On October 15, I published a post arguing that true "sensitive places" where guns are banned must have armed protection.
asserted
guns → publish → protection
The same day, a murderer broke into a "gun-free-zone" school in Oregan and began shooting children and teachers.
asserted
murderer → break → children
A dad of two girls at the school just happened to be driving by and grabbed his pistol, rushed into the school, and "neutralized" the killer with several shots.
asserted
dad → happen → shots
He was a concealed pistol licensee.
asserted
He → conceal → ?
It is located in Bend, Oregon.
asserted
It → locate → Bend
On October 15, a 16-year-old former special-needs student threw a shotgun over a fence outside the school and then scaled the fence.
asserted
student → throw → fence
A passerby verbally confronted the teenager, who fired three shots at his truck.
asserted
who → confront → truck
The driver called 911 at 12:59 p.m.
Kaylub Giamanco, a concealed pistol licensee, was also passing by when he saw the intruder shoot at the truck and then shoot the glass panes on two double doors to get inside the school.
asserted
intruder → call → school
He reached for his .40-caliber pistol and rushed in through the same door.
asserted
He → reach → door
But the killer had already shot and killed three boys and a teacher and wounded another boy and a teacher.
asserted
killer → shoot → boy
Another teacher threw a phone at the suspect, tackled him, and attempted to disarm him.
asserted
teacher → throw → him
As they struggled, Giamanco entered the room and shot the teen several times, killing him.
asserted
Giamanco → struggle → him
The killer fired as many as 15 rounds from a Maverick 88 12-gauge pump-action shotgun, which his mother had legally purchased.
asserted
mother → fire → which
He had 44 more shotshells on his person and in his backpack.
asserted
He → have → backpack
His devastation would have been far worse had not Giamanco intervened.
asserted
Giamanco → intervene → ?
Besides a round in the chamber, the Maverick 88 shotgun holds either five or seven rounds in the magazine, depending on the model.
asserted
shotgun → hold → model
Manufactured by Mossberg, the shotgun is typically used for protection and for hunting.
asserted
shotgun → manufacture → hunting
It would not be an "assault weapon" under any of the laws that ban them, which exempt pump-action firearms.
asserted
which → ban → firearms
Police arrived on the scene at 1:02 p.m. after being advised that the suspect had already been shot by a community member who had pursued the gunman.
asserted
who → arrive → gunman
An armed citizen had ended the tragedy minutes before police could arrive.
uncertain
police → end → tragedy
Oregon Governor Tina Kotek reacted to the event as follows:
asserted
Kotek → react → event
"To the community member who heroically intervened to stop further loss of life: Your actions carry a heavy emotional burden, and I just want you to know that my thoughts are with you as well."
asserted
thoughts → intervene → you
Just last year, Governor Kotek signed S.B. 243, the Community Safety Firearms Act, which her press release said "will help prevent mass shooting events in Oregon."
asserted
release → sign → Oregon
"This matters to every parent dropping their kid off at school," in her words.
asserted
This → matter → words
As revised by S.B. 243, Oregon law makes it a felony to possess a firearm in a public building, but if the building is a school, it is an affirmative defense that the person has a concealed handgun license, in which case it is a misdemeanor.
asserted
it → revise → license
However, a district school board "may adopt a policy providing that the affirmative defense … concerning persons licensed to carry a concealed handgun … does not apply to the possession of firearms on the grounds of the schools controlled by the board."
uncertain
defense → adopt → board
A board that adopts the policy must "Post a clearly visible sign, at all normal points of entry to the school grounds subject to the policy…."
asserted
that → adopt → policy
The only effect of this policy is to criminalize a concealed handgun licensee from possession of a handgun at a school.
asserted
effect → criminalize → school
It was already an offense for a member of the general public to possess a firearm at a school.
asserted
member → possess → school
Given that murder was already illegal, one would not expect a person intent on homicide to be dissuaded by a sign.
asserted
person → give → sign
Only 25 of the 197 school districts in Oregon have adopted this policy, one of them being the Bend-La Pine School District.
asserted
one → adopt → them
That policy prohibits school staff members, such as the teacher who threw her phone at the attacker, from being armed even if they are concealed pistol licensees.
asserted
they → prohibit → attacker
It also means that the brave community member who entered the school and ended the carnage would have violated the law, but for a "choice-of-evils" justification defense.
asserted
who → mean → defense
It was an emergency measure to avoid an imminent injury of such gravity that the desirability and urgency of avoiding the injury outweighed the desirability of avoiding the injury sought to be prevented by the statute defining the offense (ORS 161.200).
asserted
desirability → avoid → offense
Likewise, his use of deadly force was justified as the defense of third persons from what he reasonably believed to be the use of unlawful physical force (ORS 161.209).
asserted
he → justify → ORS
Those two provisions were held to warrant an adequate jury instruction in State v. Taylor (Ore. App. 1993), which was a self-defense case.
asserted
which → hold → Taylor
The lessons to be learned here are timeless.
asserted
lessons → learn → ?
Thomas Jefferson and other of our Founders recognized the wisdom of Cesare Beccaria, who wrote in On Crimes and Punishments (1764):
The laws that forbid the carrying of arms … disarm those only who are neither inclined nor determined to commit crimes.
asserted
who → recognize → crimes
Can it be supposed that those who have the courage to violate the most sacred laws of humanity … will respect the less important and arbitrary ones, which can be violated with ease and impunity….
asserted
which → suppose → ease
Such laws make things worse for the assaulted and better for the assailants; they serve rather to encourage than to prevent homicides, for an unarmed man may be attacked with greater confidence than an armed man.
uncertain
man → make → man
The Aporia
