Carney's geopolitical ambitions tested in defence industry co-operation with Turkey
asserted
ambitions → test → Turkey
Developing partnership allows Canada to lessen dependence on U.S. military suppliers
While in Istanbul this past week, Prime Minister Mark Carney struggled for a moment when asked to describe how he felt about limits that had been placed on Ukraine's access to the Starshield military-grade satellite network.
asserted
that → develop → network
When he found his voice, he spoke about the "immense human suffering" of missile strikes on Kyiv and elsewhere.
asserted
he → find → Kyiv
"I search for the right adjective to describe whoever took this decision, or a group of people took this decision, against a country — and it's against a country that is literally fighting for the lives of its citizens against naked aggression.
asserted
that → search → aggression
"
Carney was, however, quick to turn it into an object lesson for Canadians who are skeptical of warming relations with authoritarian-leaning Turkey.
asserted
who → turn → Turkey
"We as Canadians do not want to be caught in a situation where we are reliant on one provider that may change their view, or may be forced to change their views, by one nation state that puts Canadians at risk — or compromises our sovereignty, our ability to express our values and live our values.”
uncertain
that → want → values
Early last week, Ukrainian officials said they had lost some of their access to Starshield, the military version of Starlink, the global satellite communications system owned and operated by Elon Musk's company SpaceX.
Ukraine employs Starshield to both track incoming missiles and jet-powered drones, and to guide interceptor and spy drones, while using Starlink for critical internal communications.
asserted
Ukraine → say → communications
Without mentioning the United States or the Trump administration, Carney's reference was clear: We don't want to find ourselves in the same situation as Ukraine.
asserted
We → mention → Ukraine
Canadian officials have made no secret of wanting to reduce reliance on Starlink in favour of a future Telesat system.
asserted
officials → make → system
Much of Carney’s recent whirlwind trip to Istanbul and the Turkish capital, Ankara, was framed through the lens of the contradiction of values-based Canadians cosying up to a regime that shuts down opposition television stations, arrests journalists and attacks 2SLGBTQ+ advocates.
asserted
that → frame → advocates
What was mentioned as part of a strategic partnership signed by Carney — but received far less scrutiny — is the burgeoning defence-industrial co-operation between the two countries, which arguably is an early test of Carney's geopolitical ambitions.
asserted
which → mention → ambitions
"Canada-Turkey defence co-operation is an early test of whether the middle-power co-ordination the prime minister called for at Davos can produce anything more durable than a sequence of transactions,” wrote Tolga Demiryol, an associate professor of political science at Altınbaş University in Istanbul.
asserted
Demiryol → call → Istanbul
He was referring to Carney's speech at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, in January.
asserted
He → refer → January
A research paper penned by Demiryol was published on the Canadian Global Affairs Institute website in early October.
asserted
paper → pen → October
He said both countries now share a similar outlook when it comes to the defence industry as an instrument of national sovereignty.
asserted
it → say → sovereignty
"Canada is seeking to reduce the concentration of its defence procurement in the United States, while Turkey's industry was built through repeated efforts to escape foreign control over critical components and export permissions," Demiryol wrote.
asserted
Demiryol → seek → components
"Turkey is courted today for two reasons: it has more to offer than it once did; and Canada has more reason than it once had to look beyond the United States.
asserted
it → court → States
Demiryol also said Carney is is not searching "for a replacement partner, but rather to reduce Canadian exposure to any single foreign supplier.
asserted
is → say → supplier
In addition to it being an early test of Carney's middle-power strategy, the defence partnership represents a leap of faith.
asserted
partnership → represent → faith
Not many years have passed since the events that sent relations between Canada and Turkey into the wilderness.
asserted
that → pass → wilderness
In 2020, Turkish authorities applied for an exemption related to the importation of target acquisition gear, made by Canadian company Wescam, used in Turkey's Bayraktar drones.
asserted
authorities → apply → drones
Documents made public stated that Turkish authorities claimed they were using the cameras for reconnaissance activities related to NATO operations in the north of Syria.
But it was later discovered that the cameras were illegally diverted to Azerbaijan and used during the war in Nagorno-Karabakh.
asserted
cameras → make → Karabakh
Human rights groups accused Turkey of lying to the Canadian government.
asserted
groups → accuse → government
The de facto arms embargo that resulted was lifted in early 2024 when Canada's Department of Foreign Affairs stopped presumptively denying arms export permits to the Middle Eastern country.
asserted
Department → result → country
While trust has been restored, Carney made clear following talks with Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan that the agreement signed on Thursday does not mean unfettered exports and that permits will be reviewed on a case-by-case basis.
"We have standards, we have rules and we will follow them, we will continue to follow them," Carney said.
asserted
Carney → restore → them
The short answer is the country's capacity to go from reliance on foreign defence contractors to building its own equipment in a short period of time.
asserted
answer → go → time
"An important point here, I believe that in Turkey, about 80 per cent of the defence needs of this country are produced here.
asserted
cent → believe → country
This is not the case in Canada," Carney said.
asserted
Carney → say → Canada
"So there are a lot of lessons for us on how we can create an industry in our country.
asserted
we → be → country
It is also the type of military equipment that Turkey is building that makes it attractive.
asserted
it → build → that
A Turkish TB2 drone is seen in Golcuk, Turkey, on Aug. 21.
asserted
drone → see → Aug.
The TB2, manufactured by Baykar — a private defence and tech company that Carney met with during his stop in Istanbul — proved itself in combat during the opening phase of the war in Ukraine by stopping Russian armoured columns with deadly precision strikes.
asserted
Carney → manufacture → strikes
The country is now manufacturing land and sea drones.
asserted
country → manufacture → drones
It is also developing its own next-generation fighter jet, known as KAAN.
asserted
It → develop → KAAN
Carney didn't rule out buying Turkish military equipment such as the TB2 but suggested the country's know-how and ability to integrate technologies will be important as Canada expands it own industry.
uncertain
Canada → rule → industry
"We're in a position where we're more in need of Turkish expertise in terms of reinforcing what we need to do to protect Canadians and to serve as a full NATO ally at this stage," Carney said.
asserted
Carney → reinforce → stage
Investment in Canada
Mike Ward, executive director of the Canada Turkey Business Council, said direct investment is another attractive aspect for the prime minister.
asserted
investment → say → minister
Last year, four major Turkish defence companies visited the Toronto Global Forum and pitched investment in Canada's aerospace sector, among others.
asserted
companies → visit → others
"They said, 'Look, we want to do business with Canada.
asserted
we → say → Canada
And sure ... Canadian companies can invest in Turkey if you'd like.
asserted
you → invest → Turkey
…and 8 more, not listed.
The Aporia
