- Published
"Democracy is the worst form of government except for all those other forms that have been tried."
asserted
that → try → forms
So said Winston Churchill in the House of Commons in 1947.
asserted
Churchill → say → 1947
His aphorism came to mind as Israel's election results filtered through on Tuesday night - exit polls blending with ballots that were cast to dash or fulfil people's hopes and fears.
asserted
that → come → hopes
Voters turning out in record numbers, Jews and Arabs alike.
asserted
Voters → turn → numbers
Many spent thousands to fly in from abroad to cast their ballot.
asserted
Many → spend → ballot
At polling stations across the country, we saw the passion of campaigners, as they used every minute to try to change that last mind and win that last vote.
asserted
they → see → vote
President Isaac Herzog said the election was a "badge of honour" for Israeli society.
asserted
election → say → society
"It is remarkable to see how deep the desire for democracy is in Israel," he exclaimed.
asserted
he → see → Israel
Yet this election left the most established democracy in the Middle East without a clear path to a new government.
asserted
election → leave → government
It produced an inconclusive result where neither opposing bloc will have a majority in parliament.
asserted
bloc → produce → parliament
Some might say this was business as usual.
uncertain
this → say → ?
Israel has never had a one-party government.
asserted
Israel → have → government
Its fragmented, proportional representation system is almost designed to govern by coalition.
asserted
system → design → coalition
Yet many commentators warned this election had revealed the fundamental and perhaps growing divisions that scar this nation.
asserted
that → warn → nation
This was not a plebiscite in which an electorate united around a single cause.
asserted
electorate → unite → cause
There were divisions over judicial reforms that led to mass demonstrations in the early years of this government.
asserted
that → be → government
The casualties suffered by Israeli reservists in the fighting in Gaza that followed deepened tensions over the exemption of ultra-Orthodox young men from military service.
asserted
that → suffer → service
But has this election put in even sharper contrast the deep fault-lines that lie within Israeli society?
asserted
that → put → society
Should Israel's government subsidise religious study?
asserted
government → subsidise → study
Should some parents sacrifice their sons and daughters to defend Israel when others do not?
asserted
others → sacrifice → Israel
The ultra-Orthodox now make up almost 15% of the population.
asserted
Orthodox → make → population
Benjamin Netanyahu's Likud party suffered significant losses, but is still on track to be the largest in the Knesset.
asserted
party → suffer → Knesset
All this for a prime minister accused of corruption, which he denies; a leader also accused of failing to protect Israel before 7 October, something he will not allow to be investigated.
asserted
he → accuse → October
Some 10% of voters backed the Jewish supremacist far-right: politicians like Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, who even as results were being announced was promising to establish Jewish settlements in Gaza.
asserted
results → back → Gaza
The Arab parties, which represent about a fifth of Israeli citizens, made huge gains, winning some 15% of the vote, potentially giving them seats numbering in the high teens.
And then there was the opposition bloc, a mix of centre, left and right led by Gadi Eisenkot who fell short of winning the change they wanted - change that many believed was existential for the future of this country.
asserted
many → represent → country
How these vastly diverging views coalesce into some form of government is now the unenviable task facing Israel's body politic - the choices and compromises they may have to make could involve fundamental decisions about the country's future.
Would Netanyahu be ready to abandon his religious allies and form a coalition with right-wingers from the opposition bloc?
uncertain
Netanyahu → diverge → bloc
Would they be ready to swallow their hostility towards the prime minister and sit in his government?
asserted
they → swallow → government
Is the opposition bloc ready to abandon much of its campaign promises and co-operate with Arab parties to force Netanyahu out of office?
asserted
bloc → abandon → office
Are the Arab parties ready to risk joining a government that could fall within months?
uncertain
that → risk → months
Yair Golan, the left-wing Democrat leader, urged the opposition bloc to form a partnership with Arab parties.
asserted
Golan → urge → parties
"We must no longer accept Netanyahu's racist division between Jewish votes and Arab votes," he said.
asserted
he → accept → votes
Amit Segal, an Israeli commentator sympathetic towards Netanyahu, said the high turnout among Arab Israeli voters "reminded Jews on both sides that, after years of division, they may have to learn to sit together after all".
uncertain
they → say → division
The risk is that this election, instead of putting Israel on a new path, has instead raised further doubts about what it is that unites its citizens.
asserted
that → put → citizens
What are the common factors that bind this complex, varied collection of peoples into one polity?
asserted
that → bind → polity
Autocratic governments, which are growing in number, have long criticised democracies for producing weak and temporary governments, often fragile coalitions that struggle to hold together, let alone deliver what the people wanted.
asserted
people → grow → what
Israel may now struggle for months to form a government.
uncertain
Israel → struggle → government
It might even fail and have to hold another election.
uncertain
It → fail → election
President Herzog acknowledged this risk head on as he prepared to open coalition negotiations: "We must do everything we can, certainly after yesterday, to avoid another round of elections."
For years, Israel has focused on defending itself against its external enemies.
asserted
Israel → acknowledge → enemies
But must it also now be ready to defend itself from perils within, if the divisions writ large by this election become unmanageable?
asserted
divisions → defend → election
In another speech, Churchill once said democracy was not just "insurance against dangers from abroad".
asserted
democracy → say → dangers
…and 2 more, not listed.
The Aporia
