Air France has confirmed that it is complying with new Israeli restrictions limiting who can fly to and over Israel based on their nationality, a controversial policy that some experts say could expose the airline to discrimination lawsuits.
uncertain
experts → confirm → lawsuits
The new Israeli restrictions, reported by Israeli media and French investigative publication Mediapart, list 31 Muslim-majority countries, including Algeria, Tunisia, Iran, Oman, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and Niger, whose nationals are no longer allowed to fly into Israel’s airspace.
asserted
nationals → report → airspace
Recommended Stories
list of 4 items- list 1 of 4Who is the mystery co-pilot behind the Flydubai attack?
- list 2 of 4What are the five questions being asked regarding the Flydubai attack?
- list 3 of 4How was the Flydubai co-pilot who attacked his captain cleared to fly?
- list 4 of 4Flydubai stabbing: How safe are planes if a pilot turns violent?
asserted
pilot → ask → captain
“Like all airlines, Air France is required to comply with the entry regulations established by the authorities of the countries it serves, both for its customers and employees,” Air France told Al Jazeera in a statement.
asserted
France → require → statement
According to Israel’s N12 broadcaster, the Ministry of Transport and Road Safety told foreign airlines on October 1 that pilots and cabin crew operating flights into Israeli airspace must not hold the nationality or dual nationality of countries that lack diplomatic relations with Israel.
uncertain
that → accord → Israel
The directive came a day after an Omani copilot allegedly attempted to hijack a Flydubai flight from Dubai to Tel Aviv and crash it into Israel’s Ben Gurion airport on September 30, according to Emirati and Israeli authorities.
uncertain
copilot → come → authorities
The copilot is accused of attacking the plane’s Indian pilot, who has been recovering in hospital.
asserted
who → accuse → hospital
“The staff concerned have been informed of the new regulations implemented by the Israeli authorities for flights to Tel Aviv,” Air France told Al Jazeera.
asserted
France → concern → Jazeera
Dozens of airlines affected
The Israeli directive could affect dozens of airlines that fly to, from or over that country.
uncertain
that → affect → country
Al Jazeera contacted the Israeli Transport Ministry for comment but had not received a response by the time of publication.
asserted
Jazeera → contact → publication
Al Jazeera also contacted 15 major international airlines operating flights to Israel, asking whether they had received the directive and changed crew assignments in response.
asserted
they → contact → response
Smartwings, the largest Czech airline, confirmed that it had received the new Israeli directive, and while it said its operations were not impacted at the moment, it added that it would comply with the restrictions.
asserted
it → confirm → restrictions
“We received the directive from the Israeli authorities in September 2026.
asserted
We → receive → September
We have carefully reviewed the directive and continue to monitor and comply with all applicable requirements issued by the relevant authorities.
asserted
We → review → authorities
At present, the directive does not have any impact on our operations, crew management procedures, or the deployment of crew members on flights to and from Israel,” Vladimira Dufkova, a spokeswoman for Smartwings, told Al Jazeera.
asserted
Dufkova → have → Jazeera
United Airlines responded, saying only that they “don’t have anything to share”.
asserted
they → respond → anything
The US airline did not confirm whether it had received the Israeli directive or acted on it.
asserted
it → confirm → it
An internal memo to Air France pilots and cabin crew, seen by Mediapart, warned that “failure to comply with this directive would expose Air France and the employee to potential sanctions”.
asserted
failure → see → sanctions
Al Jazeera could not independently verify the memo.
uncertain
Jazeera → verify → memo
The reported restrictions could put Air France at odds with French employment law, said Paris-based anti-discrimination lawyer Clara Gandin, raising questions about whether an airline can comply with a foreign government’s security requirements while ignoring its obligations to its workers.
uncertain
airline → report → workers
“The measure rests on a collective presumption which amounts to a discriminatory bias: Every national of these 31 countries, most of them Arab or Muslim-majority, is treated as a potential security threat,” Gandin told Al Jazeera.
asserted
Gandin → rest → Jazeera
She said Air France’s adoption of the directive amounts to outright “discriminatory harassment”.
asserted
adoption → say → harassment
“Article L1132-1 of the French Labour Code prohibits any discriminatory measure based on a person’s actual or perceived nationality, in particular regarding assignment, pay and discipline,” Gandin said.
asserted
Gandin → prohibit → assignment
“Removing employees from certain flights because they hold Algerian, Tunisian, Iranian or another of Israel’s listed nationalities is therefore direct discrimination – even without loss of pay.
asserted
they → remove → pay
”
With the countries listed on Israel’s list of barred nationalities largely Arab or Muslim-majority, the measure could also constitute “indirect discrimination based on origin, and possibly on perceived religion”, she added.
uncertain
she → list → religion
Gandin explained that French law does make a caveat for a difference in treatment in cases where it is an “occupational requirement”, where a move pursues a “legitimate aim” that is proportionate, and where it is linked to the nature of the job.
asserted
it → explain → job
“Evidently, nationality is not a requirement for flying an aircraft.
asserted
nationality → fly → aircraft
Air France also lets the same pilots and crew operate every other route, which demonstrates it does not regard them as a safety risk,” she said.
asserted
she → let → risk
The lawyer said Air France holds no valid legal justification for adopting Israel’s policy.
asserted
France → say → policy
“Air France’s aim is commercial: keeping access to the Israeli market.
asserted
aim → keep → market
But economic considerations cannot justify discrimination in the eyes of the law,” Gandin said, explaining that the safety objective is Israel’s, not the company’s, and that French law looks at the aim pursued by the employer itself, not its clients.
asserted
law → justify → employer
“More specifically, a third party’s wishes cannot turn a protected characteristic into an occupational requirement,” she added, referencing a 2017 ruling by the Court of Justice of the European Union adopted by France’s highest court that same year.
asserted
she → turn → court
“A proportionate response to a security concern relies on individual assessment, which French aviation security vetting already provides.
asserted
vetting → rely → which
It cannot rest on nationality alone,” Gandin said.
asserted
Gandin → rest → nationality
Airspace sovereignty vs national laws
However, the question of whether the restrictions amount to discrimination under French law is distinct from a state’s authority to regulate access to its airspace and territory.
asserted
restrictions → amount → airspace
Analysts pointed to international civil aviation law, which recognises state sovereignty over territorial airspace under Article 1 of the 1944 Chicago Convention and, subject to specified conditions, the recognition of flight crew licences issued by other contracting states under Article 33.
asserted
which → point → Article
Vincent Correia, a professor of air law at McGill University in Canada, also pointed to Article 13 of the Convention, which allows states to enforce their laws and regulations governing the admission of passengers and crew into their territory.
“Hence, a state can impose immigration restrictions on crews from other countries, on the basis of nationality, given that crew members must go through immigration and customs when flying on international routes,” Correia told Al Jazeera.
asserted
Correia → point → Jazeera
Pilots and other crew from countries that Israel does not have diplomatic relations with were already barred from flying there, making the new measure applicable only to dual citizens, which explains why airlines like Air France might have complied, he explained.
uncertain
he → have → France
Still, Gandin said, a state’s authority to impose entry restrictions does not necessarily exempt airlines from their obligations under other applicable laws, including national anti-discrimination and employment legislation.
asserted
authority → say → legislation
While Air France could make an argument about state sovereignty over airspace, it “does not change the fact that the measure is discriminatory”, she said.
uncertain
she → make → fact
…and 12 more, not listed.
The Aporia
