- Published
Chancellor John Healey and Prime Minister Andy Burnham have both spoken of their desire for the benefits bill to come down, but the government has not yet laid out a timetable for any reductions.
asserted
government → publish → reductions
Their political opponents have criticised them for a lack of detail on welfare reform in Wednesday's Budget, accusing the government of delaying difficult decisions over cuts.
Official forecasts released alongside the Budget indicate welfare spending is going to increase by £79bn in cash terms over the next few years.
asserted
spending → criticise → years
BBC Verify has taken a look at the numbers behind this thorny political issue and some of the difficult options the government have to bring down welfare costs.
asserted
government → take → costs
How much is being spent on welfare?
asserted
much → spend → welfare
The official forecaster, the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), estimates in its latest forecasts that the cost of the welfare system will rise, external from £353bn this year to £431bn in 2032.
asserted
cost → estimate → 2032
The OBR's figures include spending on pensioners, which accounts for just under half of the total.
asserted
which → include → total
However, if we look at the size of welfare spending relative to the size of the overall economy the OBR's projections are less dramatic, increasing from 11.1% today to 11.3% of GDP in 2032.
asserted
projections → look → 2032
Total welfare spending would also remain below the peak of around 12% of GDP in 2013 following the global financial crisis, leading some economists and researchers to question the idea that welfare spending is out of control., external
asserted
spending → remain → control
But there are some welfare costs that are rising rapidly.
asserted
that → be → ?
Spending on health and disability related benefits, in particular Personal Independence Payments (PIP), is up sharply since the Covid-19 pandemic.
asserted
Spending → relate → pandemic
Accounting for inflation, spending on working-age disability benefits increased from £14bn in 2020 to £25bn in 2026, external.
asserted
spending → account → 2026
Inflation-adjusted welfare spending remains lower than 2013 because several other working-age benefits, such as Universal Credit and housing benefit, were cut by Conservative-led governments as part of their austerity programme from 2010 onwards, external.
So spending in some parts of the system has come down while it has risen in others - and there could be a connection.
Some researchers think the post-2010 welfare cuts to benefits might have created an incentive for people to claim sickness and disability benefits instead to protect their living standards, external, therefore shifting costs around the system rather than generating lasting savings.
uncertain
people → adjust → savings
The problem of Neets
Many also see a specific problem regarding the growing number of young people in the welfare system claiming benefits, including PIP.
asserted
Many → see → PIP
Official figures show the number of 16 to 24-year-olds who are not in employment, education or training (Neets) has risen, external by around 230,000 since 2019 to just under one million.
asserted
who → show → million
Former Labour health secretary Alan Milburn is leading an official review into Neets and is expected to recommend major reforms designed to get many off benefits and into work.
asserted
Milburn → lead → work
His interim report in May estimated that annual PIP expenditure on 16 to 24-year-olds rose from £1.3bn in 2020 to around £3.2bn in 2025, external.
uncertain
expenditure → estimate → 2025
It also projected this cost would reach £6.5bn and cover 700,000 young people in five years' time.
asserted
cost → project → time
PIP claimants can be in work, but official statistics show that only around one in five are, external.
What could cutting the benefits bill mean?
uncertain
cutting → show → bill
Politicians are often unclear about what they mean by reducing spending on welfare.
uncertain
they → mean → welfare
In March 2025, former prime minister Sir Keir Starmer's government presented a plan which it said would save £5bn a year from health-related welfare spending by 2030 by tightening PIP access and reducing the value of health-related Universal Credit payments.
asserted
it → present → payments
But official forecasts made it clear that annual spending on health-related welfare in cash terms was still set to rise after the reform, external, just not as rapidly as the path it had previously been on.
However, at the time the OBR did forecast the plans would help put overall UK welfare spending on a "slightly downward trajectory" as a share of the economy, external over the medium term, rather than remaining flat as had been previously projected.
asserted
plans → make → term
So this type of relative reduction in anticipated welfare spending, rather than a cut in absolute cash terms, could be what the government seeks to deliver.
uncertain
government → anticipate → what
Looming reports may offer options
uncertain
reports → loom → options
The final Milburn report is expected in the coming weeks, as well as a separate final report from disability minister Stephen Timms into the options for PIP reform.
asserted
report → expect → reform
There has been speculation that these could recommend creating a new welfare system for people under the age of 25, external, so they are not eligible for PIP and receive lower payments than older people.
uncertain
they → recommend → people
There are also suggestions Timms could propose a new PIP eligibility test to reduce access, external, although he was not specifically instructed to find savings.
uncertain
he → be → savings
Reforms along these lines could potentially make some savings to the welfare bill relative to the existing trajectory of rising spending, as well as reducing forecast welfare spending as share of GDP.
But some analysts argue that to be effective in delivering sustainable savings, such reforms are likely also to require the government to spend a lot more, external to enable young people in particular to get into and remain in work.
uncertain
people → make → work
This was signalled by the interim Milburn report which noted that for every £1 the government spends on employment support for young people around £25 is spent on benefits, suggesting he could propose a significant increase in government spending on welfare-to-work schemes.
uncertain
he → signal → schemes
This means that any welfare savings could, in the near term at least, be offset by additional spending in other departments.
uncertain
savings → mean → departments
However, in the long term this approach could still deliver welfare savings if the employment support was effective.
uncertain
support → deliver → savings
The Aporia
