This week, a columnist for The New York Times’ The Athletic called for the Indiana Fever to part ways with Sophie Cunningham.
asserted
Fever → call → Cunningham
"She’s too turbulent to be paired with Caitlin Clark," Candace Buckner wrote in the headline.
asserted
Buckner → ’ → headline
"[I]f the Fever ever want to go back to being a basketball team again and follow the lead of rivals openly clashing with the forces trying to hijack their league, then Cunningham has to go," she added.
asserted
she → want → league
This page may contain affiliate links to legal sports betting partners.
uncertain
page → contain → partners
If you sign up or place a wager, FOX News may be compensated.
uncertain
News → sign → wager
This content was created by a team that works independently from the FOX newsroom.
asserted
that → create → newsroom
The column portrays Cunningham as an outspoken agitator whose growing profile has become a distraction for the Fever.
asserted
profile → portray → Fever
As evidence, Buckner cited comments Cunningham made earlier this year in an ESPN article about trans athletes competing against girls.
asserted
Cunningham → cite → girls
For background, Cunningham said she "loves" all communities but believes it is important to "protect young girls" and that they "shouldn’t have to go against biological men" in sports.
asserted
they → say → sports
WNBA players and members of the media subsequently framed those comments as transphobic.
asserted
players → frame → comments
We emphasize that particular comment because, beyond it, Cunningham has hardly been the political lightning rod her detractors depict her as.
asserted
detractors → emphasize → her
Most of Cunningham’s public persona consists of playing basketball, dancing on TikTok, and trying on outfits.
asserted
Most → consist → outfits
One could argue that her personality and attractive appearance have contributed to her supposed polarizing status.
uncertain
personality → argue → status
As Sydney Sweeney could attest, a certain corner of the media and social media seems uniquely irritated by attractive blonde women who refuse to apologize for it.
uncertain
who → attest → it
The second-most controversial thing Cunningham has said recently was telling A’ja Wilson to "grow up" after Wilson charged toward a courtside fan who pointed at her during a playoff game.
asserted
who → say → game
Teammates had to restrain Wilson before arena security intervened.
asserted
security → have → Wilson
And yet, The New York Times’ sports vertical has seen enough.
asserted
vertical → see → enough
It's time for the Fever to move on, the reporter declared.
asserted
reporter → move → ?
One might find The Athletic’s position more persuasive if it were consistent.
uncertain
it → find → ?
Unlike Cunningham, Rapinoe spent years making politics central to her public identity.
asserted
politics → spend → identity
She knelt during the national anthem and later said she would probably never sing it again.
asserted
she → kneel → it
She claimed during the 2019 World Cup that she was "not going to the f---ing White House" if President Donald Trump invited the team.
asserted
Trump → claim → team
She publicly supported Democratic candidates, including Hillary Clinton and Elizabeth Warren.
asserted
She → support → Clinton
She described Trump as "sexist," "misogynistic," "small-minded," "racist," and "not a good person."
asserted
She → describe → Trump
Rapinoe also condemned the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision overturning Roe v. Wade as "sad and cruel," became a prominent supporter of Black Lives Matter, repeatedly advocated for transgender women to compete in women’s sports, and once dismissed concerns about competitive fairness as "total bullshit."
More recently, she called for traditional WNBA media to make room for people who "understand queer culture."
asserted
who → condemn → culture
After tearing her Achilles in the final match of her career, Rapinoe said afterward that the injury was "proof that there isn’t" a God.
asserted
injury → tear → career
Whatever one thinks of those positions, no reasonable person could describe Rapinoe as reluctant to inject politics, religion, and contentious social issues into sports.
Yet the sports media never mounted a campaign for Rapinoe’s teams to part ways with her because she was too "turbulent."
uncertain
she → think → her
Her activism was not treated as an impediment to her team getting "back to being a soccer team."
asserted
team → treat → impediment
Rapinoe became one of the most celebrated athletes in American sports media, in no small part because of her willingness to speak about politics – the right side of politics, that is.
asserted
that → become → politics
Her activism was incorporated into her public brand and routinely presented as evidence of courage and leadership.
asserted
activism → incorporate → courage
The sports media rarely treats athletes who espouse liberal or progressive political views as problematic, even when those views are provocative, divisive, or factually incorrect.
asserted
views → treat → views
LeBron James has spent years commenting on presidential politics, policing, and race all in favor of Democratic positions.
asserted
James → spend → positions
Colin Kaepernick turned an anthem protest into the defining feature of his public identity.
asserted
Kaepernick → turn → identity
Sue Bird, Breanna Stewart and Natasha Cloud have routinely spoken about progressive political causes.
asserted
Bird → speak → causes
Steve Kerr has addressed topics ranging from gun control to presidential politics and supported Kamala Harris for president on stage at the Democratic National Convention in 2024.
asserted
Kerr → address → 2024
We can't find a single article from The Athletic, New York Times, ESPN, The Ringer, Washington Post, or CBS Sports critical of any of those statements.
asserted
We → find → statements
Meanwhile, the same reporters and commentators treat Cunningham saying that girls deserve protected athletic categories, Harrison Butker promoting traditional marriage, or Jaxson Dart introducing Trump on stage
asserted
Dart → treat → stage
See, the perspectives of many sports writers are shaped by the bubble in which they operate.
asserted
they → see → which
In their world — virtual newsrooms, Bluesky, Threads, Instagram and sports blogs — saying that men and women possess meaningful biological differences can qualify as an outrageous offense.
asserted
men → say → offense
National polling consistently shows that between 75-80% of voting Americans oppose biological males competing in women’s sports.
asserted
% → show → sports
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
