Photo via Fox News

No, the San Diego Padres didn't lose because of controversial ninth inning home run ruling

Read the original at Fox News ↗
Cite

Miller, I. (2026, October 4). No, the San Diego Padres didn't lose because of controversial ninth inning home run ruling. Fox News. https://www.foxnews.com/outkick-sports/san-diego-padres-didnt-lose-controversial-ninth-inning-home-run-ruling

Dated when The Aporia collected the article, usually within hours of publication. Check the original for its exact date and byline.

Fox News · collected 2026-10-04 · by Ian Miller

Quick Summary

In Saturday night's Major League Baseball playoff game between the San Diego Padres and Milwaukee Brewers, controversy erupted during the ninth inning over a disputed home run ruling. Ty France hit a high fly ball that struck the roof support system at American Family Field before falling into play where it was caught for an out. Despite initial confusion among fans and players about the legitimacy of the call, MLB rules clearly state such a scenario is "In Play" and results in an out if caught by a fielder. The article focuses on explaining why the ruling favored the Brewers and discusses the debate surrounding potential rule changes for similar situations.
Written by AI on 2026-10-04, from this article's own text only (the story summary below draws on all the coverage).
See how they differ ↓

AI analysis

Story summary

On October 3, 2026, the Milwaukee Brewers defeated the San Diego Padres 3-2 in Game 1 of their National League Division Series (NLDS) matchup at American Family Field. The game was marked by a bizarre incident where Ty France of the Padres hit what could have been a game-tying home run that struck the roof and landed as an out, preventing it from being ruled fair or foul. Despite this setback, the Padres managed to push Jacob Misiorowski, the Brewers' ace, out after only 4 innings due to their aggressive approach at the plate. William Contreras hit a tie-breaking homer for Milwaukee in the seventh inning, securing the win despite the Padres’ strong comeback efforts.

Written for “Brewers Vs Padres NLDS Openers” on 2026-11-18, grounded in this article and the 9 other(s) covering the same event.

How they differ

4 outlets covered “Brewers Vs Padres NLDS Openers”.

What each outlet says

One AI summary per outlet of its latest article on this story, written from that article alone and checked against it. Open the article for the outlet's own words.

Fox NewsThis outlet4 Oct

In Saturday night's Major League Baseball playoff game between the San Diego Padres and Milwaukee Brewers, controversy erupted during the ninth inning over a disputed home run ruling. Ty France hit a high fly ball that struck the roof support system at American Family Field before falling into play where it was caught for an out. Despite initial confusion among fans and players about the legitimacy of the call, MLB…

No, the San Diego Padres didn't lose because of controversial ninth inning home run ruling (this article)2 articles from Fox News on this story
New York Post4 Oct

In Game 1 of the NLDS between the San Diego Padres and Milwaukee Brewers, Ty France hit a high-velocity fly ball that struck a cable attached to American Family Field’s retractable roof, altering its course and resulting in an out. The unique ground rule at this stadium declares such balls live if they strike the roof above fair territory. Despite the unusual circumstances, the umpires correctly upheld the call…

The insane ballpark rule behind Padres’ brutal NLDS heartbreak →4 articles from New York Post on this story
Toronto Star4 Oct

In the NLDS opener between the Milwaukee Brewers and San Diego Padres, Ty France hit a high-arching flyball in the ninth inning at American Family Field that struck a cable on the stadium’s roof before being caught by Jackson Chourio for the second out. The unusual play, which went against the Padres due to the stadium’s ground rules allowing such balls to remain live if they hit the roof, prevented France from…

Brewers get a big assist from their ballpark roof to beat the Padres 3-2 in NLDS opener →3 articles from Toronto Star on this story
The Guardian4 Oct

In the ninth inning of their playoff game on Saturday, the San Diego Padres lost what could have been a tying home run when Ty France's hit struck a roof cable at Milwaukee's American Family Field. The ball was ruled fair and caught by left fielder Jackson Chourio for an out, despite the Padres' challenge. Brewers manager Pat Murphy joked that legendary broadcaster Bob Uecker might have influenced the play from…

