Not much has gone right for the global economy this year, and plenty has gone wrong.
asserted
plenty → go → economy
Two big regional wars are destabilising prices and supply chains everywhere.
asserted
wars → destabilise → prices
Businesses and consumers are feeling the effects of a serious energy shock.
asserted
Businesses → feel → shock
Rising inflation has made it a lot more expensive for governments to finance their debts.
asserted
governments → rise → debts
It is something of a miracle that the finance ministers and central bank governors gathered for this year’s annual meeting of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) in Bangkok are not having to deal with a full-blown crisis.
asserted
ministers → gather → crisis
This is not like the autumn of 2008, when the meetings took place during the worst of the global banking meltdown.
asserted
meetings → take → meltdown
The IMF is right when it says countries have shown resilience when having to cope with so many headwinds.
asserted
countries → say → headwinds
There was even some good news for the UK, with the IMF upgrading its growth forecast for this year and praising the government for its deficit-reduction plan.
asserted
IMF → be → plan
The better-than-expected performance of the global economy breaks with historical precedent.
asserted
performance → expect → precedent
In the past, oil shocks of the magnitude witnessed since the start of Iran war have had a marked and immediate impact, but there are three key reasons why growth has remained robust and inflationary pressure has been muted this time.
asserted
pressure → witness → impact
This has been particularly important in the US, which is comfortably the fastest growing member of the G7 group of major developed economies year on year.
asserted
which → grow → year
The second is that countries have drawn on inventories of oil, and that has helped to alleviate the loss of crude from the Middle East.
asserted
that → draw → East
Had stockpiles not been run down, oil prices would have risen even more sharply.
asserted
prices → run → ?
The third is that China’s economic strategy relies on exporting cheap goods to the rest of the world, and this is bearing down on the prices of imports elsewhere.
asserted
this → rely → imports
All that said, the potential flashpoints for trouble are everywhere.
asserted
flashpoints → say → trouble
The situation in the Middle East is deteriorating, with the conflict spreading to Saudi Arabia.
asserted
conflict → deteriorate → Arabia
Oil stocks are running low and Donald Trump has got the US into just the sort of forever war that he used to rail against.
asserted
he → run → that
The downside to cheap Chinese goods is that they are threatening manufacturing jobs in the west, with Germany especially vulnerable.
asserted
Germany → threaten → west
Meanwhile, massive US investment in AI has pushed up the cost of borrowing and resulted in shortages of capital for non-AI sectors.
asserted
investment → push → sectors
Governments are coming under pressure to rein in spending or raise taxes in the hope that bond markets will be impressed by their efforts to cut budget deficits.
asserted
markets → come → deficits
Warnings from (among others) the head of the IMF, Kristalina Georgieva, and the governor of the Bank of England, Andrew Bailey, of the need to run a tighter fiscal ship come at a time when voters want politicians to do more, not less.
asserted
politicians → run → more
There is little appetite for a new era of austerity, and finance ministers know it.
asserted
ministers → be → it
If they follow through on the tough talk and actually deliver painful measures, the backlash is likely to be brutal.
asserted
backlash → follow → measures
Just as big a problem for governments is the need – at a time when global supply chains are stretched and fragile – to boost national self-sufficiency.
asserted
chains → stretch → sufficiency
The student protests in India and France highlight the pressures on states to intervene.
asserted
protests → highlight → states
Yet the capacity of states to act effectively is much weaker than they care to admit.
asserted
they → act → states
At a time when globalisation is in retreat, there is a need for a strong system of multilateral cooperation to cope with the strains.
asserted
globalisation → be → strains
The World Trade Organization is moribund in this new age of protectionism, and the IMF and the World Bank are reluctant to call Trump out for his erratic behaviour.
asserted
IMF → call → behaviour
Yet the idea that a new era of partnership will flower when there is a new US president is for the birds.
asserted
era → flower → birds
The problems of multilateralism run far deeper than that.
asserted
problems → run → that
The liberal world order that the IMF and World Bank have presided over since the end of the second world war was dysfunctional long before Trump arrived in office.
asserted
Trump → preside → office
As the former UN official Richard Kozul-Wright points out in a paper published next month, the IMF and World Bank – created at the 1944 Bretton Woods conference – may still be operational but they have lost their connection to the New Deal principles laid out 82 years ago: state intervention in the running of economies, active industrial policy, the pursuit of full employment and help for poor countries to develop.
uncertain
countries → point → employment
“Instead, they have in recent decades pursued an agenda which encourages footloose capital, bolsters (and protects) private profit, and reduces the policy space available to governments.
asserted
which → pursue → governments
As a result, they have acted as hand maidens to an age of rising inequality, debt distress and heightened anxiety.”
asserted
they → act → inequality
The IMF’s own programmes for countries that come looking for financial assistance illustrate Kozul-Wright’s point about the lack of policy space.
asserted
that → look → space
Help comes with strings attached: an insistence on tax increases and spending cuts that are frontloaded so that half the measures are implemented in the first year and two-thirds within two years.
asserted
measures → come → years
The IMF argues that this “tough love” has a higher chance of success, although its view of what constitutes success is limited, and primarily means that a borrowing country doesn’t need another IMF programme in the next three years.
asserted
country → argue → years
It doesn’t mean living standards are improving or that fewer people are in poverty.
asserted
people → mean → poverty
Clearly it would help to return to New Deal principles.
asserted
it → help → principles
It would mean governments had more policy space to develop strategies tailored to their own needs.
asserted
governments → mean → needs
…and 8 more, not listed.
The Aporia
