Court ruling narrows pathway to citizenship for DACA recipients
asserted
ruling → narrow → recipients
-
Click here to listen to this article -
- The ruling concerns how recipients of DACA may travel abroad and their ability to obtain green cards.
-
uncertain
recipients → click → cards
Some DACA recipients can still safely travel, but others — particularly those with deportation orders — could face reentry bans.
uncertain
others → travel → bans
The Trump administration has largely ended a pathway to citizenship for DACA recipients who marry U.S. citizens.
asserted
who → end → citizens
President Trump tried, unsuccessfully, to end DACA during his first term.
asserted
Trump → try → term
This week’s action reflects his administration’s ongoing focus on the Obama-era program that shields from deportation hundreds of thousands of immigrants, often referred to as Dreamers, who were brought to the U.S. as children.
asserted
who → reflect → children
DACA renewal delays are costing some recipients their jobs and exposing them to deportation risk as the Trump administration chips away at protections for immigrants brought to the U.S. as children.
asserted
administration → cost → children
“It was inevitable that what Trump was going to do in office this time was to embark on a massive delegalization mission,” said Karen Tumlin, director of the Justice Action Center in Los Angeles.
asserted
Tumlin → go → Angeles
“That’s what this is.”
asserted
this → ’ → ?
Tumlin was referring to a ruling by an administrative immigration court that was published Thursday.
asserted
that → refer → court
The ruling concerns a travel provision afforded to recipients of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, the program created in 2012.
asserted
ruling → concern → 2012
The provision allows DACA recipients to travel in ways other people without legal status cannot.
asserted
people → allow → status
DACA isn’t technically a form of legal status, though its recipients are granted work permits.
asserted
recipients → grant → permits
For immigrants who entered the U.S. illegally, leaving the country or being deported triggers a penalty — many are banned from coming back into the U.S. for a decade.
asserted
many → enter → decade
Most people who qualify for legal residency, or a green card, have to serve that 10-year ban before they can apply for the green card, which can lead to citizenship.
asserted
which → qualify → citizenship
But DACA recipients, under the travel provision called advance parole, could leave the U.S. for school, work or humanitarian reasons.
uncertain
recipients → call → reasons
When they returned through an airport or border, the stain of their original unlawful entry was erased.
asserted
stain → return → entry
With the penalty wiped away, a DACA recipient married to a U.S. citizen or who had another way to obtain legal residency could start that process for a green card without delay.
uncertain
who → wipe → delay
Thursday’s ruling by the Board of Immigration Appeals does away with that benefit.
asserted
ruling → do → benefit
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services spokesman Zach Kahler said the decision confirms a “straightforward principle” that departing the U.S. has meaning.
asserted
departing → say → meaning
“The immigration laws enacted by Congress impose consequences when someone who has accrued unlawful presence leaves the country and later seeks admission, including when that departure occurs under advance parole,” he said.
asserted
he → enact → parole
“U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services will ensure that immigration filings are decided based on the laws, regulations, and binding legal precedent that govern each case.”
asserted
that → ensure → case
Immigration attorneys and other advocates quickly convened Thursday to determine how the ruling will affect immigrants.
asserted
ruling → convene → immigrants
Tumlin said some DACA recipients can still safely travel with advance parole, while for others — particularly those with deportation orders — it would be too risky to leave.
asserted
it → say → orders
She said DACA recipients should consult an immigration attorney before traveling.
asserted
recipients → say → attorney
“For over a decade, I could reassure my clients that traveling on Advance Parole was a safe option,” Shilpa Malik, an immigration lawyer in Florida, wrote Thursday on X. “What was once a vital protection is now gone.”
uncertain
was → reassure → X.
Under the ruling, having the travel document may no longer protect certain DACA recipients when they return from their trips abroad, because leaving could expose them to the years-long ban.
uncertain
leaving → have → ban
The decision also makes obtaining green cards more difficult.
asserted
obtaining → make → cards
Tumlin said some DACA recipients could qualify for waivers that allow them to avoid the years-long reentry ban, but the waivers are granted under limited circumstances.
uncertain
waivers → say → circumstances
The latest federal data show there are 455,000 DACA recipients in the U.S. as of March, with about 126,000 in California.
asserted
data → show → California
According to the nonpartisan Congressional Research Service, 45,447 DACA recipients were approved for advance parole as of Aug. 21, 2017.
uncertain
recipients → accord → Aug.
About 76,000 DACA recipients had become legal residents as of July 31, 2019, most after marrying a U.S. citizen, according to the research service.
uncertain
recipients → become → service
It’s unclear how many DACA recipients have obtained advance parole or green cards since then.
uncertain
recipients → ’ → parole
Path2Papers, a project at Cornell Law School, analyzed 1,600 consults and estimated that around 60% of DACA recipients would be subject to the 10-year ban.
asserted
% → analyze → ban
Republicans have viewed advance parole as an abuse of the immigration system.
asserted
Republicans → view → system
The office of Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) blasted the provision, saying in 2017 that “the Obama administration allowed thousands of DACA recipients to exploit an immigration law loophole to obtain green cards.”
asserted
thousands → blast → cards
Last year, Grassley introduced a bill to guarantee that it would no longer be used by immigrants seeking to adjust their legal status.
asserted
it → introduce → status
This week’s ruling essentially accomplishes that goal.
asserted
ruling → accomplish → goal
The immigration appeals board’s decision applies to future travel.
asserted
decision → apply → travel
People who previously traveled and returned to the U.S. won’t be affected and could still adjust their immigration status.
uncertain
who → travel → status
…and 4 more, not listed.
The Aporia
