Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva winning his fourth term as Brazil’s President has also interrupted a series of right-wing electoral wins in Latin America.
asserted
winning → win → America
That said, Brazil and Mexico are now the sole left-wing governments among the region’s largest economies.
asserted
Brazil → say → economies
And while it would be reductive to believe the left is more welcoming of climate action and the right is more disdainful, Mr. Lula also faces significant challenges in his role on the issue both in Brazil and beyond.
asserted
Lula → believe → Brazil
Also read | Belém as a test of a new model of forest finance
His foremost opportunity will be to have Brazil cement its mantle of leadership.
asserted
Brazil → read → leadership
Brazil is somewhat unique: it is Latin America’s largest economy, the world’s fifth-largest by area, host to most of the Amazon and, crucially, has diplomatic relationships with the European Union, the U.S., China, the BRICS countries, and many other developing economies — potentially allowing Mr. Lula to negotiate across the divides that currently frustrate climate agreements.
asserted
that → have → agreements
In fact, China has made tariffs on clean energy technologies a priority for the COP31 summit, set to commence in under a fortnight in Türkiye, with Beijing arguing against protectionist trade measures while the EU and the U.S. have raised concerns about dependence on Chinese manufacturers.
asserted
EU → make → manufacturers
On the regional level, Brazil straddles several problems, including deforestation in the Amazon, illegal mining, forest fires, and a degrading river basin, that demand region-wide cooperation, including the representation of Indigenous groups.
asserted
that → straddle → groups
Mr. Lula revived such cooperation to a commendable degree through the Amazon Cooperation Treaty Organisation (ACTO), by hosting the Belém summit in 2023, and by making further commitments at the Bogotá summit in 2025.
asserted
Lula → revive → 2025
However, the optimism Mr. Lula warrants is tempered by the Belém Declaration in 2023 failing to establish a binding collective deadline to end deforestation in the Amazon rainforest and to prohibit the development of new oil projects in the region.
asserted
Lula → warrant → region
Both the dependence of the Amazonian countries on agriculture, petroleum, and mining and the powers and resources available to their regulators are markedly different, and political changes are not conducive to sustaining regional cooperation.
asserted
changes → sustain → cooperation
Mr. Lula’s fourth term could thus keep ACTO going, especially on cross-border enforcement and in preserving a forum for governments to negotiate on conflicting political priorities.
uncertain
governments → keep → priorities
But given the divergent economic incentives and weak national institutions, lasting change means ACTO also developing common monitoring and financing arrangements.
asserted
ACTO → give → arrangements
On a more global level, Brazil has come to play a major role in climate negotiations because of its simultaneous status as a major oil producer and, especially under Lula, a strong advocate of international climate cooperation.
asserted
Brazil → come → cooperation
In fact, the day after Mr. Lula’s election win, the Netherlands announced that it intends to contribute up to $500 million over a decade, on certain conditions, to Brazil’s ‘Tropical Forest Forever Facility’ (TFFF).
asserted
it → announce → Facility
The pledge brings the sum of commitments announced thus far to $7.8 billion, against the target of $10 billion by the end of 2026.
asserted
pledge → bring → 2026
Lula’s continuing government will help establish the TFFF in its formative years and steady its hand as a potentially new international financial institution.
asserted
government → continue → institution
In the same spirit, Colombia and the Netherlands convened the first international conference dedicated to transitioning away from fossil fuels in April.
asserted
Colombia → convene → April
Fifty-seven countries, including Brazil, participated to develop proposals for financial cooperation, among other matters, and planned for a second meeting in 2027.
As well, at the COP30 climate talks that Brazil presided over last year, Mr. Lula supported proposals to develop an international roadmap to transition away from fossil fuels, drawing support from more than 80 countries, but the summit could not see through due to opposition from Russia and Saudi Arabia, among others.
uncertain
summit → include → others
The April conference has thus emerged as a parallel mechanism to effect action.
asserted
conference → emerge → action
The EU and the South American trade bloc signed their interim trade and partnership agreements in January.
asserted
EU → sign → January
The latter’s ratification will be significant because they require governments to comply with the Paris Agreement — and could allow Mr. Lula’s climate diplomacy to work through UN negotiations as well as trade and investment relationships to create longer-lasting economic commitments.
uncertain
diplomacy → require → commitments
On the flip side, it may also create greater incentives to convert forestland for other use, so Lula and his peers will have to institute more effective protections.
uncertain
Lula → create → protections
All this said, while preserving cooperation is essential to effective climate action, it will amount to little if it does not also cut emissions.
asserted
it → say → emissions
In fact, continuity in international climate diplomacy could prevent regression without also yielding the acceleration required to meet climate goals.
uncertain
continuity → prevent → goals
The UN Environment Programme has already found that even if all countries deliver on their pledges vis-à-vis the Paris Agreement, the world is on course to warming by 2.6°C by the end of the century.
asserted
world → find → century
Brazil’s incoming conservative Congress is also likely to constrain the Lula government’s ability to sustain expenditure — even if his term provides continuity through 2030, an important year that numerous climate-related commitments use as a deadline or milestone year.
asserted
commitments → constrain → deadline
That Mr. Lula’s win is a record also raises the prospect of policy whiplash, especially against programmes that depend on his personal political authority, when his last term ends.
asserted
term → raise → authority
The Aporia
