To raise your voice against injustice? To draw attention to a cause? Or to make those in power uncomfortable enough to listen?
For more than three decades, Indians have tried to do all three in a narrow, tree-lined road near Jantar Mantar, an 18th Century astronomical obervatory in Delhi.
asserted
Indians → raise → Delhi
But that may now be coming to an end.
uncertain
that → come → end
This week, Delhi Police said Jantar Mantar, located close to parliament, would no longer be a designated protest site.
asserted
Mantar → say → parliament
The decision comes months after the Gen Z-led Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) - not a political party but a collective which began as a joke - led a massive protest there demanding the resignation of federal education minister Dharmendra Pradhan.
asserted
which → come → Pradhan
Tens of thousands turned up and Pradhan subsequently resigned.
asserted
Pradhan → turn → ?
Police barricaded Jantar Mantar soon afterwards, preventing further demonstrations.
asserted
Police → barricade → demonstrations
Last week, an attempt by CJP supporters to march there, this time demanding the resignation of India's election chief, ended in a police crackdown.
asserted
attempt → march → crackdown
Protesters have now been directed to three other sites.
asserted
Protesters → direct → sites
Two are far from parliament, while the third, the sprawling Ramlila Ground, is often booked months in advance.
asserted
third → book → advance
Unlike Jantar Mantar, which is free, all three charge tens of thousands of rupees a day.
asserted
three → charge → rupees
Delhi Police says, external it acted after the Supreme Court suggested identifying alternative sites with adequate infrastructure.
uncertain
Court → say → infrastructure
But critics say the move could push protests beyond the reach of ordinary Indians, further from the seat of power and into venues many cannot afford.
uncertain
many → say → venues
Over the years, Jantar Mantar has witnessed everything from mass movements that shook governments to small, lonely demonstrations by people desperate to be heard.
asserted
that → witness → people
Farmers, students, grieving parents and ex-soldiers have gathered under its trees, holding placards and shouting slogans.
asserted
Farmers → grieve → slogans
Not every protest made headlines, but for many, it was a place to turn to when other doors had closed.
asserted
doors → make → many
This week, when the BBC visited, those scenes seemed a distant memory.
Yellow barricades blocked both ends of the road, with hundreds of paramilitary personnel standing guard, batons in hand.
asserted
hundreds → visit → hand
In a nearby lane, uniformed men sat in shops drinking tea or scrolling through their phones.
asserted
men → sit → phones
At one of the few shops without policemen, the shopkeeper folded his hands and said he did not want to answer any questions.
asserted
he → fold → questions
Built by Maharaja Sawai Jai Singh II in the 1720s, Jantar Mantar was once better known as a tourist attraction than a place where a thousand revolutions were imagined.
asserted
revolutions → build → place
Its story as a protest site began in 1993, when the then-Congress government stopped allowing demonstrations at the Boat Club lawns opposite the old parliament.
asserted
government → begin → parliament
Historian Harleen Kaur has traced how, from the 1960s onwards, successive governments brought in new rules that shifted the site of protest in Delhi further away from parliament.
asserted
that → trace → parliament
"Jantar Mantar, situated 3km (1.86 miles) from the Parliament House, [allowed the government] to contain protesting crowds at some distance from the Parliament House and PM's residence," she wrote in a 2023 paper, external.
asserted
she → situate → paper
Yet, the road saw countless spirited protests over the years.
asserted
road → see → years
Rachna Dhingra, an activist with the Bhopal Group for Information and Action, an advocacy group for survivors of a 1984 gas leak disaster, camped at Jantar Mantar with hundreds of others for around five months in 2008, trying to get the government to agree to demands including setting up a commission to allocate resources for rehabilitation schemes.
asserted
government → camp → schemes
Through a scorching summer, they held press conferences, met politicians and even chained themselves to railings opposite then Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's residence to draw attention to their cause.
asserted
they → scorch → cause
It was also where she formed solidarities with others - Tibetans protesting against China, activists opposing the displacement of people over large dam projects and even just lone protesters who caught a train from their home towns with nothing but a placard and a grievance.
asserted
who → form → placard
"It can be lonely to protest but that place became a home for so many of us.
asserted
place → protest → us
We shared each other's stories, struggles and victories," says Dhingra.
asserted
Dhingra → share → stories
Dipa Sinha, an academic associated with the Right to Food campaign, has seen ground-breaking laws - a landmark rural jobs guarantee scheme, the National Food Safety Act and Forest Rights Act - take shape at Jantar Mantar.
asserted
laws → associate → Mantar
"It was a place where you could discuss issues with people who came to Delhi from across the country," she says.
uncertain
she → discuss → country
Protesters would demonstrate outside government offices, including the erstwhile Planning Commission and the agriculture ministry, where they were often detained by police, before returning to Jantar Mantar to "gather, discuss and strategise".
asserted
they → demonstrate → Mantar
But sustaining a protest for months was not easy.
asserted
sustaining → sustain → months
Dhingra says they sheltered under tarpaulin sheets when it rained, used public toilets near the site and went to nearby gurdwaras to freshen up.
asserted
it → say → gurdwaras
In 2017, the National Green Tribunal cited the lack of infrastructure, along with complaints from locals, to have Jantar Mantar shut down for protests.
asserted
Mantar → cite → protests
A year later, the Supreme Court overturned this, citing the rights to free speech and peaceful assembly guaranteed under the constitution.
asserted
Court → overturn → constitution
When asked whether the proximity to parliament made a difference to their cause, Dhingra quoted the reactions of her co-protesters who had come to Delhi for the first time.
asserted
who → ask → time
Does the prime minister live there?
asserted
minister → live → ?
How can they not listen to us when we are at their gates?" she remembered them saying.
asserted
them → listen → gates
Sinha points out that Jantar Mantar was also near institutions like the Press Club and Constitution Club, making it easier to get media coverage, and for politicians to drop by and meet protesters.
asserted
politicians → point → protesters
It was a simpler time - sometimes they would ask for permission from police only on the morning of the protest.
asserted
they → ask → protest
…and 14 more, not listed.
The Aporia
