Elon Musk approached Donald Trump with the idea of slowing down Starlink in Ukraine, The Telegraph can reveal.
asserted
Telegraph → approach → Ukraine
The billionaire tech entrepreneur approached the US president with the proposal to introduce speed limits on the system, which hampered Ukraine’s drone defences, according to four sources familiar with the discussions.
uncertain
which → approach → discussions
One of the sources said Trump “agreed” with Musk’s suggestion, paving the way for the Pentagon to execute the slowdown on Starshield, the military-grade version of the satellite communications system.
asserted
Pentagon → say → system
Musk had previously blamed Trump for the chaos, claiming any changes would have been decided by the US military and ultimately the president.
asserted
changes → blame → military
At the time, Trump was embroiled in a row with Volodymyr Zelensky over Ukraine’s strikes on Russian oil refineries.
asserted
Trump → embroil → refineries
US officials had warned Kyiv’s team of peace negotiators that Washington could shut off intelligence-sharing and other kinds of support if the long-range attacks were not halted.
uncertain
attacks → warn → support
Earlier this week, one of Zelensky’s advisers said Musk’s SpaceX had restricted access to the Starshield system, used by Kyiv to intercept jet-powered drones and strike behind enemy lines.
asserted
SpaceX → say → lines
Speaking on the fringes of an EU summit in Brussels on Friday, the Ukrainian president called the slowdown a “very dangerous and unpleasant surprise”.
asserted
president → speak → slowdown
On Wednesday, Musk denied he was responsible for limiting Starlink access, blaming the White House.
asserted
he → deny → House
He claimed that “any limits on speed or usage” were “decided by the US military and ultimately POTUS”, referring to Trump.
asserted
limits → claim → Trump
However, after what was described as a “night of carnage” in Kyiv because of the blackout, a senior source said Musk had been alarmed about the possibility of adverse consumer reaction in Europe.
asserted
Musk → describe → Europe
The source said: “He tweeted out that he was innocent and that it was the US administration that did it.
asserted
that → say → it
A high-ranking European official and two well-placed Ukrainian sources confirmed this version of events.
Speaking at the White House on Friday evening, Trump said he did not think either he nor Musk had been responsible for Ukraine losing Starlink access.
asserted
Ukraine → rank → access
On Friday, an anonymous US official, cited in a report by the AFP, insisted that Trump did not make the request for a reduction of Starshield’s services for Ukraine.
asserted
Trump → cite → Ukraine
“No request was ever made by the president,” the US official said, after a report by Reuters claimed the decision came from the White House.
asserted
decision → make → House
The Pentagon has not publicly explained the restrictions.
asserted
Pentagon → explain → restrictions
Starshield is a military-grade version of Musk’s Starlink satellite network that allows pilots to stay in touch with drones moving at high speed.
asserted
pilots → allow → speed
The speed cap imposed on Ukraine limited drones using the Starshield system to around 160km/h, making it virtually impossible to intercept Russia’s barrages of jet-powered drones and missiles, which travel double the speed.
asserted
which → impose → speed
On Friday, Zelensky said signals were being restored.
asserted
signals → say → Friday
He said: “Our defence ministry is in touch and my partners, they told me that there were signals from the White House that they would return these capabilities.
asserted
they → say → capabilities
Have they returned to the previous speed limits?
asserted
they → return → limits
But is it coming back now?
asserted
it → come → ?
It is not the first time Musk has been accused of limiting the use of his Starlink platform to the detriment of Ukraine.
asserted
Musk → accuse → Ukraine
In 2023, he confirmed he had rebutted requests by Kyiv to use the system in drone attacks on Crimea, the peninsula illegally annexed by Russia, to avoid being complicit in a “major act of war”.
asserted
he → confirm → war
However, Musk was lauded by Ukrainians earlier this year for his direct role in blocking illegal access to Starlink by Russian soldiers fighting in Ukraine.
asserted
Musk → laud → Ukraine
‘We are watching you’
asserted
We → watch → you
A source told The Telegraph that Poland had been leading warnings against Europe becoming too reliant on Musk or his SpaceX company.
asserted
Europe → tell → Musk
Writing on social media, Radek Sikorski, Poland’s foreign minister, warned the tech billionaire: “As your European customers, we are watching you.”
asserted
we → write → you
The EU is planning to have its Iris2, a Starlink replacement, operational by 2030.
asserted
Iris2 → plan → 2030
Zelensky arrived in Brussels bruised and seeking more support from his European allies after his war of words with Mr Trump.
asserted
Zelensky → arrive → Trump
Diplomats said leaders had advised the Ukrainian president to tone down his criticism of his US counterpart amid fears Washington could further withdraw its support for Kyiv.
uncertain
Washington → say → Kyiv
Trump has been highly critical of Ukraine’s strikes on Russia’s oil refineries, blaming them for soaring energy prices before the midterm elections next month.
asserted
Trump → blame → elections
“All he’s doing is making the world oil price higher,” Trump told the Newsmax television channel.
asserted
Trump → do → channel
“Well, I think that’s a disgrace.”
asserted
that → think → ?
Last Friday, he announced a deal to lift sanctions on Russia to purchase hundreds of thousands of diesel from Vladimir Putin.
asserted
he → announce → Putin
Europeans rallied around Zelensky, applauding him as he entered the room for just over an hour of discussions with the EU’s prime ministers and heads of state on Friday.
asserted
he → rally → Friday
The Ukrainian president later said he had heard “only support”.
asserted
he → say → support
In the room, he told EU leaders that the war would cost some €155bn ($250bn) in 2027.
asserted
war → tell → 2027
“And we need at least €70 billion more from you – for defence, for weapons and for our resilience,” he told them.
asserted
he → need → them
Zelensky also hinted he would continue to defy Trump’s order to halt strikes on Russian oil refineries, telling reporters that “the main rule of our operations is to respond – other things you will see”.
asserted
you → hint → operations
…and 4 more, not listed.
The Aporia
