Israeli settlers steal Palestinians' olives as attacks on harvest grow more violent
LUBBAN AL-GHARBI, West Bank, Oct 22 -
asserted
attacks → steal → harvest
Brought to tears as he recalled Israeli settlers hitting his cherished olive trees with sticks and taking off with the olives, Palestinian Ahmed Salem said he feared being attacked if he tried to intervene.
asserted
he → bring → olives
Settlers have intimidated Palestinians harvesting their olives in the occupied West Bank for decades, but this year, not only has violence increased sharply, theft has been widespread, according to Palestinians, Israeli rights groups and the UN.
uncertain
theft → intimidate → Palestinians
The settlers dumped Salem's olives into sacks and then drove them to a nearby Israeli settler outpost to be pressed into olive oil, the 50-year-old Palestinian told Reuters of the incident around two weeks ago near his village Lubban al-Gharbi.
asserted
Palestinian → dump → village
"How would you feel if something that belonged to you was being violated, and you could do nothing about it?" he asked.
uncertain
he → feel → it
The couple living in the outpost, whose olive press settlers have urged Israelis to use for West Bank olives, declined multiple Reuters requests for comment, while the Yesha Council, which oversees Israeli settlements in the West Bank, did not immediately respond.
The attacks have accelerated ahead of an Israeli election next week that opinion polls show Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his pro-settler coalition could lose to opponents who have taken a more critical stance against settler violence.
uncertain
who → live → violence
'SETTLERS CAN COME AND GO FREELY'
asserted
SETTLERS → come → ?
The olive harvest starts with the onset of cooler weather, allowing Palestinian families to gather in the lush, terraced groves that they have groomed for generations.
"My six-year-old son remembers going there with me, eating there, making tea there," Salem said.
asserted
Salem → start → tea
With the establishment of hundreds of small settler outposts under Netanyahu's government since 2022, the military has increasingly restricted Palestinian access to areas nearby, including many olive groves.
asserted
military → restrict → groves
"This creates a situation where Palestinians, in many of the cases, many of the lands, especially in proximity to settlements and outposts, cannot enter the land and harvest the trees," said Ziv Stahl, executive director of Israeli rights group Yesh Din.
asserted
Stahl → create → Din
"But settlers can come and go freely, and that's what they do."
Even when Palestinians can access their trees, it is not without risk.
asserted
it → come → risk
Yesh Din on Wednesday reported 125 physical attacks on Palestinian olive harvesters over the 24 days since the season began and 168 incidents of crop theft, with Israeli military forces present in at least a quarter of cases.
asserted
forces → report → cases
An Israeli military official said it takes acts of violence, criminal activity and attempts to undermine security very seriously.
asserted
it → say → security
The official did not refer to settlers or comment on the reports of olive theft in the presence of the Israeli military, which has separately uprooted trees with excavators, citing what it said was a need to prevent Palestinian attacks.
asserted
it → refer → attacks
The removal of Palestinians' olives has met with widely differing responses from Israeli rabbis.
asserted
removal → meet → rabbis
"I call it theft.
asserted
I → call → it
From my perspective, I define it as theft or robbery, and it is forbidden," said Zev Weitman, the rabbi for the Alon Shvut settlement south of Bethlehem.
asserted
Weitman → define → Bethlehem
Prominent Orthodox rabbi Dov Lior said settlers should harvest across the West Bank, asserting in an open letter that Palestinians had no ownership rights to the land and that harvesting olives fulfilled "the commandment of conquering the land.
asserted
harvesting → say → land
"
'IT'S EITHER US OR OUR ENEMY', SETTLERS SAY ON SOCIAL MEDIA
Hundreds of acres of the land around Salem's village, Lubban al-Gharbi, including olive groves, were fenced off and seized between 2023 and 2026 by Avichai Farm, an Israeli settler outpost built on a nearby hill.
asserted
Hundreds → say → hill
Salem said villagers have seen settlers harvest olives from the seized land and take them to the outpost's olive press.
asserted
settlers → say → press
At the start of the olive harvest, settlers posted on social media calling on Israelis to harvest West Bank olives and bring them to Avichai Farm's press.
asserted
settlers → post → press
"Both fine oil and strengthening the Jewish hold on the vast expanses of our land!," read a message on a settler Telegram group.
asserted
message → strengthen → group
The press at Avichai Farm advertises "premium products produced by Avichai Farm" with olive oil at about $20 a bottle via a website run by the Farms Association, a settler group that Reuters has reported receives significant financial support from the Israeli government, which says the aim is to promote peace.
asserted
aim → advertise → peace
The Farms Association did not immediately respond to a request for comment and the couple who live on the farm with their children declined to be interviewed by a Reuters reporter who approached the area on Sunday.
asserted
who → respond → Sunday
On a road leading to Avichai Farm, Reuters spoke to a man who declined to be identified and said he had driven from a settlement around 90 minutes away to press 14 bags of olives from trees he said he grew himself.
asserted
he → lead → trees
Lubban al-Gharbi villagers and other Palestinians who have lost land to settler expansion say the harvesting of olives from trees in groves seized from Palestinian land constitutes theft.
asserted
harvesting → lose → theft
UN bodies and most countries deem Israel's settlements on land occupied in war illegal under international law regarding military occupations.
asserted
settlements → deem → occupations
Israel rejects this, viewing the territory as disputed rather than occupied.
asserted
Israel → reject → territory
'WE PAY IN BLOOD FOR THE OLIVES'
asserted
WE → pay → OLIVES
During this year's olive harvest, Palestinian authorities say three Palestinians have been killed in daily militant settler attacks, which have also injured several journalists, European diplomats and a French mayor.
asserted
which → say → journalists
Stahl from the Yesh Din Israeli rights group said the violence was "part of a campaign of ethnic cleansing, paving the way for the annexation of the West Bank without its Palestinian population."
asserted
violence → say → population
Israel, which has considered the idea of annexation, said it is investigating some of the incidents.
asserted
it → consider → incidents
An Israeli government spokesperson said olives "picked by a Jew in the ancestral homeland of the Jewish people" did not constitute theft and that Jews owned and cultivated "millions of olive trees" in the area.
asserted
Jews → say → area
No one should take the law into their own hands, the spokesperson added.
asserted
spokesperson → take → hands
Palestinian farmer Samer Ben Shamsi said masked settlers attacked him on October 9 in the Palestinian village of Beita near Nablus, then sped away in a pickup truck with his harvest of olives after he and other farmers fled.
asserted
he → say → olives
"This year, they steal without fear because they have a state and a powerful force backing them," Ben Shamsi said, referring to the security forces.
asserted
Shamsi → steal → forces
Within the past year alone, settlers had shot him in the leg, beaten him and smashed his possessions, he said.
asserted
he → shoot → possessions
"We pay in blood for the olives."
asserted
We → pay → olives
The Aporia
