Trade war puts spotlight on Canada's relationship with U.S. big tech
Experts say Canada can reduce its reliance on U.S. tech, but there's a difficult road ahead
Trade and political tensions between Canada and the United States have raised concerns about Canada's digital sovereignty, but what does that term mean, and how can Canada promote it?
asserted
Canada → put → it
While it may sound like jargon, experts say digital sovereignty can be defined simply.
uncertain
sovereignty → sound → jargon
It's about regulation, Vass Bednar, managing director of independent public policy think-tank the Canadian Shield Institute, told CBC Radio's Just Asking.
asserted
Bednar → manage → Radio
"Fundamentally, our digital sovereignty is our ability to regulate digital environments using the tools that we have," she said, including regulation of algorithms that influence what information we see online.
asserted
we → regulate → information
It's also about choice and the law, according to Michael Geist, Canada Research Chair in internet and e-commerce law at the University of Ottawa.
uncertain
It → accord → Ottawa
"It's fundamentally about both the ability to make Canadian choices … so we have alternatives to some of the larger — predominately U.S. — players, and also ensuring that Canadian law applies," he told CBC Manitoba's Information Radio last week.
asserted
he → make → Radio
Google updates maps to show Lake America in the U.S. — but Canadians are now seeing it, too
'Lake America' change highlights Canada's reliance on U.S. tech
asserted
change → update → tech
The federal government also has a definition.
asserted
government → have → definition
"Digital sovereignty means Canada stays in control of its own digital future — including its data, technology and essential online services — instead of relying on foreign companies, foreign systems or foreign laws," a government webpage reads.
asserted
webpage → mean → companies
"Think of it like this: Just as we want our homes, money and identities protected in Canada, we want the same protection for our digital information and services."
asserted
we → think → information
A mid-August X post from the U.S. Trade Representative account said a potential trade deal between Canada and the U.S. would include "digital trade alignment," which prompted expert concerns and speculation about digital sovereignty.
asserted
which → say → sovereignty
Only days later, talks between the two countries fell apart at the last minute, reportedly over American insistence that U.S. streaming companies be exempt from Canadian content rules.
uncertain
companies → fall → rules
After talks broke down, President Donald Trump signed an executive order that Lake Ontario be renamed Lake America.
asserted
Ontario → break → order
Google and Apple Maps quickly implemented the change for American users, but some Canadians reported seeing it on their maps.
asserted
Canadians → implement → maps
Right now, Canada doesn't have many alternatives to American technology companies and digital platforms.
asserted
Canada → have → companies
"We are heavily dependent on the American big tech companies when it comes to our Canadian businesses and the public sector," said Shion Guha, assistant professor in information and computer science at the University of Toronto, on Just Asking.
asserted
Guha → come → Toronto
The federal government also uses the Microsoft Office and Microsoft 365 platforms.
asserted
government → use → platforms
In January, Shared Services Canada, which is responsible for providing IT services to the government, renewed its agreement with Microsoft in a deal worth $940 million over seven years.
asserted
which → provide → years
Guha was part of a study on the federal government's AI Register which found that Microsoft was the single biggest supplier of systems, accounting for 42 of 409.
asserted
Microsoft → find → 409
"An American big tech company is very heavily intertwined, not just with things like email or OneDrive … or Microsoft Office, but also in the types of predictive analytics and other types of AI products that the federal government has currently acquired," Guha said.
asserted
Guha → intertwine → that
"
There is precedent for switching, Bednar said, noting, "France has been a little bit ahead of the curve here."
Canada ready to further distance itself from U.S. on military procurement
Why isn't Canada blocking the Welland Canal? Other trade war questions answered
asserted
questions → be → Canal
France's Interministerial Directorate for Digital Affairs announced in April that it will remove Microsoft's Windows operating system from government computers.
asserted
it → announce → computers
Open-source software Linux will replace it.
asserted
Linux → replace → it
The French government also developed Tchap, an instant messaging application, and mandated its use for public sector employees, citing security and privacy concerns.
asserted
government → develop → concerns
The French government says over 600,000 public sector employees use the app.
asserted
employees → say → app
What can Canadians do?
asserted
Canadians → do → What
But if getting the Canadian government to switch platforms could be difficult, getting Canadians to change everything from their credit cards to their cloud storage to their social media and instant messaging platforms and more could be even harder.
uncertain
Canadians → get → media
Gander Social launched in July, marketing itself as a nicer, Canadian alternative to U.S. social media platforms.
asserted
Social → launch → platforms
The company posted on Facebook last week, saying it's approaching 50,000 users, though Bednar pointed out that Prime Minister Mark Carney isn't among them.
asserted
Carney → post → them
But having Canadian options doesn't mean Canadians will want them, Guha said.
asserted
Guha → have → them
"There is a certain amount of inertia in getting Canadians to switch to things, because convenience usually rules over most things," he said.
asserted
he → be → things
"Just because we can, or do, have Canadian alternatives — and they may provide better features, they may be good for us — doesn't mean that we can overcome the social inertia to get people to switch.
uncertain
people → provide → inertia
"
But it is one way ordinary Canadians can promote digital sovereignty, Bednar said.
asserted
Bednar → promote → sovereignty
Though she also acknowledged it's going to require more "institutional imagination in Canada" to move forward
asserted
it → acknowledge → Canada
Staying sovereign in the AI age
The Canadian government released its National AI Strategy in June.
asserted
government → stay → June
In it, the government pledges to develop a home-grown supercomputer, as well as "sovereign cloud, AI, cyber and quantum initiatives."
asserted
government → pledge → supercomputer
Geist said the government should take an approach that balances building Canadian AI programs with access to foreign ones.
"
asserted
that → say → ones
If a single government gets to determine whether or not you have access to those frontier models, they're really determining whether or not you've got the very best tools to counter things like cybersecurity threats," he said.
asserted
he → get → threats
- Analysis
Canada wants sovereign AI data centres.
asserted
Canada → want → centres
What does that actually mean?
asserted
that → mean → What
…and 7 more, not listed.
The Aporia
