Leo Garcia Venegas, an American citizen and construction worker, has been arrested and detained by federal immigration officers, not once, not twice, but three times since the spring of 2025, despite carrying and presenting an Alabama REAL ID each time.
asserted
Venegas → arrest → ID
A federal judge ruled on Wednesday that his lawsuit against the Trump administration for violating his Fourth Amendment rights can move forward.
asserted
lawsuit → rule → rights
Venegas was working early on May 21, 2025, laying the foundation for a new home in Foley, Alabama, southeast of Mobile, when he saw "five armed men in camouflage" jump the property line fence and run toward the construction workers, according to his complaint filed in the Southern District of Alabama.
uncertain
men → work → Alabama
Venegas quickly began recording on his phone after one of the officers physically assaulted his brother, another worker at the construction site.
asserted
one → begin → site
Video of the incident shows another officer approach Venegas.
asserted
officer → show → Venegas
"Yes, immigration," the masked officer says.
asserted
officer → say → ?
Venegas sidesteps the man, trying to get clear footage of his brother's ongoing arrest.
asserted
Venegas → sidestep → arrest
"You're making this more complicated than you want to," the officer says while following Venegas.
asserted
officer → make → Venegas
Venegas exclaims as the officer grabs him by the arm and tries to force him to the ground.
asserted
officer → exclaim → ground
"I'll show you my papers now!
asserted
I → show → papers
I'm a citizen!" pleads Venegas.
asserted
Venegas → plead → ?
Additional officers run over to assist in the tackle.
asserted
officers → run → tackle
"Get on the fucking ground now!" one yells, and Venegas falls to the ground.
asserted
Venegas → get → ground
While pinned to the ground by three officers, one of the men grabbed Venegas' wallet out of his back pocket, according to the lawsuit.
uncertain
one → pin → lawsuit
But despite carrying his valid REAL ID–compliant driver's license—which requires proof of citizenship or lawful presence to be issued—the officers refused to accept the ID as proof that he was in the country legally.
asserted
he → carry → country
Instead, the officers accused Venegas of having a fake ID and placed him in handcuffs.
asserted
officers → accuse → handcuffs
After pleading with officers to check his Social Security number for over an hour in the hot Alabama sun, "one of the officers finally relented, made a phone call, and confirmed that [Venegas'] Social Security Number was valid," writes the complaint.
asserted
complaint → plead → call
Venegas was released with no charges.
asserted
Venegas → release → charges
But just three weeks later, it happened again.
asserted
it → happen → ?
While working alone inside a "partially constructed home," armed, masked federal officers entered the private property without permission and detained Venegas.
asserted
officers → work → Venegas
And for the second time, according to the complaint, the officers told Venegas that his REAL ID could be fake and therefore was not enough to prove his citizenship or legal status.
uncertain
ID → accord → citizenship
Venegas was eventually released after officers confirmed, again, that he was a citizen.
asserted
he → release → ?
Represented by the Institute for Justice (I.J.), a nonprofit law firm, Venegas filed suit in September 2025, arguing the two warrantless detentions lacked probable cause and were instead based only on his ethnicity.
asserted
detentions → represent → ethnicity
In response, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has defended the immigration officers' actions, arguing that Americans have no reasonable expectation of privacy while working on privately owned construction sites and that REAL IDs can't be trusted to prove U.S. citizenship.
asserted
IDs → defend → citizenship
But as his case works its way through the courts, Venegas has been forced to live with the reality of the Trump administration's immigration policies.
asserted
Venegas → work → policies
And on May 2, almost one year after his initial immigration arrest, he was detained for a third time.
uncertain
he → detain → time
Without asking any questions or issuing any lawful commands, the agents confronted Venegas after parking in front of his own home, pulled him from his car, tackled him to the ground, and placed him in handcuffs, according to his declaration following the incident.
uncertain
agents → ask → incident
And, once again, officers refused to let Venegas go after he presented his REAL ID.
asserted
he → refuse → ID
However, Venegas' luck may be turning.
uncertain
luck → turn → ?
According to an I.J. press release on September 3, a federal judge rejected the Trump administration's attempt to dismiss the case.
uncertain
judge → accord → case
In what IJ senior attorney Jared McClain called "an important first step," Venegas' case is moving forward.
asserted
case → call → what
"We know the [DHS] thinks it can raid construction sites without a warrant, round up all the workers, and refuse to credit their government-issued IDs," McClain continued.
asserted
McClain → know → IDs
"Now we'll have the chance to prove these violations of the Fourth Amendment."
asserted
we → have → Amendment
