A crackdown on visa overstayers will only embolden abusers who weaponise Australia's migration system, domestic violence victim-survivor advocates say.
asserted
advocates → embolden → system
The experts say the immigration system has long been documented as a tool of domestic and family violence (DFV), including threats to cancel a visa, report someone to the Department of Home Affairs for potential detention or deportation, or to separate an Australian-born child from their parent.
asserted
system → say → parent
The warning comes as the federal government and opposition have detailed proposals to overhaul the migration system.
asserted
government → come → system
"In my view, the crackdown hands perpetrators more power," immigration lawyer Ann Emmanuel said.
asserted
Emmanuel → hand → power
Ms Emmanuel is a principal solicitor at NSW's only specialist community legal centre that advises on all migration and visa types.
asserted
that → advise → types
She estimated more than 80 per cent of clients at Immigration Advice and Rights Centre's main legal practice faced immigration-related domestic and family violence issues.
asserted
cent → estimate → issues
Perpetrators could often control their partner's visa application process, passports, and interactions with home affairs.
uncertain
Perpetrators → control → affairs
"We have had clients who we discover together during an appointment are now unlawful," Ms Emmanuel said.
asserted
Emmanuel → have → appointment
Clients can discover they've been residing in Australia unlawfully because their partner never made a visa application, or never informed them their visa application was rejected according to Ms Emmanuel.
uncertain
application → discover → Emmanuel
"It's putting victim-survivors in a greater risk of potentially being put in some form of immigration detention when they've done nothing wrong through any fault of their own."
Abusers already using threats of deportation
In his September 17 National Press Club address, Immigration Minister Tony Burke flagged a return to pre-2015 immigration policy where those who overstayed their visa were placed in immigration detention centres.
asserted
who → put → centres
This week, the Coalition also proposed reinstating intelligence functions in Home Affairs to target overstayers, in a wider plan Angus Taylor called "the biggest cut to immigration in Australian history".
asserted
Taylor → propose → history
Migrant women are already worried by the announcements, according to Immigrant Women's Speakout Association of NSW CEO, Maria Kissouri.
uncertain
women → worry → Kissouri
"[Abusers are] already using those threats of deportation, of detention," she said.
asserted
Abusers → use → detention
"That's already been used and weaponised and this is adding fuel to it."
asserted
this → use → it
"There's nothing basic and simple about it and so the solutions are not simple and straightforward either," she added, speaking about the complexity of the migration system.
asserted
she → be → system
"I would love to see the government take a step back, rather than react to ill-informed ideas about migrants."
asserted
government → love → migrants
'We need system reform'
University of Melbourne Professor Marie Segrave, who studies the weaponisation of temporary visas, said politicians did not consider the many factors that might lead to women overstaying their visa.
"
uncertain
women → need → visa
This commitment from the minister doesn't recognise that it also signals to women that you are not safe.
asserted
you → recognise → women
In fact, we're trying to get rid of you if you're in this circumstance of overstaying your visa.
asserted
you → try → visa
"It's actually strengthening the arm of perpetrators who are using women's visa statuses as leverage,"Professor Segrave said.
asserted
Segrave → strengthen → statuses
In a statement to the ABC, a home affairs spokesperson said domestic and family violence was "not acceptable under any circumstance".
asserted
violence → say → circumstance
"[The department] is committed to supporting visa holders experiencing DFV and does not encourage clients (visa applicants/holders or sponsors) to stay in a violent or abusive relationship under any circumstance," they said.
asserted
they → commit → circumstance
The spokesperson also pointed to the department's specialised domestic and family violence support service, which provided victim-survivors with information and support regarding their visa.
asserted
which → point → visa
Shadow Home Affairs and Immigration Minister Jonno Duniam said the Coalition's policy was directed at "people who have no lawful entitlement to remain in Australia" and aimed "at preventing the deliberate misuse of temporary visa and review processes".
asserted
who → say → processes
"It is not in any way about punishing victims of domestic or family violence," he told the ABC.
asserted
he → punish → ABC
The Coalition also recognises that coercive control can involve a perpetrator withholding documents, misleading someone about their visa status and/or deliberately allowing a victim to become unlawful without their knowledge.
asserted
victim → recognise → knowledge
"Those circumstances plainly need to be taken into account when individual cases are considered."
asserted
cases → need → account
One Nation was also contacted for comment.
asserted
Nation → contact → comment
Many systems enabling abusers have faced fresh scrutiny amid a renewed focus on eradicating domestic and family violence from Australia.
asserted
systems → enable → Australia
Professor Segrave questioned why the migration system was not one of them.
asserted
system → question → them
"It's not just the perpetrators we need to focus on, it's the system.
asserted
it → need → ?
And we need system reform."
asserted
we → need → reform
'Piecemeal' protections in place
In 2024, the federal government overhauled the system to introduce a safety net for applicants to apply for permanent residency without staying with their abuser.
asserted
applicants → overhaul → abuser
But advocates criticised its process, including that it asks for proof the relationship is "genuine" via documents that usually do not exist.
asserted
that → criticise → documents
It also only applies to certain visas.
asserted
It → apply → visas
Ms Emmanuel acknowledged the safety net had been "life-changing" for those who could access it but also "piecemeal".
uncertain
who → acknowledge → it
"The protections under the migration system, which we call the family violence provisions, only apply once an application for a certain kind of visa has been made," she said.
asserted
she → call → visa
"So the promise of making an application is still a very effective tool for coercion that perpetrators continue to use and exploit.
asserted
perpetrators → make → that
"
Push for a temporary visa that addresses abuse
The National Advocacy Group on Women on Temporary Visas Experiencing Violence recently issued a blueprint, detailing changes that would make a difference to migration-related abuse.
asserted
that → push → abuse
One of the recommendations was to introduce a new, three-year visa to protect victim-survivors, allowing them time to seek help and safety.
asserted
One → introduce → help
…and 7 more, not listed.
The Aporia