B.C. NDP Premier David Eby brought all the charisma and energy of a disgruntled used car salesman — desperate to sell voters a lemon — to the provincial election debate last night.
asserted
Eby → bring → debate
He was bested by both his opponents, Conservative Party of B.C. interim leader Lorne Doerkson and the B.C. Green Party’s Emily Lowan.
asserted
He → best → B.C.
Eby, who comes off as morose at baseline, looked particularly gloomy, and often on the verge of losing his temper.
asserted
who → come → temper
His lagging poll numbers may as well have been written on his face.
uncertain
numbers → write → face
Predictably, the night opened with moderator Shachi Kurl, president of the Angus Reid Institute, asking the question of the hour: Why are we even here?
asserted
we → open → hour
Why did you call this snap election, two years early and in the middle of municipal elections, Mr. Eby?
asserted
you → call → elections
Voters of all persuasions know the real answer.
asserted
Voters → know → answer
This election call was an attempted power grab, taken at the precise moment Eby saw the Conservatives in disarray and leaderless after the resignation of short-lived party leader Kerry-Lynne Findlay.
asserted
Conservatives → attempt → Findlay
Eby thought he could extend his term by another two years, just months after his public approval rating dropped to an abysmal 31 per cent.
uncertain
rating → think → cent
It surely looked like the opportunity of a political lifetime, notwithstanding — or so Eby thought — a populace that might not want to go to the polls twice in a month.
uncertain
that → look → month
Eby, of course, claimed his one-seat majority government has been preoccupied with “surviving another day” in the legislature.
asserted
government → claim → legislature
He even invoked recently deceased NDP MLA Joan Phillip, telling us that she had to vote from her hospital bed to keep his government from crumbling.
asserted
she → invoke → government
“Joan Phillip, dying of cancer, after her tracheal tube was removed, voted at 4:30 in the morning,” Eby claimed, apparently referring to Phillip’s history of having voted on legislation several times while hospitalized this year.
asserted
Eby → die → legislation
It felt uncouth for Eby to discuss Phillip in this manner.
asserted
Eby → feel → manner
Eby, who professes to despise the “culture wars,” invoked them almost immediately.
asserted
who → profess → them
More than once, Eby attempted to derail Doerkson with tired claims of “hate” and “extremism” within Conservative ranks.
uncertain
Eby → attempt → ranks
He mentioned an allegation that Conservative MLA Heather Maahs called Centre B.C. MLA Elenore Sturko “immoral” for being a lesbian.
asserted
Maahs → mention → Sturko
Maahs has denied this, and posted on X before the debate that the claim is “false and defamatory.”
uncertain
claim → deny → debate
Maahs also took heat for previous comments about sexualized LGBT books held in public high school libraries in the province.
asserted
Maahs → take → province
The NDP broadly conflated her criticism of age-inappropriate books with criticism of homosexuality.
asserted
NDP → conflate → homosexuality
At the debate, Eby repeatedly accused Maahs of suggesting that gay men are “secret pedophiles.”
asserted
men → accuse → Maahs
Doerkson deflected from the Maahs issue, but went on the defensive for his campaign director, Katy Merrifield, who has faced calls to resign over a now-deleted X post stating “F–k Islam” and calling for the expulsion of the “abhorrent ideology.”
asserted
who → deflect → ideology
Merrifield linked her posts to anger over the U.K. grooming gang scandal.
asserted
Merrifield → link → scandal
Doerkson will not tell her to resign, he told Eby — but how about that 2018 comment from Attorney General Niki Sharma about the “unbearable whiteness of local elections results,” eh, Eby?
asserted
he → tell → results
From the start, Doerkson was placed in the unenviable position of deciding how much time to dedicate to countering Eby’s mudslinging, versus focusing on the premier’s terrible track record.
asserted
Doerkson → place → record
Did he strike the right balance?
asserted
he → strike → balance
We’ll have to wait for the next round of polls to find out.
asserted
We → have → polls
Lowan held her own in the debate, coming across as serious as any Green Party leader could in promising free, well, everything.
uncertain
leader → hold → everything
She very well may split the left-wing vote after demonstrating her ability to make Eby look like the unreasonable person in the room.
uncertain
Eby → split → room
Candidates were asked about a range of topics, from the economy and government spending, housing, health care, daycare, public safety, the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (DRIPA), and how the parties will work together after the election.
asserted
parties → ask → election
Eby deflected from his record and insisted that the Conservatives would be no better than former B.C. Liberal governments, which haven’t been in power for nearly a decade.
asserted
which → deflect → decade
Neither Doerkson nor Lowan took the opportunity to hammer Eby on his family’s scandalous use of one of B.C.’s coveted $10-a-day child-care spots, a program that Eby halted the expansion of, but personally benefits from.
asserted
Eby → take → expansion
Doerkson stressed his plan to grow the province’s resource-based economy, fix the health-care system, repeal DRIPA, and offer better policing, housing and involuntary care to address B.C.’s homelessness and drug addiction crisis.
asserted
Doerkson → stress → crisis
He denied that he would privatize healthcare.
asserted
he → deny → healthcare
He demonstrated a calm, confident demeanour that may persuade voters of his ability to lead the province.
uncertain
that → demonstrate → province
Eby, meanwhile, struggled to articulate why an election was necessary to make the changes he now promises.
asserted
he → struggle → changes
On street disorder, Eby entirely blamed the former Liberal government for shutting down Riverview Hospital, a mental health facility.
asserted
Eby → blame → Hospital
He then spoke of “providing dignified care so people aren’t lying half naked in a gutter,” as though the NDP hasn’t been in power since 2017, and hasn’t worsened street disorder and the addictions crisis by expanding “harm reduction” policies and running a failed drug decriminalization experiment.
asserted
NDP → speak → experiment
If there was a single moment that should have proved Eby’s inability to govern this province, it was his admission that he cannot get over his ongoing resentments and work alongside the Conservatives in the legislature.
asserted
he → be → legislature
“I have a hard time imagining working with this iteration of the Conservative Party,” Eby stated.
asserted
Eby → have → Party
…and 2 more, not listed.
The Aporia
