An anti-terrorism court (ATC) on Saturday sought an explanation from jail authorities for failing to produce human rights lawyer Imaan Mazari and her husband, Hadi Ali Chattha, despite a court order directing their appearance in a case related to the removal of security barriers erected for the English cricket team.
asserted
court → seek → team
The couple were indicted by the ATC on Tuesday in the case.
asserted
couple → indict → case
Both opposed the framing of charges, arguing that they had not been provided copies of the case record or allowed to meet their lawyers.
asserted
they → oppose → lawyers
ATC Judge Tahir Abbas Sipra was hearing the case in which the couple have challenged the framing of terrorism charges.
asserted
couple → hear → charges
Neither accused was initially produced before the court, and no representative of the jail administration appeared to explain their absence.
asserted
representative → accuse → absence
The judge directed prosecution and police officials to contact the jail authorities by telephone to ascertain the reason for their non-production.
asserted
judge → direct → production
He also ordered the submission of a written explanation via WhatsApp by 11am.
asserted
He → order → am
Advocate Aimal Khan requested the court to ensure the personal appearance of both accused, pointing out that an earlier order had directed the authorities to produce them either physically or through a video link.
asserted
order → request → link
The couple were subsequently produced before the court through a video link.
asserted
couple → produce → link
Dr Shireen Mazari also appeared, along with lawyers Zainab Janjua and Aimal Khan.
asserted
Mazari → appear → Janjua
At the outset of the hearing, Judge Sipra inquired about photographs taken during the previous proceedings and imposed a ban on mobile phones inside the courtroom.
asserted
Sipra → inquire → courtroom
The restriction was later lifted following a request by court reporters.
asserted
restriction → lift → reporters
Advocate Zainab Janjua informed the court that the accused had challenged the framing of charges before the Islamabad High Court (IHC), where their petition was scheduled to be heard on Monday.
asserted
petition → inform → Monday
She requested the trial court to defer proceedings until the high court considered their challenge.
asserted
court → request → challenge
“What does it matter?
asserted
it → matter → What
If the framing of charges is set aside, the entire proceedings will come to an end,” Judge Sipra remarked, observing that the challenge before the high court did not automatically prevent the trial court from proceeding.
asserted
challenge → set → court
The judge also questioned why the trial had stalled at this stage, noting that superior courts had already dealt with related matters and that a show-cause notice had previously been issued.
asserted
notice → question → matters
Janjua questioned the repeated failure of jail authorities to produce the accused despite standard operating procedures governing their appearance.
asserted
Janjua → question → appearance
She also sought an adjournment, saying senior counsel Riasat Ali Azad was unavailable.
asserted
Azad → seek → adjournment
During the video-link hearing, Chattha told the court that he and his wife respected the judge and had regularly appeared before him.
asserted
he → tell → him
Referring to the principle of a fair trial, he said they had learnt from the judge that judicial proceedings could not be conducted without due process.
uncertain
proceedings → refer → process
“Why are we not being produced before the court?” he asked, questioning how their right to a fair trial under Article 10 of the Constitution was being protected.
asserted
right → produce → Constitution
He also referred to newspaper reports stating that charges had been framed against them.
asserted
charges → refer → them
Judge Sipra asked whether the couple had challenged the framing of charges, observing that the high court could set them aside if they had not been framed in accordance with the law.
uncertain
they → ask → law
The judge also directed a prison official to arrange chairs for the accused during their video-link appearance and questioned why they had not been brought to court physically as ordered.
asserted
they → direct → court
He directed the relevant authorities to submit a written explanation by 11am regarding the failure to produce the couple.
asserted
He → direct → couple
The court adjourned the proceedings pending the submission of the report by the jail administration.
asserted
court → adjourn → administration
When the hearing resumed, the court disposed of the petition seeking to drop the terrorism charges, saying that this was not an appropriate stage to grant the relief sought without hearing arguments from the lawyers representing the two accused, whose counsel had boycotted the proceedings.
asserted
counsel → resume → proceedings
During the proceedings, the court noted that, according to the report submitted by the jail authorities following the adjournment, the Islamabad Police had failed to provide an escort to bring Imaan Mazari and Hadi Ali Chattha to court.
uncertain
Police → note → court
The court observed that the two accused could not be brought to court because the police had failed to provide the required security.
uncertain
police → observe → security
Advocate Janjua said the state was acknowledging that the accused had not been brought to court owing to its own failure to provide an escort.
asserted
accused → say → escort
“On the one hand, the state is asking the court to record the witnesses’ statements today, while, on the other, the same state is failing to provide security for Imaan and Hadi to appear before the court,” she remarked.
asserted
she → ask → court
She maintained that the failure to ensure their appearance was undermining the accused’s right to a fair trial.
asserted
failure → maintain → trial
The lawyer couple has been in jail since their arrest on Jan 23 in a case registered against them for protesting outside the Islamabad High Court (IHC) and allegedly manhandling the IHC Bar Association (IHCBA) president.
uncertain
couple → register → president
The arrest prompted criticism by rights bodies, politicians and journalists, who stressed the couple’s right to a fair trial.
asserted
who → prompt → trial
Just a day later, a sessions court sentenced them to 17 years on multiple charges under the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (Peca) in a case pertaining to controversial social media posts.
asserted
court → sentence → posts
The convictions were widely condemned by lawyers and United Nations (UN) experts.
asserted
convictions → condemn → lawyers
On Sept 17, following months of litigation before the courts, the Supreme Court suspended their sentences in the case.
asserted
Court → follow → case
The SC ordered their release pending the Islamabad High Court’s final verdict on their appeals against the trial court’s decision.
asserted
SC → order → decision
However, the reprieve was short-lived as hours later, Islamabad police arrested the couple again in connection with another case and produced them before an ATC, which sent them to jail on judicial remand.
asserted
which → live → remand
…and 4 more, not listed.
The Aporia