Cable robs Padres of potential home run in bizarre playoff loss to Brewers →

Where they agree and split

The full story: what happened, how it changed, and all 10 articles →

Compared with similar articles

This article reads unscored and hedges 7% of its claims. Each row says how that neighbour differs.
New York Post
Hedges 0 of 33 claims Outlet record 66/100
“The articles describe different games involving the San Diego Padres: one against the Chicago Cubs in a Wild Card Series rematch, and another against the Milwaukee Brewers.”
New York Post
Hedges 3 of 29 claims Outlet record 66/100
Toronto Star
Hedges 3 of 39 claims Outlet record 64/100
Toronto Star
Hedges 2 of 45 claims Outlet record 64/100
“The articles describe different games played on consecutive days between the San Diego Padres and Milwaukee Brewers, not a single specific incident.”
New York Post
Hedges 5 of 17 claims Outlet record 66/100
“The articles discuss different games in the series between San Diego Padres and Milwaukee Brewers; Article A seems to be about Game 2, while Article B is a prediction for Game 3.”
New York Post
Hedges 0 of 14 claims Outlet record 66/100
“The articles describe different games between the Cubs-Padres and Brewers-Padres, with distinct dates and contexts.”
Toronto Star
Hedges 0 of 24 claims Outlet record 64/100
“The articles describe different games; Article A is about the Padres' 8-0 victory over the Cubs in their Wild Card Series opener, while Article B refers to a later game involving the Padres and Brewers with drama surrounding a controversial home run ruling.”
New York Post
Hedges 0 of 18 claims Outlet record 66/100
“The articles describe different games involving the San Diego Padres; ARTICLE A refers to a Game 2 loss against the Cubs with an incident involving a pitcher and bench reaction, while ARTICLE B discusses a game against the Brewers.”
New York Post
Hedges 1 of 10 claims Outlet record 66/100
“The articles describe different games between San Diego Padres and two different teams (Chicago Cubs and Milwaukee Brewers) with distinct outcomes and dates.”

Story

Brewers Vs Padres NLDS Openers
Sports · 10 article(s) covering the same event. Compare every outlet's account →
How this article was measured signals, leaning charts, publisher record, byline, topics and claims

Signals How these are calculated →

Claims extracted
45
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
7%
3 of 45 hedged ("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
not political
takes no side on a contested political question
Publisher signals
67/100
Fox News's corrections and hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
10
Sports
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
Analyzed 2026-10-04 · how these are computed

How this is being covered How these are calculated →

Article leaning vs. publisher reliability
Source leaning vs. consistency

Publisher

Fox News · 8110 article(s) · 15 correction(s) detected
Running correction rate · 15 correction(s)

Who wrote this

Ian Miller
57 article(s) here · 1 carrying a prediction
So will the committee stay true to their word and penalize the Tide for all of their "quality SEC wins" losing over the weekend?
The Tigers and their boosters were willing to commit to resources that Ole Miss either wouldn't or couldn't match.
And just as they so often have, the Trojans defense couldn't get the ball back with the game still in reach.
That's a 60 run positive contribution to the Astros, without which they would never have reached the postseason.
What though, would be the best system for putting teams in order?
But given the widespread discontent and overwhelmingly negative feedback pouring towards the committee, there was some small sliver of hope that the week two poll might address some of the issues.
The smaller field ensured that the best of the best would compete for a title.
This proposal had widespread support among many coaches who will now have greater job security, as well as some conference commissioners who have never actually watched or followed college football.
Well, opinions vary, but a preferable outcome would be a transparent process with clearly communicated metrics and measurements.
Some on the optimistic side believe that the two sides will find a way to come to an agreement before games are canceled.
Also by Ian Miller
Nothing else under this byline is closely related to this article, so these are simply their most recent.
All 57 articles by Ian Miller →

Topics

Brewers Major League Baseball Milwaukee Brewers Padres San Diego Padres

Subjects

France GPE · 5× Padres ORG · 3× Statcast ORG · 3× Brewers ORG · 2× Jackson Chourio PERSON · 2× Jacob Misiorowski PERSON · 1× Major League Baseball ORG · 1× Milwaukee Brewers ORG · 1× Misiorowski PERSON · 1× San Diego Padres ORG · 1×

Narrative

- Tyler O'Neill on April 26 — exit velocity 105.0, launch angle 49 degrees, distance 283 feet, result: fly ball out - Luis Robert Jr. on Aug. 30 — exit velocity 104.9, launch angle 49 degrees, distance 321 feet, result: fly ball out - Luis Robert Jr. on April 21 — exit velocity 104.8, launch angle 49 degrees, distance 323 feet, result: fly ball out - Pete Alonso on Aug. 5 — exit velocity 104.7, launch angle 49 degrees, distance 318 feet, result: fly ball out Expanding the search to 2024 and 2025, there were a number of other balls that met these exact characteristics.
framing: assertive · carried by 1 article(s) · first seen 2026-10-04
This page may contain affiliate links to legal sports betting partners.

Claims (45 extracted, 3 hedged)

