Questioning the prevailing narrative about the "Cornell seven" case is bound to create controversy.
asserted
Questioning → question → controversy
And at Columbia University, two student journalists drew condemnation for their views on the case from the unlikeliest of places: a college free speech group.
asserted
journalists → draw → places
On October 13, Barnard junior Christina Ma and Columbia junior Nikos Mohammadi published an article called "The 'Cornell Seven' Is Really About Liberalism" in the Columbia Sundial, an independent student publication.
asserted
Seven → publish → Sundial
The piece argued that the discourse surrounding the alleged rape at Cornell University infantilizes women by omitting the possibility that in a post–sexual revolution, liberal society, women may make regrettable but consensual choices.
uncertain
women → argue → choices
"In the world that, for better or worse, follows from it, we cannot claim to stand for sexual freedom and then recoil in disgust when there's a possibility that a young woman simply chose to exercise it," Mohammadi and Ma wrote.
uncertain
Mohammadi → follow → it
The piece also argues that the "collective frenzy" over the Cornell case has created a climate on campus that makes it "difficult to disagree with the maximalist position on what happened" the night of the alleged rape.
asserted
what → argue → rape
As Mohammadi wrote in UnHerd, the piece caused immense backlash.
asserted
piece → write → backlash
He said he received an onslaught of messages urging him to commit suicide and demanding that his "career and life be destroyed."
asserted
career → say → suicide
But the criticism went beyond threatening DMs and comments.
asserted
criticism → go → DMs
The day after the article's publication, the Columbia Open Discourse Alliance (CODA) canceled an event about press freedom because the Sundial's editor in chief, Nick Baum, had been slated to speak at the event.
asserted
editor → cancel → event
Although Baum did not author the piece, CODA wrote in an Instagram post that the free speech group "refused" to be affiliated with the Sundial's article "in any way."
asserted
group → author → way
CODA also claimed that the event, ironically called "Who Gets to Tell the Story? Press Freedom and the Public Square," could not take place at a time when "many survivors in our community feel that their stories are under attack and are not being believed."
uncertain
stories → claim → attack
The group added that the Sundial's article "promotes rape culture and works to silence survivors of sexual assault."
The group's president, Aum Desai, told Columbia's student newspaper, the Columbia Daily Spectator, that the group canceled the event "not in spite of, but because of [CODA's] commitment to free expression."
Columbia graduate Clayton Smith, who founded CODA in 2025, quickly commented that he was "shocked" by CODA's statements on Instagram.
asserted
he → add → Instagram
Smith started the organization to create a central hub for groups hosting events promoting free speech and open discourse, including the Sundial and Columbia's Heterodox Academy chapter.
asserted
Smith → start → Sundial
He tells Reason that CODA's rationale for canceling the event was "ironic" and "hypocritical," and he believes the group should have collaborated with the Sundial if there were legitimate safety concerns at the event.
asserted
group → tell → event
He says he was particularly disturbed by the group's condemnation of the article and CODA's claim that it promotes "rape culture."
uncertain
it → say → culture
"They don't argue or explain how it works to silence survivors of sexual assault.
asserted
it → argue → assault
It is a baseless slander that they use to condemn the article because it promoted an opinion they do not like," Smith says.
asserted
Smith → use → opinion
Smith says he spoke to Desai on the phone after CODA posted the statements, and Desai tried to reassure him that CODA would uphold the principle of free speech.
asserted
CODA → say → speech
But Smith says he did not leave the phone call feeling "very confident at all" in Desai's commitment.
asserted
he → say → commitment
Desai did not respond to Reason's requests for comment.
asserted
Desai → respond → comment
CODA faculty adviser and Columbia Business School professor emeritus Eli Noam was traveling in China during the fallout from the Sundial article and was not involved in CODA's decision.
asserted
Noam → travel → decision
After speaking with members of both CODA and the Sundial, Noam tells Reason that he thinks CODA "made some proper decisions, some correct decisions, and some mistakes.
asserted
CODA → speak → decisions
"
"I think we're dealing here with…a group of college students who kind of were confronted with a crisis at 2 a.m.," Noam says.
asserted
Noam → think → a.m.
"And kind of [made] some judgments that they now regret, and they do."
asserted
they → make → that
He tells Reason that it was not "unreasonable to assume there would be a disruption" at the event, given the climate at Columbia and "about this rape allegation."
asserted
it → tell → allegation
He says the group suddenly "had an event where they needed college security" and could not organize in time.
uncertain
they → say → time
CODA, Noam says, is not yet recognized by the university, and he thinks the group was likely fearful of jeopardizing its recognition.
asserted
group → say → recognition
Still, Noam says CODA's statements condemning the article were "unreasonable," and it was "disappointing that they kind of lost their nerve here."
Although he was not involved in planning the panel, Mohammadi says, to his knowledge, there were no credible threats of violence to the panel.
asserted
Mohammadi → say → panel
He understood there may have been "disgruntled students" and an "environment CODA did not want to deal with."
uncertain
CODA → understand → ?
But instead of simply canceling the event or working with the Sundial to find a solution, Mohammadi says CODA overstepped by condemning the Sundial piece.
asserted
CODA → cancel → piece
James Applegate, an astronomy professor who serves on Columbia's Academic Freedom Council (CAFC) alongside Noam, tells Reason that he disagreed with CODA's decision to cancel the event.
asserted
he → serve → event
Applegate tells Reason he was considering attending the event, and he was "rather surprised and disappointed" when it was canceled.
asserted
it → tell → event
He recalled that when he was a professor in 2000, he objected to changes to the school's sexual misconduct policy on the University Senate floor.
asserted
he → recall → floor
He says his statements were "similar to what was said in the Sundial article" and there was a "level of emotion in this debate."
asserted
what → say → debate
"Nonetheless, we had the debate.
asserted
we → have → debate
I was in it, and the degree to which it was civil is shocking when you look at where we are now.
asserted
we → look → which
Applegate said he does not condemn CODA, however, "for the simple reason that the atmosphere on college campuses and on the left wing of politics in general in the United States is quite vicious."
asserted
atmosphere → say → States
CODA's honorary faculty fellow John McWhorter tells Reason he interpreted CODA's statement as "saying that an event about who gets to tell the story is untenable when or if a critical mass of people with such stories don't even feel comfortable telling them— i.e.being a participant in the event."
asserted
mass → tell → event
He added, "I imagine some might think of that as cutting the salami a little thin, but then I highly suspect that Desai is equally worried about the event becoming a physical melee of some kind.
uncertain
event → add → kind
…and 11 more, not listed.
The Aporia
