Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has refused to say whether he approved or was aware of a 'dirt sheet' circulated by his office about independent MP Helen Haines.
asserted
he → refuse → Haines
Haines lost a leg and remains in a critical condition after she was allegedly rammed against her car by a Toyota LandCruiser and struck a second time outside her office in Wangaratta, in north-east Victoria, on Monday afternoon.
uncertain
she → lose → afternoon
Following the alleged incident, Albanese called for the political temperature to be lowered as he praised Haines and warned against unjustified attacks on politicians' motives.
asserted
he → follow → motives
The Daily Mail has since revealed that his office circulated a 'dirt sheet' to journalists just weeks before, raising questions about her integrity after she criticised a $6million government grant allocated to the Marrickville Golf Club in Sydney's inner west.
asserted
she → reveal → west
The document did not provide evidence of wrongdoing.
asserted
document → provide → wrongdoing
When asked about the document, which was obtained by the Daily Mail, Albanese did not answer the question and instead praised the independent MP.
asserted
Albanese → ask → MP
'Were you aware or [did you give] approval to your office to distribute to the press gallery information about Helen Haines?'
asserted
you → give → Haines
News24 host Kieran Gilbert asked on Wednesday.
asserted
Gilbert → ask → Wednesday
Albanese said: 'Helen Haines is a good local member.
asserted
Haines → say → ?
She put forward applications like other members do for grants, and that's what good local members do, and Helen Haines is a very strong advocate for her community.'
asserted
Haines → put → community
Anthony Albanese (pictured) refused to comment on the 'dirt sheet' circulated by his office about independent MP Helen Haines
Albanese's office circulated a list of funding requests and lines of questioning about Haines
Gilbert then redirected the interview to the file, asking: 'So did the office send that out?
asserted
office → picture → that
Do you regret that in hindsight, given the events of recent days?
asserted
you → regret → days
Albanese did not directly answer the question.
asserted
Albanese → answer → question
'Helen Haines is a strong advocate for her community, and she advocates for funding, just as the Coalition made more than 1,000 commitments worth $1.644 billion during the election campaign,' he said.
asserted
he → advocate → campaign
'That's what local members do for their local communities.'
asserted
members → do → communities
It follows previous revelations from the Daily Mail that Albanese's office circulated a document to selected journalists about a month before Haines was seriously injured in the alleged attack.
asserted
Haines → follow → attack
The sheet, which bore the name of the Prime Minister's deputy director of communications, catalogued funding requests made by Haines for projects in her regional Victorian electorate and suggested lines of inquiry for reporters.
uncertain
which → bear → reporters
It questioned whether Haines had received undeclared gifts, held business interests, accepted political donations or maintained personal relationships with organisations that could potentially benefit from government funding.
uncertain
that → question → funding
The briefing note supplied no evidence of wrongdoing.
asserted
note → supply → wrongdoing
Haines remains in a critical condition after she was struck by a vehicle outside her office
Daily Mail Political and Economics Editor Peter van Onselen said Albanese had failed to explain either the purpose of the document or his office's role in distributing it.
'
asserted
Albanese → remain → it
The PM was asked whether he knew about or approved the dirt file.
asserted
he → ask → file
He answered by praising Helen Haines,' he said.
asserted
he → answer → Haines
It leaves entirely unexplained why his office circulated insinuations about her integrity.
asserted
office → leave → integrity
This document appeared after Haines challenged the $6 million grant to the Prime Minister's local golf club.
asserted
Haines → appear → club
If the purpose wasn't to discredit her, what was it?
asserted
it → discredit → her
Albo has offered no explanation for either its timing or its contents.'
asserted
Albo → offer → timing
Van Onselen said the Prime Minister's defence of Haines during the interview sat uneasily alongside the contents of the briefing note.
asserted
defence → say → note
The PM now says advocating for local funding is what good MPs do.
asserted
MPs → say → what
Yet his office invited journalists to treat Haines' advocacy as grounds for suspicion about undeclared gifts and personal interests.
asserted
office → invite → gifts
'The dirt file had no evidence of undisclosed wrongdoing.
asserted
file → have → wrongdoing
He hasn't addressed that contradiction.
asserted
He → address → contradiction
'When I showed Helen the document at the time I received it, she was disgusted.
asserted
she → show → it
She was openly advocating for community projects, and suddenly found her personal integrity being questioned without supporting evidence.
asserted
integrity → advocate → evidence
'The Prime Minister's praise for her now is welcome, but it doesn't explain his office's disgraceful treatment of her then.'
asserted
it → explain → her
On Tuesday evening, Victoria Police charged 43-year-old Brendan Nugent over the alleged hit-and-run that left Haines seriously injured.
asserted
that → charge → Haines
He has been charged with dangerous driving causing serious injury and intentionally causing serious injury, following an investigation by detectives into the incident.
asserted
He → charge → incident
Police also laid a federal charge of causing harm to a Commonwealth public official against Nugent, with a maximum sentence of 10 years behind bars if convicted.
asserted
Police → lay → bars
Nugent briefly appeared before Wangaratta Magistrates Court on Wednesday.
asserted
Nugent → appear → Wednesday
He did not apply for bail and was remanded in custody to face court again in February.
asserted
He → apply → February
The Aporia
