Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem strongly criticized a New York Times report alleging her agency paid $108 million for a luxury Boeing 737 and other aircraft from Daedalus Aviation Corp. just before she was fired, claiming this price was significantly higher than what the company originally paid for them. Noem accused the NYT of misleading readers by calling William Walters, Daedalus's chairman who donated to her political action committee, a "donor." The Times stands by its reporting and states that the deals were approved during Noem’s tenure, with aviation experts noting that the planes' market value was likely much lower.
Written locally by qwen2.5:14b on 2026-10-05,
using this article's own text rather than the other coverage of the
same event (that is the story summary below).
Why this leaning score
The model judged this article politically coded and scored it -0.35, but every quote it verified points right, so the score is not published.
Written under an earlier scoring contract, which gave a paragraph
rather than checkable quotes. Re-analysing this article replaces it.
Leaning score withheld for article 58042: score contradicts its own evidence · logged 2026-10-05
Fired Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem went ballistic over claims that her former agency vastly overpaid a political donor's company for five airplanes just hours before she left office.
uncertain
she → fire → office
In a furious social media post, Noem demanded that The New York Times “entirely” retract its exposé regarding the last-minute spending spree, which reportedly included $108 million for a luxuriously appointed Boeing 737 that the company bought months earlier from a seller who asked for less than $90 million.
uncertain
who → demand → million
Noem's post also said that calling Daedalus Aviation Corp. Chair William Walters a “donor” was “materially misleading” and "conveys a false implication of a direct financial relationship obviously intended to influence official action."
“Numerous times clarifications were made to the journalists responsible for this libelous story,” Noem, now a State Department special envoy to the “Shield of the Americas” security initiative, said Sunday.
asserted
Noem → say → initiative
In a Monday statement to The Independent, an NYT spokesperson said, “We stand by the characterization of the political donor and his firm.”
asserted
We → say → donor
“As our article makes clear, the Department of Homeland Security bought five airplanes from Daedalus at a substantial markup, a deal approved during Ms. Noem's tenure,” NYT spokesperson Nicole Taylor said.
asserted
Taylor → make → tenure
“Daedalus’s chairman is William Walters, who gave $10,000 to the American Resolve political action committee, a group that existed to support Ms. Noem.”
asserted
that → give → Noem
Daedalus Aviation didn't immediately return an inquiry from The Independent, but the company reportedly told the NYT that Walters didn't know the PAC was associated with Noem, even though it featured Noem's image on its website.
uncertain
it → return → website
In addition to the converted Boeing 737 — which reportedly features a stand-up bar, two bedrooms, marble showers and a table covered with manta ray skin — DHS paid $106 million for two Gulfstream luxury jets that Daedalus marked up after buying them for $83 million, the NYT said, citing documents it reviewed.
uncertain
it → feature → documents
DHS also reportedly paid $45 million each for two 17-year-old Boeing 737 passenger planes, with aviation experts telling the NYT that their typical market value was millions less.
uncertain
value → pay → NYT
Noem's successor, Markwayne Mullin, reportedly considered canceling the purchases but didn't do so after speaking with White House chief of staff Susie Wiles, who shared his concern about having to pay a hefty penalty for backing out of the deal.
uncertain
who → consider → deal
DHS has declined to release a copy of the contract, according to the NYT.
uncertain
DHS → decline → NYT
In a statement to The Independent, a DHS spokesperson didn't deny Mullins' reported discussion with Wiles and said, “These planes were purchased prior to Secretary Mullin’s arrival at DHS."
asserted
planes → deny → DHS
A White House official also told The Independent that Noem purchased the planes and confirmed that Mullin sought advice from the White House about canceling the agreement.
asserted
Mullin → tell → agreement
The official said an unspecified termination fee in the contract led the administration to decide that keeping the planes was the most fiscally responsible move.
asserted
keeping → say → planes
In August, the NYT reported that DHS paid Daedalus $464 million for 10 planes during Noem's tenure, which was marked by widespread outrage over the fatal January shootings of anti-ICE protesters Renee Good and Alex Pretti in Minneapolis.
asserted
which → report → Minneapolis
The 10 planes, which DHS said were desperately needed for deportation flights, have since largely gone to waste because the agency doesn't have crews to fly them, according to the NYT.
uncertain
agency → say → NYT
President Donald Trump announced Noem's firing on March 5, one day after she was asked during a House Judiciary Committee hearing whether she'd engaged in an extramarital affair with top adviser Corey Lewandowski.
asserted
she → announce → Lewandowski
Noem called the question “tabloid garbage” but didn't answer it directly.
Both she and Lewandowski — whom Trump fired as his campaign manager in 2016 and as head of his Make America Great Again Action super PAC in 2021 — have denied rumors of an alleged affair.
asserted
Trump → call → affair
Noem remained a Cabinet member until March 24, when DHS amended its contract with Daedalus to include the purchase of the lavishly customized 737 and the four other planes, according to the NYT.
uncertain
DHS → remain → NYT
Under Noem, DHS reportedly awarded more than $900 million worth of contracts to companies led by Walters, including Salus Worldwide Solutions, which was hired to encourage migrants to voluntarily leave the U.S. and to fly Noem and her aides on chartered jets.
uncertain
which → award → jets
Sunday's NYT report followed Noem's announcement last week that she was divorcing her husband Bryon Noem, about seven months after the Daily Mail revealed that he paid adult entertainers to chat with him online while he wore giant fake breasts and pink hot pants.
asserted
he → follow → breasts
The practice is part of a sexual fetish called “bimbofication,” and a Noem spokesperson told the Mail at the time that she was “devastated” and “blindsided.”
asserted
she → call → time
Bryon Noem “is saddened that the marriage is ending and hopes for a private and amicable resolution
asserted
marriage → sadden → resolution
,” lawyer Tim Bottum told the Mail last week.
“If court proceedings become necessary, Bryon will welcome the opportunity to truthfully share his perspective,” Bottum added.
asserted
Bottum → tell → perspective
The Aporia
