[This is one of the finalists in the 2026 book review contest, written by an ACX reader who will remain anonymous until after voting is done.
asserted
voting → write → reader
I’ll be posting about one of these a week for several months.
asserted
I → post → months
When you’ve read them all, I’ll ask you to vote for a favorite, so remember which ones you liked
asserted
you → read → ones
]
Holocaust stories, both true and fictional, tend to repeat the same few clichés over and over.
asserted
stories → tend → clichés
There’s the innocent child who only partially understands what’s happening (Diary of Anne Frank, Boy in the Striped Pajamas).
asserted
what → ’ → Pajamas
There’s the sentimental redemption story that focuses on a small individual act (Life is Beautiful, The Book Thief).
asserted
Life → ’ → act
You won’t find any of these tropes in The Escape Artist.
asserted
You → find → Artist
This 2022 book by Jonathan Freedland1 tells the true, and largely unknown, story of one of the few Jews ever to break out of Auschwitz.
asserted
book → tell → Auschwitz
The details of his improbable escape are remarkable enough, but what really makes the story fascinating is the way it so thoroughly defies every single expectation we have of a Holocaust narrative.
asserted
we → make → narrative
Its deeply unlikeable protagonist eventually alienates every friend and supporter he has, and dies a bitter old man, almost completely forgotten by history.
asserted
he → alienate → history
His story lacks not only good Germans, but even good non-Germans, with his harshest criticism saved not for the Nazis, not even for the dithering Allies, but for the Jewish leaders of Europe.
asserted
criticism → lack → Europe
And though one could see the story of his escape as a triumph, in his own telling, it’s a failure, for although he makes it out of Auschwitz against all odds, he fails at his larger mission: to stop the Holocaust.
uncertain
he → see → Holocaust
There’s no redemption here, no moral uplift, no lessons save for perhaps the grimmest and most nihilistic “lesson” I’ve ever encountered in any story, Holocaust-related or otherwise: that when confronted with the unthinkable, most people’s natural tendency is denial.
asserted
tendency → ’ → unthinkable
But we’re getting ahead of ourselves.
asserted
we → get → ourselves
To get out of Auschwitz, first you have to get into Auschwitz…
I.
Here’s a hot take for you: Auschwitz was bad.
asserted
Auschwitz → get → you
It was bad for all of its prisoners, of course, but it was the worst for the Jewish ones, who, if they survived at all, were held in harsher and more tightly controlled parts of the camp than everyone else.
asserted
they → survive → everyone
During the five years between Auschwitz’s opening in 1940 and its liberation by the Soviet Army in 1945, at least 900 prisoners attempted escape, and around 200 of them succeeded—but, because of their stricter confinement, only a handful were Jews2.
asserted
handful → attempt → confinement
And crazily enough, he goes to Auschwitz voluntarily.
asserted
he → go → Auschwitz
Of course, it’s not like he knows what he’s signing up for.
asserted
he → ’ → what
The Nazi line at the time—an illusion they go to great lengths to maintain3—is that the Jews deported from Europe are all being “resettled in the east.”
asserted
Jews → go → east
In 1942, when our story begins, Walter is a Slovak teenager, just eighteen years old.
asserted
Walter → begin → 1942
He’s being held at Majdanek, another Polish concentration camp, after two failed attempts to escape Nazi-occupied Czechoslovakia4.
asserted
He → hold → Czechoslovakia4
Majdanek itself is at this point “merely” a labor camp—not unheard of in wartime—though it will eventually become a death camp after Walter has left it behind.
asserted
Walter → become → it
The camp administrators seek volunteers for “farm work” elsewhere, and Walter is one of the first to raise his hand, despite the dire warnings from another prisoner: “Go there and you’ll die.”
asserted
you → seek → prisoner
It’s not that he doesn’t believe the warnings.
asserted
he → ’ → warnings
But he’s decided that being moved somewhere else, no matter where that somewhere else is, might bring an opportunity for escape.
uncertain
that → decide → escape
And from the moment the Nazi tanks first rolled into Czechoslovakia, Walter has been single-mindedly focused on escape5.
asserted
Walter → roll → escape5
Already, Walter has a sense that he’s different from the other prisoners—and, for that matter, from most people he knew back home in his hometown of Trnava.
asserted
he → have → Trnava
Why aren’t they doing anything? he wonders.
asserted
he → do → anything
Why aren’t they all trying to escape too?
asserted
they → try → ?
If Walter were alive today, one gets the sense he’d describe himself as high-agency and everyone else as NPCs.
asserted
he → get → NPCs
You Can Just Do Things, he believes, even when the thing in question is escaping from a concentration camp.
asserted
thing → do → camp
Maybe this is youth talking.
asserted
youth → talk → ?
Maybe it’s naivety.
asserted
it → ’ → ?
Or maybe Walter is simply, constitutionally, a difficult person: allergic to authority and already showing the same contrarian streak that will later get him fired from multiple academic jobs.
asserted
him → show → jobs
And so Walter goes to Auschwitz.
asserted
Walter → go → Auschwitz
The Nazis obviously do not actually believe their inscription on Auschwitz’s gates, that “work will set you free.”
asserted
work → believe → you
But this story is full of bitter ironies, and among them is that for Walter, signing up for this line of work actually is the first step toward his freedom.
asserted
signing → sign → freedom
As soon as the journey to Auschwitz begins, Walter starts having second thoughts.
asserted
Walter → begin → thoughts
Majdanek operates more or less in the open: situated right on the edge of Lublin, a midsize city, it’s visible to the general population and staffed by civilian workers who commute between the city and the camp.
asserted
who → operate → city
…and 261 more, not listed.
The Aporia
