One of Australia's largest hospitality groups has pushed back against growing calls to cut immigration, warning pubs, hotels and tourism operators would struggle to find staff without migrant workers.
asserted
pubs → push → workers
The Australian Hotels Association (AHA) has launched a fresh advertising campaign as immigration becomes a central political issue, with Labor, the Coalition and One Nation all proposing measures to reduce migration.
asserted
Labor → launch → migration
The AI-generated ad begins with a man standing in front of a giant red button beneath a sign reading: 'Press button to run Australia without migrant workers.
asserted
ad → generate → workers
'
'What's the worst that could happen?' he asks before pressing the button.
uncertain
he → happen → button
The campaign then shows a series of comic consequences, including customers forced to clean hotel rooms themselves, pubs unable to find chefs and supermarket shoppers paying $47 for an apple.
asserted
campaign → show → apple
'As changes to Australia's migration policy are being considered, it's important to understand the real economic and social impact of any changes, particularly in regional NSW,' the association said on social media.
asserted
association → consider → media
'Employing staff from overseas is rarely the first choice for NSW hotels.
asserted
Employing → employ → hotels
But when a position can't be filled locally, there is often no alternative, and the cost is significant.
asserted
cost → fill → ?
Sponsoring an overseas skilled worker such as a chef costs a venue around $35,000.
asserted
Sponsoring → sponsor → 35,000
The group also defended working holiday makers, stating they play a critical role in regional Australia.
asserted
they → defend → Australia
The AHA released an artificial intelligence ad campaign criticising moves to reduce migration
'
asserted
AHA → release → migration
Working holiday makers are also essential.
asserted
makers → work → ?
They are motivated, mobile and willing to travel to wherever seasonal work exists in hospitality and accommodation,' AHA NSW said.
asserted
NSW → travel → hospitality
'AHA NSW supports a balanced approach to migration that recognises the vital role international workers play in keeping our industry and our communities thriving.'
asserted
workers → support → industry
The campaign comes as One Nation leads calls for a dramatic reduction in migration, proposing cuts of 750,000 temporary visa holders over three years and pushing net overseas migration into negative territory.
asserted
Nation → come → territory
The Coalition has also announced plans to tighten migration settings, promising to cut annual migration levels by about a third in its first year if elected, and reduce the number of temporary visa holders by 650,000 over four years.
asserted
Coalition → announce → years
Under its proposal, the Coalition would also halve the humanitarian intake to 10,000 places, and overhaul Labor's changes to backpacker visas.
Deputy Liberal Leader Jane Hume on Wednesday said she had spoken with the AHA about the campaign and argued the Coalition's policy would focus on attracting skilled workers, not cutting access to labour entirely.
asserted
policy → halve → labour
'I've spoken to the AHA, and in fact we had an integration call with them just last week,' she said.
asserted
she → speak → them
'They understand what we're trying to do.'
asserted
we → understand → what
Jane Hume (pictured) said that Australia would not have an 'imported underclass' of workers
'
asserted
Australia → picture → workers
We want to reduce the number, but more importantly, we want to shift the focus from unskilled migration to skilled migration.'
asserted
we → want → migration
Hume said the Coalition deliberately left working holiday makers untouched and would reverse Labor's proposed ballot system for backpackers because regional businesses depend on them.
asserted
businesses → say → them
'We haven't touched working holiday makers,' she said.
asserted
she → touch → makers
'In fact, we're going to unwind the ballot process Labor announced because we think it will have a terrible effect on jobs in regional Australia.'
asserted
it → go → Australia
Asked how hotels, aged-care facilities and hospitality venues would cope without lower-skilled migrant workers, Hume rejected the idea Australia should rely on a permanent guest worker class.
asserted
Australia → ask → class
'What you're effectively saying is that it's okay to create a guest worker class,' she said.
asserted
she → say → class
'I don't think that's what Australians expect.'
'When you go to Dubai and other places like that, you see a workforce that can resemble an imported underclass.
asserted
that → think → underclass
Pauline Hanson (pictured), Labor and the Coalition have called for a cut to temporary visas
Nationals leader Matt Canavan argued migration policy should be considered alongside broader economic reforms, blaming government spending for worsening labour shortages.
'When you massively ramp up spending on programs like the NDIS, workers are drawn into government-funded roles they might otherwise perform in private businesses,' he said.
uncertain
he → picture → businesses
'So migration policy shouldn't be considered in isolation.'
asserted
policy → consider → isolation
Labor is also seeking to lower migration levels, targeting net overseas migration of 245,000 by July 2027 and 225,000 annually thereafter.
asserted
Labor → seek → July
The government also wants to reduce the number of working holiday makers eligible for second and third-year stays, while strengthening enforcement measures against visa overstayers.
asserted
government → want → overstayers
The Aporia