If there's one thing the Major League Baseball postseason always delivers, it's drama. asserted
it → be → ?
And Saturday night's game between the San Diego Padres and Milwaukee Brewers certainly had more than its fair share. asserted
game → have → share
The Brewers entered the game and the series as big favorites, thanks in large part to likely NL Cy Young Award winner Jacob Misiorowski starting game one. asserted
Misiorowski → enter → game
Misiorowski has been nearly unhittable this season, with a minuscule 1.80 ERA, just 96 hits allowed all season, and 252 strikeouts in 174.2 innings. asserted
Misiorowski → allow → innings
But the Padres have been baseball's hottest team down the stretch, and were able to force him out after pushing across two runs in just four innings. asserted
Padres → force → innings
This page may contain affiliate links to legal sports betting partners. uncertain
page → contain → partners
If you sign up or place a wager, FOX News may be compensated. uncertain
News → sign → wager
This content was created by a team that works independently from the FOX newsroom. asserted
that → create → newsroom
But the Brewers battled back, tying the game on a Jackson Chourio homer and taking the lead late on another from William Contreras. asserted
Brewers → battle → Contreras
The Padres missed an opportunity in the top of the 8th, but started the 9th with the heart of their lineup facing closer Trevor Megill. asserted
heart → miss → Megill
Dustin Harris singled to lead off the ninth, Manny Machado struck out, and Ty France launched what's now become one of the most controversial fly balls in recent postseason history. asserted
what → single → history
While it looked at first glance like a potential go-ahead home run, or might fly harmlessly foul, France hit the ball so high it banged off the roof support system at American Family Field and fell into the field of play just onto the warning track in left field, where Jackson Chourio caught it for an out. uncertain
Chourio → look → out
Several minutes of discussion followed, with the umpires ruling on the field that it was, in fact, a fair ball and effectively a fly ball out. asserted
it → follow → fact
Many fans, and some of the players, were clearly confused, assuming that a ball hitting the roof would become immediately "dead" and the play restarted. asserted
play → assume → roof
By rule though, there's no question that the umpires made the correct call. asserted
umpires → be → call
Major League Baseball's ground rule page, specifically covering American Family Field, covers this exact situation. asserted
page → cover → situation
If the "Batted ball strikes roof, roof truss, roof cable, or any cabling over fair territory," the rule states, it's considered "In Play." "If caught by fielder," it continues, "batter is out, and runners advance at own risk." That's exactly what was determined on the field, and what the replay review confirmed. asserted
review → bat → what
The ball was in fair territory when it hit the roof, it fell down to the field of play where it was caught by an outfielder, and the hitter is out. asserted
hitter → hit → outfielder
Many fans, obviously most notably Padres fans, are convinced that the ball would have been a home run had it not hit the roof. asserted
it → convince → roof
France himself said as much after the game in the clubhouse. asserted
France → say → clubhouse
"You would think with all the technology we have now we’d be able to make a clear call on that," France said. asserted
France → think → that
We’ve got ball tracking. asserted
We → get → tracking
We’ve got exit velo. asserted
We → get → velo
We’ve got projected distances. asserted
We → get → distances
We have all that stuff. asserted
We → have → stuff
And that's where the second part of the controversy has continued, and even grown. asserted
part → continue → controversy
Had the ball not hit the roof, would it have been a game, and potentially series, changing home run asserted
it → hit → roof
France is right; we do have ball tracking, exit velocity and projected distances, thanks to the league's Statcast operation. asserted
we → have → operation
And those metrics all but confirmed one thing: that was not going to be a home run. asserted
that → confirm → thing
Statcast measured France's fly ball at 105.3mph exit velocity at a whopping 49 degree launch angle. asserted
Statcast → measure → angle
Well, it's hard to know exactly where the ball would have come down if unobstructed, but the shortest dimension is 342 feet directly at the foul pole. asserted
dimension → know → pole
Statcast predicted "expected" batting average, essentially how often balls hit with those exact characteristics become hits, was .050. asserted
balls → predict → characteristics
Balls hit 105.3mph at 49 degrees are outs 99.5% of the time. asserted
hit → hit → time
Thanks to Statcast, we can compare similarly hit baseballs with that exact launch angle and see the results. asserted
we → compare → results
- Tyler O'Neill on April 26 — exit velocity 105.0, launch angle 49 degrees, distance 283 feet, result: fly ball out - Luis Robert Jr. on Aug. 30 — exit velocity 104.9, launch angle 49 degrees, distance 321 feet, result: fly ball out - Luis Robert Jr. on April 21 — exit velocity 104.8, launch angle 49 degrees, distance 323 feet, result: fly ball out - Pete Alonso on Aug. 5 — exit velocity 104.7, launch angle 49 degrees, distance 318 feet, result: fly ball out Expanding the search to 2024 and 2025, there were a number of other balls that met these exact characteristics. asserted
that → expand → characteristics
Of the 15 batted ball events, including 2026, 14 were outs, with one double from Aaron Judge in 2024. asserted
14 → bat → 2024
The furthest a batted ball traveled with those exact numbers was 337 feet, a fly ball from Cody Bellinger in April 2025. asserted
ball → bat → April
But with the exact measurements available to us, not a single ball hit with that velocity and launch angle traveled far enough to cover the left field wall at American Family Field, even if it were directly down the line. asserted
it → hit → line
France, though, was convinced it was "going out. asserted
it → convince → ?
"I guess the biggest question was whether it was going to stay fair or foul," he said. asserted
it → guess → ?
…and 5 more, not listed.
Give feedback · no sign-in needed

No sign-in needed for now. Your note is sent without a name, so it cannot be answered.

History Support