Reshaped civil rights mission at Justice Department transforms its work, workforce
asserted
mission → reshape → work
When Harmeet Dhillon took over as the new chief of the Justice Department's Civil Rights Division last April, the conservative attorney vowed to radically reshape the storied unit and its mission.
asserted
attorney → take → unit
Over the past 18 months, Dhillon has moved aggressively to make that goal a reality.
asserted
goal → move → months
She has pushed out hundreds of longtime attorneys, replaced many of them with inexperienced ideological allies, and used the division's enforcement powers to pursue President Trump's MAGA agenda, according to four current and former division officials.
uncertain
She → push → officials
Three of the individuals spoke on condition of anonymity out of fear of retribution.
asserted
Three → speak → retribution
At the root of these changes is Dhillon's vision of the Civil Rights Division and its mission that dramatically departs from tradition.
asserted
that → depart → tradition
Created almost 70 years ago during the movement to end racial segregation, the Civil Rights Division historically has sought to combat discrimination and protect the constitutional rights of all Americans in everything from voting and housing to employment, education and policing.
asserted
Division → create → employment
The division's priorities have shifted from administration to administration, although its core work has remained consistent.
asserted
work → shift → administration
But Dhillon, who was born in India and immigrated to the U.S. as a child, argues that over the years the division's mission has narrowed to protecting the rights of just one segment of society: people of color.
asserted
mission → bear → color
In her view, that has created a form of "benevolent racism" designed to punish "the descendants of those who may have been responsible for the sins of the past."
uncertain
who → create → past
"As the logic goes, the white oppressors of years past kept Brown and Black people down, why not give them a taste of their own medicine?" she said last November at an event for the conservative Federalist Society.
asserted
she → go → Society
"That's the thinking really that underlies a lot of our civil rights enforcement work.
asserted
that → underlie → work
"
Transformed focus since Trump took over
asserted
Trump → transform → ?
That all changed, she said, in 2025 when President Trump returned to office and Dhillon arrived at the Justice Department.
asserted
Dhillon → change → Department
Since then, the division has dropped investigations and withdrawn statements of interest in dozens of cases, including those involving voting rights, racial discrimination and civil actions against anti-abortion activists.
asserted
division → drop → activists
It has ended investigations into police departments over alleged constitutional violations.
asserted
It → end → violations
Some of the most aggressive work of her tenure has been on the voting front, where the division has sent monitors to keep tabs on states' primary elections, and filed lawsuits demanding voter information from a slew of states, in furtherance of Trump's focus on alleged election fraud by noncitizens.
asserted
division → send → noncitizens
State election officials—Republican and Democratic—have pushed back, accusing the Justice Department of overreach.
asserted
officials → push → overreach
Judges have tossed more than two dozen of the department's lawsuits, including most recently in Georgia.
asserted
Judges → toss → Georgia
In just the past two months, the Civil Rights Division has accused law schools at the University of California, Berkeley and Duke University as well as the medical schools at the University of California, San Francisco and George Washington University of discriminating against white and Asian students in admissions.
asserted
Division → accuse → admissions
It also has sued UCLA and Harvard for allegedly allowing antisemitism to flourish on campus.
uncertain
antisemitism → sue → campus
In August, a federal judge dismissed the department's lawsuit against Harvard, finding the claims of antisemitism were "too isolated and episodic" to prove the school was violating civil rights laws.
uncertain
school → dismiss → laws
In a statement to NPR, Dhillon defended the division's work under her leadership.
asserted
Dhillon → defend → leadership
"Under this administration, the division has held universities accountable for antisemitic harassment, defended the constitutional rights of Americans of every faith, and protected the integrity of federal elections," she said.
asserted
she → hold → elections
"Civil rights laws exist to protect individuals from discrimination, and that is exactly how we enforce them.
asserted
we → exist → them
Critics calling equal enforcement 'weaponization' are telling on themselves.
asserted
Critics → call → themselves
"
While several sections have seen drastic changes in their work, not every unit has been affected to the same degree, three current and former division officials say.
asserted
officials → see → degree
Sections that address housing and disability rights, for example, are still doing a lot of the work they've traditionally done.
asserted
they → address → work
Last year, for example, the department sued Uber for denying rides to passengers with service dogs or wheelchairs.
asserted
department → sue → dogs
Out with the old, in with the new
One of the ways Dhillon has moved to implement her vision is through changes to those who do the work: the division's lawyers and staff.
asserted
who → move → work
Early on in her tenure, she accused division attorneys of pursuing a left-wing agenda.
asserted
she → accuse → agenda
"The job here is to enforce the federal civil rights laws, not woke ideology," Dhillon told Glenn Beck in an interview last year.
asserted
Dhillon → enforce → interview
She encouraged attorneys and staff who didn't want to implement her vision of the division's mission to leave the department.
asserted
who → encourage → department
Up to 80% of the division staff did exactly that in a wave of departures that has decimated the division's institutional knowledge.
asserted
that → do → knowledge
Much of the mass exodus occurred during the height of the Trump administration's Department of Government Efficiency, or DOGE cuts, and current and former division officials say many people left or opted to retire early to prevent staff cuts imposed from on high.
asserted
people → occur → high
Current and former officials say that has left the division shorthanded—depleted of talent, expertise and basic manpower.
asserted
that → say → talent
"There are so few people there doing civil rights work at all," said Georgetown Law professor Christy Lopez, who worked for more than a decade in the division before leaving in 2017.
asserted
who → be → 2017
Since Trump returned to office, some 300 attorneys have left the division, according to current and former officials.
uncertain
attorneys → return → officials
The Justice Department says some 130 have been hired to replace them.
asserted
130 → say → them
Accusations of political hiring
Current and former officials say Dhillon has changed the hiring process, shrugging off rules that were meant to insulate it from partisan political considerations.
asserted
that → say → considerations
…and 16 more, not listed.
The Aporia
