation's capital have refused to return indictments in high-profile, politically charged cases.
asserted
juries → say → cases
While Faruqui dismissed the case, he said that nothing is stopping prosecutors from going to a grand jury and trying to secure an indictment.
asserted
nothing → dismiss → indictment
Prosecutors could also appeal his decision to the district's chief judge.
uncertain
Prosecutors → appeal → judge
After the hearing, a group of former FBI officials greeted Floris and Benavides outside the courtroom.
asserted
group → greet → courtroom
Floris, tears in her eyes, hugged several of her former colleagues before sharing a hug with Benavides.
asserted
tears → hug → Benavides
"This case should never have been brought.
asserted
case → bring → ?
The government had no case," said Margaret Donovan, one of Floris' attorneys.
asserted
Donovan → have → attorneys
"As the judge just laid out, this was a slap-dash complaint, spaghetti-at-the wall, Hunter Biden conspiracy fever dream.
asserted
this → lay → wall
But facts still matter in a courtroom.
asserted
facts → matter → courtroom
The truth still matters in a courtroom.
asserted
truth → matter → courtroom
And that's what we say prevailed today."
asserted
we → say → ?
The Aporia
