Carney says 'direct casualties' are result of Ukraine's restricted access to Musk's Starshield
PM criticizes 'whoever' decided to limit Ukraine's ability to track Russian strikes
Prime Minister Mark Carney on Friday criticized a decision to restrict Ukraine's access to Elon Musk's military-grade satellite network, saying the move is costing lives.
asserted
move → say → lives
"I search for the right adjective to describe whoever took this decision, or a group of people took this decision, against a country … that is literally fighting for the lives of its citizens against naked aggression," Carney said in Istanbul.
"So are we concerned?
asserted
we → search → Istanbul
Early last week, Ukrainian officials said they had lost some of their access to Starshield, the military version of Starlink, the global satellite communications system owned and operated by Musk's company SpaceX.
Ukraine employs Starshield to both track incoming missiles and jet-powered drones, and to guide interceptor and spy drones, while using Starlink for critical internal communications.
asserted
Ukraine → say → communications
Reuters reported last week that, according to two U.S. officials, the order to restrict the system came from inside the White House.
uncertain
order → report → House
The Wall Street Journal, meanwhile, reported on Wednesday that the restrictions were ordered personally by Musk.
asserted
restrictions → report → Musk
Musk said that Starshield was owned and controlled by the U.S. government, and that any restrictions are decided by the U.S. military and, ultimately, by U.S. President Donald Trump.
asserted
restrictions → say → Trump
The commercial Starlink system, he said, was not designed or authorized for military use.
asserted
he → say → use
Trump has denied ordering the restrictions.
asserted
Trump → deny → restrictions
On Friday, Trump said he's unaware of who did, and wouldn't tell even if he knew.
asserted
he → say → Friday
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy says that since Starshield's capacity had been restricted, his country has been unable to track drones and missiles travelling faster than 160 kilometres per hour.
asserted
country → say → hour
Ukraine says Starshield not restored
Zelenskyy says those restrictions have complicated Ukraine's efforts to repel Russian missile and jet drone attacks — resulting in the deaths of civilians, including children.
Carney agreed with that assessment, saying it now "does seem clear" the restrictions have "real consequences, human consequences" and that some recent deaths in Ukraine are "direct casualties as a consequence of this reduced ability."
asserted
deaths → say → ability
"I just refer in the last 36 hours to the attack at the centre of Kyiv," Carney said.
asserted
Carney → refer → Kyiv
On Thursday, Trump said that Musk has since restored Ukraine's access to the satellite network.
asserted
Musk → say → network
But Zelenskyy contradicted that claim in an interview with CNN saying "it still doesn't work."
uncertain
it → contradict → CNN
Ukrainian military officials also said on Friday that the restrictions on Starshield remain in place.
asserted
restrictions → say → place
In an interview with NBC's Meet The Press on Sunday, Zelenskyy was asked directly who he thought was to blame for the Starshield restrictions.
asserted
he → ask → restrictions
"It’s [the] opinion of our generals, of our government and of course my also opinion … that it was the message from American government to limit this speed, and technically SpaceX did it."
asserted
SpaceX → ’ → it
Zelenskyy said.
asserted
Zelenskyy → say → ?
The warning for Canada
The restriction of Starshield comes amid a low point in relations between Kyiv and Washington as Trump seeks to push Ukraine into accepting stronger concessions in a peace deal.
asserted
Trump → come → deal
Trump has also been pressuring Ukraine to halt strikes on Russian oil refineries, although Starshield is not used on drones conducting those attacks as it does not operate over Russian territory.
asserted
it → pressure → territory
Without mentioning Trump, Carney said that relying on an ally "that may change their view" puts Canadians at risk.
uncertain
that → mention → risk
"Once you realize that, as we have, this government has, it leads to a series of decisions and partnerships that are necessary in order to diversify and to build up sovereign capabilities within Canada or with partners," he said.
asserted
he → realize → partners
Diversifying Canada's defence partnerships, Carney said, will take time "because we're starting from a position where we're highly, highly reliant on certain systems in certain countries."
asserted
we → diversify → countries
Zelenskyy is already working to move away from his country's reliance on the U.S. satellite network, signing a letter of intent with Finnish companies Nokia and ICEYE on Thursday to develop Ukraine's own satellite communications network.
asserted
Zelenskyy → work → network
The Aporia
