Daily Mail
· collected 2026-10-07 · by Ashley Nickel, Nicholas Comino
In Melbourne and Sydney, pro-Palestine protesters gathered on October 7, the third anniversary of Hamas's attack on Israel that killed around 1,200 people. The protests in Melbourne were met with counter-protests by Israel supporters and led to clashes with police, while the event in Sydney was less chaotic, attended by about 150 people. Political leaders criticized these vigils as insensitive; NSW Premier Chris Minns called them "heartless," though he acknowledged no legal basis for preventing them.
Written locally by qwen2.5:14b on 2026-10-07,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Pro-Palestine protesters have descended on the Melbourne and Sydney CBDs on the third anniversary of Hamas' October 7 attacks on Israel.
asserted
protesters → descend → Israel
The co-ordinated bloody surprise attack on a music festival and the surrounding communities in southern Israel was carried out by the group which controls Gaza.
The terrorists killed about 1,200 people, mostly innocent civilians, which in turn triggered a massive, long-running bombing campaign from Israel on Palestine as retaliation.
asserted
which → co → retaliation
Splinter pro-Palestine groups in Australia organised the vigils to coincide with the anniversary in Sydney and Melbourne, while some other pro-Palestine groups were opposed to them being held on the date.
asserted
them → organise → date
In Melbourne, tensions between demonstrators and police quickly flared as a rival Israeli group held a counter-protest.
asserted
group → flare → protest
Pictures from the scene show protesters, notably Israeli activist and broadcaster Avi Yemini screaming at officers.
asserted
protesters → show → officers
The event in Sydney was notably less chaotic, with a crowd of no more than 150 and speakers reading poetry to the crowd.
asserted
event → read → crowd
Though it followed weeks of criticism from politicians, including Premier Chris Minns labelling the vigils 'heartless'.
asserted
it → follow → vigils
The 'Vigil for Gaza' outside Town Hall, organised by Jews Against the Occupation '48 and supported by a number of pro-Palestine groups, was promoted under the slogan 'Don't Let Israel Steal the Date'.
asserted
Israel → organise → Date
Promotional material for the event stated that 'its genocidal airstrikes began on October 7th 2023' and called for a vigil to mark the date in solidarity with Gaza.
asserted
airstrikes → state → Gaza
Pro-Palestine protesters were seen clashing with police in Melbourne on Wednesday, October 7
A large police presence watched over the vigil in Melbourne CBD
The event was held to mark the third anniversary of the October 7 attack Hamas launched on Israel in 2023
asserted
Hamas → see → 2023
The decision to hold the vigil on the anniversary also drew fierce criticism from NSW Opposition Leader Kellie Sloane who weighed in on the issue on Tuesday.
asserted
who → hold → Tuesday
Sloane urged the NSW Government to oppose the event, describing it as insensitive and deliberately provocative.
asserted
Sloane → urge → it
'It is inappropriate, it is sickening, it is cruel, and it's provocative to be holding these events on October 7,' she said.
'To do it on any other day would show a little bit of credibility.
asserted
do → hold → credibility
To do it on this day shows their true motivation, which is to provoke, which is to make people feel uneasy, and that is not on.
asserted
that → show → motivation
'At a time when we all need to be coming together and respectfully sharing opinions, this is the antithesis of that.
asserted
this → need → that
Minns was just as scathing and condemned the Sydney vigil, describing the event as 'heartless', while acknowledging authorities had no legal basis to prevent it from proceeding.
asserted
authorities → condemn → it
'There are some people suggesting it can be stopped.
asserted
it → be → ?
The Constitution doesn't allow that,' Minns said.
asserted
Minns → allow → that
They can certainly do that.
asserted
They → do → that
It's not against the law, but, as a citizen, I've got a right to make a judgement on it, too.
asserted
I → get → it
Organisers claimed the events in Melbourne (above) and Sydney were to highlight the ongoing Israeli offensive in Gaza
Professional activist Josh Lees was a prominent figure at the Sydney protest
asserted
Lees → claim → protest
The Sydney vigil (above) was notably quieter than the Melbourne event
NSW Premier Chris Minns had labelled the vigil as 'heartless' given it marked the date of Hamas' massacre of Israeli civilians
Attempts to stop the event in Sydney (above) were found to have no legal basis
'
asserted
Attempts → label → basis
I think these organisers, in many cases, thrive on the notoriety and the attention they get.'
asserted
they → think → notoriety
The Sydney event was one of two pro-Palestinian commemorations planned for October 7 in NSW.
asserted
event → plan → NSW
A separate gathering in Wollongong, organised by Wollongong Friends of Palestine, was advertised as a three-hour event to 'stop and remember the martyrs'.
asserted
gathering → organise → martyrs
The wording used in promotional material for the Wollongong event also attracted criticism from opponents, who argued the language was offensive given the significance of the anniversary for the Jewish community.
asserted
language → use → community
Organisers of the Town Hall vigil defended the choice of date, arguing that October 7 also marked the beginning of Israel's military campaign in Gaza following the Hamas attacks.
asserted
October → defend → attacks
Material circulated ahead of the event said the 'Gaza Uprising on 7 October 2023' must be viewed in the context of decades of occupation.
asserted
Uprising → circulate → occupation
They also highlighted that Israeli airstrikes began later that day after Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu declared Israel was at war.
asserted
Israel → highlight → war
The promotional material also referenced actions taken by Israel in the days after the attacks, including allegations of war crimes that have been the subject of international legal proceedings.
asserted
that → reference → proceedings
The Aporia
