A council worker suggested a wheelchair–bound amputee could be mobile enough to run a marathon while denying his request for a blue parking badge.
uncertain
amputee → suggest → badge
Nigel Ward, 71, sent Norfolk County Council photos of himself standing on one leg and sitting in his wheelchair in an application for the permit.
asserted
Ward → send → permit
Mr Ward, who lost the lower half of his left leg in an emergency situation on a cruise, has held a blue badge for the last three years.
But his most recent application for the permit was denied by the council, which said he had not provided sufficient medical evidence of his walking ability.
asserted
he → lose → ability
A council officer even suggested the pensioner could have an undisclosed 'spring leg' and be mobile enough to run a marathon.
uncertain
pensioner → suggest → marathon
Mr Ward said he can't provide new medical proof, as he no longer regularly sees doctors since receiving his prosthetic limb.
asserted
he → say → limb
He is now considered 'independent' and only requires medical assistance if 'something went wrong' with his prosthetic limb or stump, he told the BBC.
asserted
he → consider → BBC
Mr Ward said that journeys will be 'troublesome to say the least' without a permit, and that the council is yet to specify what new evidence he needs to provide.
asserted
he → say → evidence
Nigel Ward, 71, sent Norfolk County Council photos of himself standing on one leg in his application for a Blue Badge parking permit.
asserted
Ward → send → permit
It was denied by the council, which said he had not provided sufficient medical evidence of his walking ability
The Department for Transport's (DfT) blue badge scheme allows people with severe mobility issues to park closer to shops, hospitals and other destinations.
Mr Ward's daughter, Helen Robinson, said she was 'absolutely appalled' that her father's application had been denied by the council.
She wrote on Facebook: 'What more evidence is needed to demonstrate the significant impact that losing a leg above the knee can have on someone's mobility?
asserted
losing → deny → mobility
'Why is someone who has already been recognised as eligible for a blue badge now being put through this process again, having to prove their circumstances all over again?
asserted
who → recognise → circumstances
Do you think legs miraculously grow back?
asserted
legs → think → ?
'Someone at the council actually said this to Dad on the phone, "We don't know that you don't have one of those spring legs and could run a marathon!"
uncertain
you → say → marathon
'At 71, my dad should not have to face this level of stress and uncertainty just to access the parking support he needs.
asserted
he → have → support
'A blue badge is not a luxury or a privilege to be taken lightly.
asserted
badge → take → ?
It can make a real difference to the independence, dignity and everyday life of a disabled person.
asserted
It → make → person
I understand that councils have procedures to follow but surely there must also be room for common sense, compassion and a proper understanding of an individual's circumstances.
asserted
councils → understand → circumstances
Mr Ward (pictured here in his wheelchair) said that without a permit, journeys will 'troublesome to say the least', and that the council has yet to specify what evidence he needs to provide
'
asserted
he → picture → evidence
I am sharing this because I cannot believe that my dad is the only person facing this kind of frustrating and distressing experience when trying to access support they genuinely need.
asserted
they → share → support
'Disabled people deserve dignity, understanding and a fair assessment, not unnecessary obstacles.
asserted
people → deserve → ?
Since sharing his story online, the family have received several messages from people saying they were also struggling to renew their permits.
asserted
they → share → permits
Mr Ward believes an uptick in fraudulent claims for blue badges has led to legitimate applications being scrutinised more closely.
uncertain
applications → believe → badges
Norfolk County Council said: 'We know how important blue badges are for helping people to remain independent.
asserted
people → say → ?
We have to work within the guidance set for us by the Department for Transport, which includes detailed guidance how eligibility should be assessed through evidence and assessments.
asserted
eligibility → have → evidence
'As detailed on our website applicants must adequately evidence the difficulties they experience whilst walking, this applies to those reapplying for an expiring Blue Badge as well as first time applications.
asserted
this → detail → Badge
'There is no renewal process, and applicants are required to evidence their ongoing eligibility with each application.
asserted
applicants → be → application
Evidence could include letters, reports or details of treatment from a medical professional.
uncertain
Evidence → include → professional
'Anyone requiring help with a blue badge application or who is unable to use the online application process can call the council's Customer Service Centre on 0344 800 8020, and we would be happy to provide support and advice.'
asserted
we → require → support
The Aporia
