For the second time this year, James Talarico, the Texas Democratic candidate for the U.S. Senate, appeared on a late-night talk show only to get bumped from the nightly broadcast.
asserted
Talarico → appear → broadcast
In each case, both the hosts and the network seemingly buckled to pressure from President Donald Trump and the Federal Communications Commission (FCC).
asserted
hosts → buckle → Trump
And just like in that earlier case, it provides a perfect example of why we should abolish the equal time rule.
asserted
we → provide → rule
"I'll be interviewing James Talarico tomorrow night under unusual circumstances," Jimmy Kimmel said Wednesday on his ABC talk show.
asserted
Kimmel → interview → show
But the TV audience would not see the segment because of fears that by airing it, ABC's affiliates could run afoul of the equal opportunities requirement, better known as the equal time rule.
uncertain
affiliates → see → rule
The equal time rule states that if a "legally qualified candidate for any public office" appears on a broadcast network in the weeks leading up to the election, then the network must "afford equal opportunities to all other such candidates for that office.
asserted
network → state → office
The rule exempts "bona fide" news coverage, like interviews or newscasts, and the FCC had extended "bona fide" exemptions to chat shows like Kimmel's since 1984.
asserted
FCC → exempt → 1984
But in January of this year, FCC Chairman Brendan Carr issued a directive that a broadcast could not be exempt if it was "motivated by partisan purposes."
uncertain
it → issue → purposes
Kimmel noted on Wednesday that he had interviewed numerous candidates for office throughout his show's two-decade run, including Trump himself.
asserted
he → note → Trump
"At the time, when he was the one sitting next to me, he seemed to have no problem with the idea of talk show hosts interviewing candidates," Kimmel said.
asserted
Kimmel → sit → candidates
Indeed, Trump appeared on Kimmel's show twice during his first run for the presidency, first in December 2015 and again in May 2016 just two months before the Republican Party officially made him their presidential nominee.
uncertain
him → appear → May
But "now that he's president, his FCC has threatened me, threatened our show, threatened our network, ABC, our affiliates, our local stations, based on simple traditional editorial decisions, guest bookings it would seem they don't like," Kimmel continued.
asserted
Kimmel → threaten → decisions
"And so out of consideration for all our local stations, especially our ABC affiliates in Texas, who would have to deal with this nonsense, my interview tomorrow with James Talarico will not air on television; it will be posted on YouTube instead.
asserted
it → have → YouTube
"The FCC wants to make it impossible for me to interview candidates by requiring that I interview every candidate on the ballot who asks for equal time," Kimmel noted the following night.
asserted
Kimmel → want → time
Not only would he have to offer an interview to Talarico's Republican opponent, embattled Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton—"which, by the way, I would love to do, call me," Kimmel quipped—but "our affiliates in Texas would have to give equal time to as many candidates as there are on the ballot."
asserted
affiliates → have → ballot
BallotPedia lists seven total candidates in Talarico's race.
asserted
BallotPedia → list → race
Kimmel's interview with Talarico hit the show's YouTube channel Thursday night.
asserted
interview → hit → channel
On a typical night, Kimmel's broadcast averages around 1.5 million viewers, while the YouTube video racked up more than 3.6 million views in its first 16 hours.
asserted
video → average → hours
If you have déjà vu, it's because this wasn't even the first time this happened: Talarico appeared on Stephen Colbert's CBS late-night show in February, only for the interview to be shunted to YouTube and streaming services when the network feared FCC reprisal.
asserted
network → have → reprisal
The Trump administration disputes Kimmel's story.
asserted
administration → dispute → story
"Jimmy Kimmel is play-acting—as he often does—to create a false narrative about this administration's policies," White House spokesperson Davis Ingle told The Wall Street Journal.
asserted
Ingle → act → Journal
"Chairman Carr has not threatened him regarding interviewing James Talarico, or any other candidate."
That specificity is important, as Carr has threatened Kimmel numerous times.
asserted
Carr → threaten → Kimmel
Last year, Carr infamously got Kimmel pulled from the air for a week after the host made an intemperate joke about the slain conservative activist Charlie Kirk.
asserted
host → get → activist
"We can do this the easy way or the hard way," Carr told podcaster Benny Johnson, warning broadcasters to "find ways to change conduct and take action, frankly, on Kimmel" or face FCC reprisal.
asserted
Carr → do → reprisal
Carr has also threatened ABC on this very subject.
asserted
Carr → threaten → subject
Earlier this year, after Talarico appeared on ABC daytime chat show The View, Carr threatened to revoke the show's equal time exemption, and the FCC even directed the ABC affiliate in Houston to file "a petition for declaratory ruling" on whether the interview violated the equal time rule.
asserted
interview → appear → rule
And then, of course, the FCC called in ABC's affiliate licenses for review years ahead of schedule, which one free speech organization called "illegal jawboning."
asserted
organization → call → which
Taken together, these examples suggest that Carr treats the FCC's purview as primarily the defenders of Trump's feelings.
asserted
Carr → take → feelings
Trump, of course, has also criticized Kimmel repeatedly over the years and called for him to be fired.
asserted
him → criticize → years
The entire affair demonstrates why the equal time rule is so outdated and ripe to be abolished.
asserted
rule → demonstrate → ?
The rule originated in the age of radio, and it came to include TV at a time when that consisted of only a handful of broadcast networks.
asserted
that → originate → networks
Since there were only a small number of outlets broadcasting over theoretically finite airwaves, the government required that each network serve "the public interest."
asserted
network → be → interest
In fact, at the time of this writing, Kimmel's YouTube channel has over 22 million subscribers and 15.6 billion total views across 8,000 videos—an average of 2 million views per video.
asserted
channel → have → video
And that's to say nothing of how many people watch clips from the show on its social media channels, like Instagram or TikTok.
asserted
people → say → Instagram
The suggestion that broadcasters still have a responsibility to present a perfectly balanced roster of guests—or at least, as many guests as the administration in power deems balanced—is not only outdated, it's offensive to America's free speech principles.
asserted
it → present → principles
No TV show should be required to host any particular guest, nor should they be forbidden from having someone on.
asserted
they → require → someone
The equal time rule should be abolished.
asserted
rule → abolish → ?
The Aporia
