The great British actor, Sir Patrick Stewart, passed away yesterday.
asserted
actor → pass → ?
While Stewart began his career as a stage actor and performed in many Shakespeare plays, he is best known for his portrayal of Captain Jean-Luc Picard, in Star Trek: The Next Generation.
asserted
he → begin → Trek
Thanks to his impressive performance, Stewart and the character he played became science fiction icons.
asserted
he → play → performance
Stewart brought extraordinary depth and perception to the role.
asserted
Stewart → bring → role
Perhaps more than any other character, Stewart's Picard epitomized Star Trek's progressive liberal values: Enlightenment rationalism, technological optimism (highlighted by his defense of the rights of the android Data), racial and ethnic equality, and commitment to peace and diplomacy.
asserted
Picard → epitomize → peace
In many ways, Picard and TNG promoted these ideas to an even greater extent than the original series.
asserted
Picard → promote → series
Whereas Captain Kirk was often belligerent and acted on instinct, Picard sought diplomatic solutions to conflict, and tried to avoid doing anything drastic without careful deliberation.
asserted
Picard → act → deliberation
In the original series, the Klingons and Romulans are mostly depicted as evil and irreconcilable enemies of the Federation, in TNG the Klingons have become allies and there is hope that there will be peace with the Romulans, as well.
asserted
Klingons → depict → Romulans
In multiple episodes, Picard takes the lead in working to maintain and improve Federation relations with these and other previously hostile alien societies.
asserted
Picard → take → societies
But, as I have pointed out in a 2016 article (see also this more recent piece), Star Trek's ideology has a dark side, as well: its uncritical embrace of socialism.
asserted
ideology → point → socialism
This is also reflected in the Federation's seeming ideological homogeneity.
asserted
This → reflect → homogeneity
Picard also exemplifies this negative aspect of Star Trek ideology, with his thinly veiled disdain for private enterprise, and people who seek to make a profit.
asserted
who → exemplify → profit
As depicted by Stewart, the Picard character also highlights another key tension in Star Trek ideology, this one relating to cultural diversity.
asserted
character → depict → diversity
Picard is supposed to be French; but other than his noticeable British accent, he seems little different from other human Federation characters.
asserted
he → suppose → characters
The "Doylist" real-world explanation for this is that Stewart himself was British, and trying to get him to speak with a French accent might have had bad results.
uncertain
him → try → results
But the "Watsonian" in-universe effect of this is to accentuate how the human characters in Star Trek have largely lost their cultural distinctiveness.
asserted
characters → accentuate → distinctiveness
French, British, and other human cultures have largely blended together, by the 24th century (when the show is set).
asserted
show → blend → century
Star Trek may champion diversity.
uncertain
Trek → champion → diversity
But, culturally and politically, the human characters are mostly people who look different, but largely think alike on almost all major issues.
asserted
who → look → issues
The few dissenters are generally depicted as either villains or fools.
asserted
dissenters → depict → villains
As I have previously noted, this ideological homogeneity and uncritical acceptance of Federation ideology gets challenged more in later Star Trek series, beginning with Deep Space 9.
asserted
homogeneity → note → Space
DS-9 and later series depict more ideological conflict among humans, and raise serious questions about Federation ideology.
asserted
DS-9 → depict → ideology
But Stewart's Picard remains an iconic depiction of Federation ideals.
asserted
Picard → remain → ideals
As always in assessing actors, we should not assume that the character necessarily reflects the views of the actor.
asserted
character → assess → actor
We can and should recognize Picard's shortcomings and those of Federation ideology, without blaming Stewart for them.
asserted
We → recognize → them
Indeed, his performance deserves credit for providing a valuable window into these issues.
asserted
performance → deserve → issues
But I would argue the blame for that rests with the producers and their problematic plotlines, rather than Stewart.
asserted
blame → argue → Stewart
In addition to his justly famous Star Trek role, Stewart also starred in the X-Men movie series (which I won't comment on, as I know little about it).
asserted
I → star → it
His first significant science fiction role was playing Gurney Halleck in the 1984 movie version of Dune.
asserted
role → play → Dune
The 1984 Dune movie is an incoherent mess, and not as good as the more recent Denis Villeneuve version (see my reviews of the latter here and here).
asserted
movie → see → latter
But Stewart did a great job with his role, and really brought Halleck to life.
asserted
Stewart → do → life
In sum, Sir Patrick Stewart was a great actor, and well deserves his status as an SF icon.
asserted
Stewart → deserve → icon
He will be greatly missed.
asserted
He → miss → ?
The Aporia
