Toronto Star
· collected 2026-10-05 · by David Baxter The Canadian Press
Public Safety Minister Gary Anandasangaree acknowledged gaps in Canada’s security screening process on Monday after confirming a Canadian charged with espionage was given a security clearance.
asserted
Canadian → acknowledge → clearance
Anandasangaree was called to answer questions at the House of Commons national security committee, which is studying Canada’s security screening process following the arrest of a Canadian NATO intern in Belgium in July.
asserted
which → call → July
The minister said the woman was given a security clearance by Global Affairs Canada.
asserted
woman → say → Canada
He said about half a million people have some form of security clearance and government departments process about 200,000 applications annually.
asserted
departments → say → applications
“By and large, our security apparatus does a comprehensive job with respect to security screening,” Anandasangaree told the committee Monday.
asserted
Anandasangaree → do → screening
Of course there are gaps here and I recognize that there are gaps, and that’s what I think we need to improve on.”
asserted
we → be → what
Vanessa Lloyd, CSIS deputy director, told the committee she could not comment specifically on the suspect but the type of NATO internship she held normally involves a “secret” level of clearance.
uncertain
she → tell → clearance
The Belgian prosecutor’s office described the suspect as “a Canadian national of Chinese origin.”
asserted
office → describe → origin
She was arrested on charges of espionage and participation in a criminal organization in late July.
asserted
She → arrest → July
A federal source not authorized to speak publicly about the issue previously said officials in Canada were proceeding on the basis the suspect is Biwei Zhang — also known as Claire Zhang — who was previously employed by Canadian government agencies.
asserted
who → authorize → agencies
Anandasangaree and government officials told the committee they could not answer specific questions about the suspect because they do not want to jeopardize the criminal investigation.
uncertain
they → tell → investigation
The minister added Canadian security officials are co-operating fully with their Belgian counterparts.
asserted
officials → add → counterparts
The minister said he was first informed of the espionage allegations about a week before they were made public.
asserted
they → say → allegations
In a media scrum after the meeting, he said Canadian officials monitored the situation but knew there was no risk to individuals or information before the arrest was announced.
asserted
arrest → say → individuals
“It was based on the fact that individual was apprehended or was going to be apprehended and there was monitoring by the Belgian authorities.
asserted
individual → base → authorities
So at that point, I was quite confident that there was no public risk based on that individual,” Anandasangaree said.
asserted
Anandasangaree → be → individual
“What happened before is something I think is now the subject of the investigation.
asserted
I → happen → investigation
But from the time I understood and learned about this to the time the formal announcement took place, I was quite comfortable that individual was secured and it would be minimal if no risk to the public.”
asserted
it → understand → public
Opposition committee members pressed the minister to explain how the espionage suspect was able to get a security clearance despite being found to have committed fraud in 2023.
asserted
suspect → press → 2023
Court records said the Public Service Commission of Canada found in 2023 that Zhang committed fraud in an appointment process for a position with the Canada Border Services Agency.
asserted
Zhang → say → Agency
The Federal Court dismissed her application for judicial review of the decision the following year.
asserted
Court → dismiss → decision
She submitted a letter of apology during the investigation into her actions.
asserted
She → submit → actions
Responding to a question from Ontario Conservative MP Rhonda Kirkland, Anandasangaree said taking part in any kind of criminal offence “could preclude individuals from serving in government.”
uncertain
taking → respond → government
Anandasangaree said deputy department heads are responsible for granting security clearances, which can be based on information provided by CSIS and the RCMP.
asserted
which → say → CSIS
He said his office has received recommendations from both of those security agencies and he is actively reviewing them.
asserted
he → say → them
Anandasangaree said he is not sure whether the espionage suspect still has a security clearance and deferred that question to Global Affairs Canada when asked by media following his testimony.
asserted
suspect → say → testimony
He also deferred questions about whether there have been any repercussions for the person who granted the espionage suspect a security clearance.
asserted
who → defer → clearance
Adam Hatfield, Treasury Board Secretariat acting assistant deputy minister, told the committee applicants for base level security clearance go through a variety of screens, including — but not limited to — a criminal record check, a credit check and an internet search for questionable public activity.
asserted
applicants → act → activity
Higher clearance levels go through more rigorous screening.
asserted
levels → go → screening
He added security officials around the world are grappling with the same complex and globalized threat environment.
“Very frequently when we learn lessons, it isn’t at the level of policy.
asserted
it → add → policy
It’s at the level of training a security official, the tools that they had, the criteria that they use.
asserted
they → ’ → that
These are judgment decisions that are made,” Hatfield said.
asserted
Hatfield → make → ?
“You can look at a judgment decision between two different government organizations where one would say, ‘Based on our threat environment we would have said yes,’ and another would say, ‘Well, given our circumstances we would have said no in that situation.’
asserted
we → look → situation
And there are always cases that are right on that edge.”
asserted
that → be → edge
Hatfield said the “vast majority” of the more than 200,000 people who undergo security screening for Canada are reliable public servants.
asserted
who → say → Canada
The committee is scheduled to continue its study of the security screening process Wednesday.
asserted
committee → schedule → process
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Oct. 5, 2026.
asserted
report → publish → Press
The Aporia
