We've had two weeks of the College Football Playoff selection committee's top-25 poll, and two weeks of well-deserved controversy over their rankings.
asserted
We → have → rankings
And the controversy extends well past just the positions each team sits, to the reasoning behind it.
asserted
team → extend → it
Both weeks have had one consistent theme: the SEC has received an enormous, and undeserved, boost for their teams.
asserted
SEC → have → teams
Losses don't count for as much in the SEC, while every win is assumed to be a "quality" one.
asserted
win → count → SEC
Injuries are given more deference, and preseason expectations are still treated as meaningful.
asserted
expectations → give → deference
All while teams in other conferences are punished for ... not playing.
asserted
teams → punish → conferences
Like the Indiana Hoosiers, who dropped five spots in the rankings from No. 4 to No. 9 while on a bye week.
asserted
who → drop → week
Head coach Curt Cignetti, the defending national champion, brought up how many other coaches are thinking and feeling about the poll in a Monday press conference.
asserted
coaches → defend → conference
Roasting the selection committee for the disparate treatment and how they handle losses and wins dependent on brand names, stadiums, and marketing efforts, not team quality.
asserted
they → roast → names
"You get tired of the narrative sometimes," Cignetti said.
asserted
Cignetti → get → narrative
"A quality win because Joe Smith was playing at the time.
asserted
Smith → play → time
They ain’t won a game since, but it was a quality win back then.
asserted
it → win → game
I guess bad losses don’t count.
asserted
losses → guess → ?
Look, it’s all going to play out on the field.
asserted
it → look → field
It’s good for entertainment.
asserted
It → ’ → entertainment
I’m sure this’ll get a lot of nice hits and play.
asserted
this → ’m → hits
"But our guys understand that it’ll play out on the field.
asserted
it → understand → field
The good thing about it is, I think it feeds into our motivation and our chip.
asserted
it → think → motivation
That’s why I’m not afraid to keep it alive.
asserted
I → ’ → it
And you know what?
asserted
you → know → what
I’m 65 years old and I really don’t give a s--t."
asserted
I → ’m → s
How the committee handled Cignetti's Indiana team is one thing.
asserted
handled → handle → team
How they justify it is another.
asserted
justify → justify → it
And that justification is why the committee faces a major test of their legitimacy and remaining shreds of credibility.
asserted
committee → face → credibility
During committee chair Hunter Yurachek's post-release interview, he "explained" why the Hoosiers fell five spots without playing.
asserted
Hoosiers → explain → interview
"Indiana was probably a victim of having a bye week at the wrong time with seven games between Top 25 teams," he said.
asserted
he → have → teams
"The committee is really impressed with what UCLA, Texas, and Notre Dame did as well as Alabama and LSU.
asserted
UCLA → impress → what
"
"Every team that Indiana had played to date in the Big Ten all lost and that affected their strength of schedule rank and the committee's review of Indiana," he continued.
asserted
he → play → Indiana
They've won games because of their defense and not their offense."
asserted
They → win → defense
As ridiculous as it is to knock a team for having an elite defense, that wasn't the worst of it.
asserted
that → knock → it
This is: "every team that Indiana had played to date in the Big Ten all lost and that affected their strength of schedule rank."
asserted
that → play → rank
First, we have no idea how the committee evaluates the strength of schedule, because there is no transparency around what metrics they use, or even if they just make it up as they go and don't use any.
asserted
they → have → any
But the problem is that Yurachek made it clear that Indiana's opponents all losing, hurt their strength of schedule in the eyes of the committee.
asserted
losing → make → committee
Well, we've got good news for them, because they have an opportunity to demonstrate their consistency and lack of favoritism this week.
asserted
they → get → favoritism
Let's take a quick look at how Alabama's prior SEC wins did this week:
asserted
wins → let → look
- Kentucky, lost 21-14 at home to Florida
- Mississippi State, lost 41-9 at home to Auburn
- LSU, lost 22-21 at home to Texas
- South Carolina, lost 34-6 at Arkansas
- Texas A&M, 22-7 at home to Tennessee
asserted
LSU → lose → Tennessee
All five of Alabama's non-Vanderbilt wins lost on Saturday, four of them at home in the Awe-Inspiring Cathedral, which is an SEC stadium.
asserted
which → lose → Cathedral
Those five teams are now a combined 27-23, and eight of those wins came against Kent State, Towson, Louisiana-Monroe, Youngstown State, Louisiana Tech, McNeese State, Missouri State and The Citadel.
asserted
eight → combine → State
So will the committee stay true to their word and penalize the Tide for all of their "quality SEC wins" losing over the weekend?
asserted
committee → stay → weekend
Then there's an argument to be made that Alabama deserves to move down because their win over Vanderbilt might have been less impressive than Indiana sitting at home.
uncertain
Indiana → be → home
…and 22 more, not listed.