It's been a difficult week for even the most hardened of politicians in Western Australia, with an increase in hostility at their workplace prompting plenty of soul searching.
asserted
increase → prompt → searching
Energy Minister Amber-Jade Sanderson, not one to back down from a debate, was visibly shaken as she arrived at Parliament the day after staff at colleague Hannah Beazley's office were allegedly threatened.
uncertain
staff → back → office
"It is becoming more and more challenging to do this job," Ms Sanderson said.
asserted
Sanderson → become → job
"I love being an accessible member of Parliament, but I've certainly noticed over the last two years in particular it's getting harder and harder to do that."
asserted
it → love → that
A similar sentiment was shared by almost every MP who spoke this week.
Among them, police officer-turned-Labor backbencher Mark Folkard, who has had a front row seat to the best and worst of the state for decades and revealed he was dealing with a stalker.
"Everyone's saying let's take the heat down, but what's the driver of the heat?
asserted
driver → share → heat
That's the question we've got to be asking," Mr Folkard said.
asserted
Folkard → get → ?
These conversations were sparked by an attack on federal independent MP Helen Haines outside her Victorian electorate office on Monday.
asserted
conversations → spark → Monday
It's not yet clear what motivated 43-year-old Brendan Nugent to allegedly run her down in an incident which has now taken both of her legs.
uncertain
which → motivate → legs
Investigations were also continuing into John Lawrence Smart, who has been charged with threatening staff at state Labor MP Hannah Beazley's office on Tuesday.
asserted
who → continue → Tuesday
A magistrate said the 56-year-old had been diagnosed with schizophrenia previously.
asserted
old → say → schizophrenia
It's already sparking a conversation about the role of mental ill health in all of this.
And it also comes against the background of 20-year-old Jayson Joseph Michaels being charged in February with planning an attack on public buildings, including Parliament House.
asserted
Michaels → spark → House
Taken together, they have served as clear reminders for MPs, and those around them, of the risks which come with their jobs.
asserted
which → take → jobs
"This week has been a dark week for democracy in Australia," first-term Liberal MP Adam Hort said.
"Any MP that has to second-guess being available for their community is awful."
Democracy and dehumanisation
And yet that is the situation many have found themselves in.
asserted
many → say → themselves
Almost every MP who spoke was grappling with how to balance the risks to them, their staff and their families with the need to spend time with those they represent.
asserted
they → speak → those
It's a question which goes to the heart of our democracy: how can MPs do their jobs if they aren't accessible to their constituents?
asserted
they → go → constituents
It particularly goes to the heart of the future of our democracy, too, in turbulent times marred by falling trust in institutions.
asserted
It → go → institutions
"There has been a loss of trust, let's face it, and I think that gets worse if we can't engage with people on a day-to-day basis
asserted
we → let → basis
," Opposition Leader Angus Taylor told 102.5 ABC Perth on Friday.
asserted
Taylor → tell → Friday
WA Deputy Premier Rita Saffioti said she too had noticed a shift, with policy debates becoming more "extreme".
asserted
debates → say → shift
"I'm all for debating policy and facts, but what happens is, in some of these policy debates, people start dehumanising politicians," Ms Saffioti said on Tuesday.
asserted
Saffioti → debate → Tuesday
Government minister John Carey, who acknowledged he was a particular target of abuse because of his housing portfolio and because he is openly gay, believes that dehumanisation leads to further escalation.
asserted
dehumanisation → acknowledge → escalation
"People do not understand that their words in social media then create an environment which I think then enables other people, or empowers other people, to take violence, or to be aggressive, against anyone in the public sphere,"Mr Carey said.
asserted
Carey → understand → anyone
One antidote to that dehumanisation, some MPs have found, is putting an even greater focus on meeting voters in person.
asserted
MPs → find → person
Social media is no replacement for a face-to-face conversation, which can remind people that politicians are human too.
asserted
politicians → remind → people
It means one of the ways to combat the current shift towards more escalation is the very thing being made harder and less safe by that same drift towards escalation.
asserted
one → mean → escalation
But that doesn't change how people feel, in their hearts and minds, and the anxiety they feel after an attack," Police Commissioner Col Blanch said on Thursday.
asserted
Blanch → change → Thursday
"So it's really about giving advice and guidance on how to look after yourselves, and what to look out for."
asserted
it → give → yourselves
The ABC understands that is the advice MPs have started receiving in briefings.
asserted
MPs → understand → briefings
Commissioner Blanch said he hoped it would help give politicians confidence to keep making themselves available.
asserted
themselves → say → confidence
"It's important as high-profile people, even as the Police Commissioner, we maintain our presence in our community, we be part of our community," he said.
asserted
he → maintain → community
"And it's not a time to knee-jerk and disappear our presence from our community."
More security, but no easy fix
That doesn't mean that some things will have to change.
asserted
things → jerk → community
In response to concerns being raised by MPs, even before this week, the government today announced it would fund security upgrades at their personal homes.
asserted
it → raise → homes
A security review of Parliament will also be fast-tracked, in addition to providing politicians with an extra electorate officer.
asserted
review → track → officer
One Nation's WA leader, Rod Caddies, who said he had been threatened while driving home the day after Dr Haines was attacked, was cautious about going too far down that path.
"[It's] just treating a symptom of a problem that's there.
asserted
that → say → problem
We need to always be looking to treat a cause and not the symptom," Mr Caddies said.
asserted
Caddies → need → cause
Finding agreement on what those underlying causes are, let alone how to fix them, is far from easy.
asserted
causes → find → them
But the events of this week have reminded everyone in the political arena that trying to do that is more important than ever.
asserted
trying → remind → that
The Aporia
