A century-old tradition is on the line in New York City, and horse carriage drivers are speaking out about who will ultimately pay the price if Mayor Zohran Mamdani succeeds in ending the iconic industry.
asserted
Mamdani → speak → industry
Mamdani and City Council Speaker Julie Menin announced Tuesday that they had reached a deal to phase out horse-drawn carriages in the Big Apple, with a vote expected next week on a bill that would ban carriage operations beginning in June 2028.
asserted
that → announce → June
A longtime source of controversy, the horse-drawn carriages lined up at Central Park to take families and tourists for rides are at the center of a public safety debate after 18-year-old Romanch Mahajan was killed from a fall in June.
asserted
Mahajan → draw → June
The bill was later renamed "Romanch’s Law."
asserted
bill → rename → ?
Animal rights activists have targeted the industry, accusing carriage drivers of mistreating horses and even heckling some on the streets over concerns about proper care, food and water.
asserted
activists → target → care
Viral videos of horses collapsing and escaping into traffic have prompted calls to terminate the industry for good.
asserted
horses → collapse → industry
But Fox News Digital spoke to leaders in the industry who pushed back on the criticisms and argued that the New York City tradition is being unfairly maligned, and that livelihoods will be destroyed thanks to Mamdani's efforts.
asserted
livelihoods → speak → efforts
"You have pedicabs flying around, so why are they permitted to have a business?" Frank Riccobono, owner and manager of NYC Horse Carriage Rides, told Fox News Digital.
asserted
Riccobono → have → Digital
"And now a 168-year-old tradition, attraction is being forced to surrender, which is very taboo.
asserted
which → force → ?
I want my investment to stay there for the next 20 years, 50 years, 100."
asserted
investment → want → years
Riccobono, who owns 12 horses and three carriages, said raising horses is like raising a child, and that "non-horse people" will never understand that bond.
asserted
people → own → bond
"I had horses give birth in front of me," he said.
asserted
he → have → me
"I've owned their mom and I have their baby and it's like taking a child away from me.
asserted
it → own → me
The bill would not take the horses away from their owners.
asserted
bill → take → owners
Owners could keep, sell or transfer them as long as they are not sent to slaughter, another carriage business or an "inhumane purposes," but Riccobono could no longer use his horses for carriage rides in the city.
uncertain
Riccobono → keep → city
He called the criticism "brainwashing," adding his horses receive "the most perfect lifestyle" and regularly see certified veterinarians.
asserted
horses → call → veterinarians
"That's what this bill shows," he said.
asserted
he → show → what
"It shows they're trying to criminalize us because a horse is working."
asserted
horse → show → us
Riccobono said he will also lose a huge investment after purchasing a medallion for nearly $400,000.
asserted
he → say → 400,000
Medallions are licenses that allow horse carriage drivers to legally operate in New York City.
asserted
drivers → allow → City
"I am going to take a very, very big loss here and there's no reimbursement in this bill," he said.
asserted
he → go → bill
The ban means much more than just losing a business, according to Riccobono, who said it threatens a family legacy with horses spanning generations.
uncertain
it → mean → generations
Riccobono has spent more than two decades driving horse-drawn carriages after falling in love with the career through his father, who spent 47 years in the business.
asserted
who → spend → business
"I have a father that has medical conditions," he said.
asserted
he → have → conditions
"I have colleagues that are on dialysis.
asserted
that → have → dialysis
These people rely on these medallions for income, for retirement.
asserted
people → rely → retirement
But they're trying to strip this away from us and they don't even know how much they're gonna give us.
asserted
they → try → us
"
Riccobono’s wife, Natalie, said that without her husband’s income, the family will not be able to "sustain what we have right now."
asserted
we → say → what
"By taking away these businesses from us, they are literally taking food off of our table and possibly a shelter from over our heads," she said.
uncertain
she → take → heads
However, what comes next remains up in the air to drivers who say their voices have been left unheard.
asserted
voices → come → drivers
Mamdani, who has made waves with his socialist agenda, and Menin have vowed to help the city’s roughly 200 carriage drivers transition into new jobs.
asserted
drivers → make → jobs
"I think that we have a civic responsibility to ensure that we are not leaving anybody out to dry," Mamdani told reporters Wednesday.
asserted
Mamdani → think → reporters
"They should not be ones that are simply left as an afterthought of what comes after this."
asserted
what → leave → this
Christina Hansen, a veteran New York City horse carriage driver and Transport Workers Union (TWU) Local 100 shop steward, told Fox News Digital drivers have yet to hear directly from Mamdani and are being treated "as if we don't matter, as if we don't count."
asserted
we → tell → Mamdani
"The only cruelty in the New York City carriage industry has always been the way that the people in it, the way the carriage drivers and carriage owners and stable owners are treated," she said.
asserted
she → treat → it
In a statement to Fox News Digital, a spokesperson for Menin said she will remain involved in the transition that "must include meaningful protections for the workers" and said she invited TWU and the administration to join a new working group.
"Through thoughtful conversations with labor and other stakeholders, the Council developed a framework to ensure better economic opportunities for these New Yorkers," she said.
asserted
she → say → Yorkers
With the city anticipating the horses will go to rescues or sanctuaries, Hansen warned those facilities already struggle to care for the horses they have because of declining donations and a lack of resources.
asserted
they → anticipate → resources
Once the national attention fades, Hansen worries the horses could be left behind.
uncertain
horses → fade → ?
"There's no funding from the city or anything like that to say, we're going to make sure that, you know, the city pays for the horse's retirement," she said.
asserted
she → be → retirement
This isn't the first time carriage drivers have feared the industry could disappear.
uncertain
industry → fear → ?
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
