Amazon has vowed to close more than a dozen warehouses and shed thousands of workers across New York City over a labor bill being pushed by Mayor Zohran Mamdani — and the e-commerce giant is likely to make good on the threat if the controversial legislation is enacted, industry experts told The Post.
asserted
experts → vow → Post
The Delivery Protection Act would force Amazon to directly hire upwards of 5,000 delivery workers citywide who are currently employed by third-party contractors.
asserted
who → force → contractors
Proponents say the legislation will increase workers’ pay and improve safety conditions at Amazon and other delivery firms including FedEx and DoorDash.
asserted
legislation → say → FedEx
But Amazon doesn’t directly employ delivery workers anywhere else in the country — and has a history of fiercely resisting efforts to change its policies in the US and abroad.
asserted
Amazon → employ → US
The result, according to experts, could be not only that those 5,000 delivery jobs move out of the city, but also that Amazon shutters its 15 last-mile warehouses in the Big Apple and fires the additional 2,000 workers that staff them.
uncertain
that → accord → them
Early last year, Amazon closed seven warehouses in Quebec near Montreal amid a labor fight involving one of its last-mile facilities.
asserted
Amazon → close → facilities
The union, Confédération des syndicats nationaux (CSN), had organized the 300 workers at a warehouse in the town of Laval.
asserted
union → organize → Laval
By March 2025, some 1,900 Canadians across seven warehouses and 2,800 delivery contractors for those facilities had lost their jobs.
asserted
Canadians → lose → jobs
“Amazon will retaliate, because it has to send a firm message to the rest of the country that ‘If you mess with us, this is what will happen,’” said Marc Wulfraat, president and founder of Montreal-based logistics consulting firm, MWPVL International.
asserted
Wulfraat → retaliate → firm
“When you look at Amazon’s global operations, they close buildings left, right and center when there is union activity.”
asserted
they → look → buildings
According to real estate listings, the Montreal facilities are now vacant, with Amazon still paying rent on more than 1.6 million square feet of space that it spent hundreds of millions of dollars to build, according to Wulfraat.
uncertain
it → accord → Wulfraat
At least two facilities are being offered as subleases.
asserted
facilities → offer → subleases
The Delivery Protection Act — first introduced a year ago by Queens Council Member Tiffany Cabán and reintroduced in 2026 — has strong support in the City Council with some 34 co-signers.
asserted
Act → introduce → signers
But several, including Speaker Julie Menin, are “uncomfortable” with potential job losses, a source close to negotiations said.
asserted
source → include → negotiations
“This bill will have to pass in some form,” particularly since the mayor supports it, the source told The Post, adding that the final result may make “both sides unhappy.”
uncertain
sides → have → Post
Compromises that have been discussed include allowing independent contractors to continue to perform deliveries while requiring Amazon to provide more safety guarantees for workers, the source said.
asserted
source → discuss → workers
No vote has been scheduled.
asserted
vote → schedule → ?
Industry experts say parallels between Quebec and New York can’t be ignored, even as Amazon employs directly or indirectly more than 12,000 hourly workers in New York — more than twice as many as it did in Quebec.
asserted
it → say → Quebec
Those include the 2,000 workers that staff last-mile warehouses and 5,000 more to deliver the goods.
asserted
that → include → goods
The Delivery Protection Act wouldn’t affect 5,500 workers at Amazon’s giant JFK8 fulfillment center on Staten Island, who voted to unionize in 2022 — a first at an Amazon US facility — but who still lack a collective bargaining agreement.
asserted
who → affect → agreement
While Amazon employs unionized workers in Europe, it has made headlines since the pandemic battling unions in the US.
asserted
it → employ → US
It’s now locked in litigation over allegedly hardball tactics it has used to fight labor organization in Bessemer, Ala., and Staten Island.
uncertain
it → lock → Bessemer
In April, the National Labor Relations Board ordered Amazon to the bargaining table with the Teamsters in Staten Island, but Amazon has filed lawsuits questioning the legitimacy of the NLRB.
asserted
Amazon → order → NLRB
“Amazon will say or do whatever it takes to deny workers stronger rights and wages and abdicate its responsibilities for its own employees,” the Teamsters said in a statement.
asserted
Teamsters → say → statement
The risks posed by the Delivery Protection Act are not lost on the 40 independent companies that employ the 5,000 delivery workers in New York City.
asserted
that → pose → City
“Look at what happened in Quebec,” Kris Basmagy, owner of DashWave Delivery, which handles Amazon’s deliveries on Manhattan’s Upper East Side, told The Post.
asserted
which → look → Post
“There was pressure on Amazon’s model, and it pulled out.”
asserted
it → be → model
Basmagy, who employs150 delivery workers, added that nothing is stopping Amazon from replacing its New York City facilities with some of the “warehouses being built along the New Jersey Turnpike.”
asserted
nothing → employs150 → Turnpike
Amazon is still tied up in litigation in Quebec, where it denies that it closed its warehouses because of CSN’s organizing activity.
asserted
it → tie → activity
The union filed a complaint with Quebec’s labor tribunal, but even if it proves that Amazon violated labor laws, Amazon faces at most a fine and potential consumer backlash, according to a CBC News report.
uncertain
Amazon → file → report
A class action lawsuit filed by an Amazon Prime customer in Quebec in February 2025 claims that the warehouse closures slowed Amazon’s delivery times beyond the one- and two-day guarantee for Prime service — with some deliveries instead taking as long as four to six days.
uncertain
deliveries → file → days
In May, a Quebec court ruled that the case can proceed.
uncertain
case → rule → May
Still, plaintiffs who are seeking refunds admit the disruption only lasted about two months, according to the complaint.
uncertain
disruption → seek → complaint
Amazon says service hasn’t suffered since a large Canadian logistics company, IntelCom, took over its Quebec deliveries.
asserted
company → say → deliveries
“Then they got their act together and stopped the delays,” said Saro Turner, a partner in the law firm Slater Vecchio, which filed the suit.
asserted
which → get → suit
In New York, Amazon maintains that delivery times and prices for customers would increase if it closed its warehouses.
asserted
it → maintain → warehouses
New York is “fundamentally different” from Quebec, where Amazon operated “far fewer sites,” according to Amazon spokesperson Steve Kelly.
uncertain
Amazon → operate → Kelly
The company bankrolled a study by AKFR showing that the Delivery Protection Act would cost New Yorkers an extra $664 extra a year — or about $5.20 per package.
asserted
Act → bankroll → package
That figure covers deliveries made by other companies, including FedEx and Doordash.
asserted
figure → cover → FedEx
“New York City is one of the largest and most complex delivery regions in the country,” Kelly said in a statement.
asserted
Kelly → say → statement
…and 15 more, not listed.
The Aporia
