From floating saunas to clinical trials: How heat might help mental health
uncertain
heat → float → health
From floating saunas to clinical trials: How heat might help mental health
The belief that heat can benefit the mind and relieve psychic suffering has a long history across human societies.
uncertain
heat → float → societies
But when Eva Hilland scanned the scientific literature for the kind of evidence that would support recommending heat as a legitimate intervention for mental health, she came up with very little.
asserted
she → scan → little
"There are many knowledge gaps," says Hilland, a cognitive neuroscientist at Oslo Metropolitan University.
asserted
Hilland → be → University
Although, what existing evidence she did find seemed promising.
asserted
find → exist → evidence
"So we just saw the potential."
asserted
we → see → potential
Sauna-going – sometimes paired with cold plunges or winter swimming – is attracting a new generation of followers, from the U.S. to Hilland's sauna-steeped country of Norway.
asserted
going → pair → Norway
The trend not only reflects the reach of the broader wellness and longevity movement, but also a thirst for communal experience and social connection, particularly in the wake of the pandemic.
asserted
trend → reflect → pandemic
The science is just beginning to catch up with many of the theorized benefits.
asserted
science → begin → benefits
Though considerably less studied than the cardiovascular impact, mental health has emerged as one of the more exciting and appealing applications.
asserted
health → study → applications
Hilland, whose research group focuses on neuroimaging and genetics, is one of the scientists now diving into this research domain of heat and mental health.
asserted
group → focus → heat
And she's leveraging the sauna popularity surge in her own city, Oslo, to do it.
asserted
she → leverage → it
With funding from a local municipality, she's recruiting 50 people for a randomized controlled trial to see whether coupling sauna with a simple set of mental health habits improves stress, well-being, sleep and more.
asserted
coupling → recruit → stress
Instead of visiting a windowless research lab, her study participants take two sessions a week at one of the floating sauna villages that have cropped up in Oslo's inner harbor – a waterfront that has transformed into a world-class destination for heat-seekers in just the past decade.
asserted
that → visit → decade
Large surveys of sauna users reflect what many readily share: It's the psychological benefits more than anything else that keeps them coming back, whether that's stress reduction, elevated mood, improved sleep or the ineffable post-sauna glow.
asserted
that → reflect → them
Some of these self-reported improvements may have less to do with sweating and more to do with the digital detox, time in nature, mindfulness and social connection that sauna-going facilitates.
uncertain
going → report → that
But the weight of the evidence suggests heat itself is also "powerful physiological stimulus for promoting mental health," says Christopher Lowry, an integrative physiologist and neuroscientist at the University of Colorado, Boulder.
uncertain
Lowry → suggest → Colorado
What we know heat does
While warm baths were commonplace in psychiatric asylums a century ago, the modern evidence base largely rests on translational work done with animals and cell models, and a small number of human studies, most of which lack strict control groups.
asserted
most → know → groups
In his lab, Lowry has extensively explored the physiological mechanisms linking temperature and mental health.
asserted
Lowry → explore → temperature
When our skin senses heat, those signals travel to a primitive part of the brain that tells our body to cool down.
asserted
that → sense → body
That process overlaps with a pathway involved in mood and pleasure, which is implicated in depression.
asserted
which → overlap → depression
Heat also triggers a specific anti-inflammatory response.
asserted
Heat → trigger → response
A similar phenomenon occurs during exercise, a well-established treatment for depression and other mental health conditions.
asserted
phenomenon → occur → depression
And separately, Lowry says, animal studies find heat activates a group of "serotonin neurons" in the brain that may "provide stress resilience and antidepressant effects."
uncertain
that → say → resilience
In humans, the strongest data come from a landmark trial, published ten years ago, and led by a team at the University of Wisconsin-Madison and co-authored by Lowry.
asserted
data → come → Lowry
A total of 30 people with depression were randomly separated into two groups.
asserted
total → separate → groups
About half spent around two hours in a whole-body infrared machine designed to raise their body temperature to 38.5 C, or about 101 F. The rest received a sham treatment.
asserted
rest → spend → treatment
Within a week, a majority of those in the treatment group had a 50% reduction in their symptoms and the effects persisted throughout the six-week follow-up period.
asserted
effects → have → period
Training the body to cool down
Those findings are what originally inspired Ashley Mason to enter the field.
asserted
what → train → field
A clinical psychologist who studies mood disorders and sleep at the University of California, San Francisco, Mason now has funding from the National Institutes of Health and others to study various forms of heat therapy for depression, sleep and loneliness.
asserted
Mason → study → depression
The renewed scientific interest in using heat for psychiatric conditions, in part, reflects an intriguing observation – people with depression tend to have difficulty with thermoregulation.
asserted
people → renew → thermoregulation
"What we know from a bunch of literature is that depressed people seem to run hot," says Mason, also a professor of psychiatry and behavioral science.
asserted
Mason → know → psychiatry
"When their depression improves, their thermoregulatory system seems to also change."
asserted
system → improve → ?
In fact, Mason's lab recently tracked this association between self-reported symptoms of depression and body temperature using wearable device data collected from close to 20,000 people.
asserted
lab → track → people
Even when controlling for factors like weather and medical conditions, symptom severity correlated with higher skin temperature and less daily fluctuation in body temperature, meaning their bodies weren't cooling down as much at night.
asserted
bodies → control → night
It may seem counterintuitive to heat folks up even more, but Mason says doing so seems to function like a "thermoregulatory workout" – training their system to become more efficient at cooling down in the long run.
uncertain
doing → seem → run
"So when you are actually done being exposed to that heat, your body temperature drops for a much longer period of time than you were spending in that heat," she says.
asserted
she → do → heat
"Days, possibly weeks, we still don't know."
uncertain
we → know → Days
Several older studies have also shown that successfully treating people with antidepressant medication or other therapies improves their thermoregulation.
asserted
treating → show → thermoregulation
The implication, Masons says, is that acting on this "bi-directional" relationship – both via heat and traditional therapeutic approaches – could have a synergistic effect.
uncertain
acting → say → effect
…and 9 more, not listed.
The Aporia
